5 ms·
Can we please have a higher standard of truth than a Reddit comment, especially one that doesn't cite any sources? I am not saying the linked comment is wrong
by mulmen 10y ago
Can we please have a higher standard of truth than a Reddit comment, especially one that doesn't cite any sources? I am not saying the linked comment is wrong but why should I believe it over anything else?
- rimantas 10y agoActually reddit often has better comments and discussion in general compared to HN. Alas.
- bigbugbag 10y agoTry using common sense here. It is self-evident that water had a long history of being drank before beer came to be, that you can't replace drinking water by drinking beer, and lastly that water was safer to drink before we started putting shit in it.
- mulmen 10y agoYour invocation of common sense is insulting. What part of drinking water makes it self-evident that it was drank before beer? Additionally, how does it establish a long history? You seem to cite your entire comment as a source for the extraordinary claim that drinking water has no substitute and that adding things to water only makes it worse. Are you saying that any additive to drinking water is harmful?
- JimDabell 10y ago> What part of drinking water makes it self-evident that it was drank before beer? You're taking skepticism to absurd levels. Water is naturally occurring. Beer is not.
- andrepd 10y agoThe linked article is pop-history clickbait. The comment I linked is not a peer review article, granted, but it's a statement by a verified accredited specialist in History of Alcohol. Since I don't have time or expertise to do in depth research, I think I'll take this comment. Besides, most of the comments in this thread are positing wild guesses and making spurious claims. If you didn't complain about the article or those comments you have no right to complain about my link not being a high standard of truth :^)
- mulmen 10y agoI do not accept subreddits as a source of anything beyond Reddit commentary itself. They are opinion pieces unless they include sources. The quality of comments in this thread are entirely irrelevant to the comment you linked. I apply the same standard to all internet comments. If you wish to deflect that is on you but I stand by my standard of truth.
- BigJono 10y agoA comment by a flaired user in /r/AskHistorians is a very different thing to a "Reddit comment".
- fsloth 10y agoYes, but it's just a reddit comment none the less with no way to backtrack to peer reviewed work.
- jetru 10y agoWe've all learnt that "peer reviewed work" is code for "accept other peoples papers so they will accept ours" and has nothing to do with confirming the finding.
- fsloth 10y agoDon't throw the baby away with the bathwater. Peer reviewed publications offers the only venue for accountable reporting on complex subjects. By definition this mean "accountability to peers" and is the only mechanism which outsiders can use to gauge the credibility of claims. Like all things humans do that is not pure maths, it's not perfect but the best we have.
- mulmen 10y agoAre you implying that we should just accept peer reviewed work and Reddit comments as equally valid? I don't disagree with you, peer-review is no guarantee of proof but I assign more weight to it than an upvote. Especially if I can read the work myself and investigate further sources.
- oxide 10y agoI think his point is the fact that /r/AskHistorians comments are usually sourced properly and are strictly moderated.
- mulmen 10y agoBut this one isn't so it doesn't get the benefit of the doubt based on higher quality peers. /r/AskHistorians may be a fine place to discuss history but without sources the comments can be treated as nothing more than opinion.
- JimDabell 10y ago> a Reddit comment, especially one that doesn't cite any sources? That Reddit comment is literally saying "[the claim that beer was safer than water] cannot be substantiated with primary sources". You're complaining that somebody isn't citing sources when all they are saying is that there is a lack of evidence that the claim is true. You're placing the burden of proof in the wrong place.
- lostboys67 10y agothe fact that teetotal sailors where considered a higher insurance risk which can be backed up with sources
- mulmen 10y agoThe GP claim is that "beer as a safe alternative to water" is likely a myth. In order to back this up they linked to a comment that does nothing to prove this claim. Sure, the Reddit comment says there is no primary source evidence to back up the claim that beer was used as a safe alternative to water but that does not make it a source to claim that beer was not used as a safe alternative to water. Furthermore, the Reddit post makes unsubstantiated claims, such as "failing many logic tests" without naming the logic tests themselves. The entire second paragraph is predicated on the assumption that homesteads used only clean water sources without polluting them. How did they handle waste? Did they know how far from water sources to deposit their waste? The comment doesn't say. Indeed the burden of proof is on the accuser and in this case the GP is the accuser. Reddit comments do not meet my standard for proof.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoI think what we're all trying to say is, could you provide any evidence for the "beer as a safe alternative to water" theory? If we place the burden of proof on the skeptical "accuser", that could redeem almost any theory about history, including the more colorful ones involving aliens.
- mulmen 10y ago