6 ms·
The "beer as a safe alternative to water" is likely a myth. See https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1yts0v/comment/cfnrg32 https://www.reddit.com/r/
by andrepd 10y ago
The "beer as a safe alternative to water" is likely a myth. See https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1yts0v/comment/cfnrg32 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1yts0v/comme...
- mc32 10y agoIt's likely a myth with regard to the middle ages, but what about ancient times --ie Roman, Greek, Egyptian, etc? These places had urban centers.
- bigbugbag 10y agoIf they had urban centers, then they had civilization already debunking the claim.
- peterwwillis 10y agoAncient (specifically Roman) civilizations had fantastic systems to transport water and even developed indoor plumbing. They didn't need to augment their water quality with wine. Wine was simply made ubiquitous due to their civilization determining that it should be enjoyed by everyone. Of course there are stories of soldiers augmenting pond water with wine, but this could have been as much to make it more palatable as preventing oneself from getting sick. Here's a paper that talks about Ancient thoughts on water: https://issuu.com/eajournal/docs/articulo_-_van_tillburg_-_drinking_ https://issuu.com/eajournal/docs/articulo_-_van_tillburg_-_d... Basically, humans have for a really freaking long time been able to determine whether water is basically more or less safe to drink, and have not really worried about it more than any other thing (and certainly not drank beer or wine because they feared for the quality of the water)
- mirimir 10y agoA counterexample is cholera. http://www.ph.ucla.edu/epi/snow/choleratheories.html http://www.ph.ucla.edu/epi/snow/choleratheories.html
- jahewson 10y agoIs it? I don't see how 19th century cholera outbreaks have anything to do with ancient civilisations.
- mirimir 10y agoBecause cholera existed before the 19th century, and people didn't understand that contaminated water was the cause?
- bigbugbag 10y agoCholera only existed in the old world and is a byproduct of animal domestication and urbanization[1]. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk
- peterwwillis 10y agoSo as late as the 19th century, people were just drinking regular water, believing there was nothing wrong with it. (This, plus the fountains and wells that have existed since antiquity as public places to both drink water and wash your hands... eww)
- mulmen 10y agoCan we please have a higher standard of truth than a Reddit comment, especially one that doesn't cite any sources? I am not saying the linked comment is wrong but why should I believe it over anything else?
- rimantas 10y agoActually reddit often has better comments and discussion in general compared to HN. Alas.
- bigbugbag 10y agoTry using common sense here. It is self-evident that water had a long history of being drank before beer came to be, that you can't replace drinking water by drinking beer, and lastly that water was safer to drink before we started putting shit in it.
- mulmen 10y agoYour invocation of common sense is insulting. What part of drinking water makes it self-evident that it was drank before beer? Additionally, how does it establish a long history? You seem to cite your entire comment as a source for the extraordinary claim that drinking water has no substitute and that adding things to water only makes it worse. Are you saying that any additive to drinking water is harmful?
- JimDabell 10y ago> What part of drinking water makes it self-evident that it was drank before beer? You're taking skepticism to absurd levels. Water is naturally occurring. Beer is not.
- andrepd 10y agoThe linked article is pop-history clickbait. The comment I linked is not a peer review article, granted, but it's a statement by a verified accredited specialist in History of Alcohol. Since I don't have time or expertise to do in depth research, I think I'll take this comment. Besides, most of the comments in this thread are positing wild guesses and making spurious claims. If you didn't complain about the article or those comments you have no right to complain about my link not being a high standard of truth :^)
- Baeocystin 10y agoLack of clean water is a huge issue today, much less in historic times before germ theory. Anyone who says otherwise is stunningly ignorant. That they so blithely claim otherwise tells me that they don't know what they're talking about. http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/diseases-risks/en/ http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/diseases-risks/en...