5 ms·
I really wish they would quit promulgating this because it's actually counterproductive: "women face continued pay disparity" Seeing this statement tells me i
by bsder 10y ago
I really wish they would quit promulgating this because it's actually counterproductive:
"women face continued pay disparity"
Seeing this statement tells me immediately that the author is grinding an ax.
In some fields of engineering (EE, for example), women actually get paid more (104% last I checked). And, when you control for experience, time off for family, etc., pay disparities in most tech fields almost disappear.
Complaining about discrimination or harassment? Sure, go for it. Lack of child care and having undue burden with family health issues? The stats back you up.
However, attempting to promulgate something which is not true hurts the overall movement when there is so much that is true and needs to be fixed.
- tomlock 10y ago>pay disparities in most tech fields almost disappear. So what you're saying is there are pay disparities in most tech fields. Aka, women face continued pay disparity.
- 59nadir 10y agoIt's a hard sell to say someone "faces" something when they're on the better end of it.
- tomlock 10y ago>In some fields of engineering (EE, for example), women actually get paid more (104% last I checked). As you can see, you disagree with the commenter I was responding to. They think women only get paid more in "some" fields, not most. The original comment is both inconsistent with itself, and your comment.
- throwaway91111 10y agoExcept—women DO face continued pay disparity. Just because a hand-picked statistic deviates from this norm doesn't mean it's not true.
- Harimwakairi 10y agoDo you have citations for the stats you claim? That's not a dig, btw; I'd honestly like to see them.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoI believe this is the paper by Prof. Claudia Golden that is getting the publicity http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/goldin/files/goldin_aeapress_2014_1.pdf http://scholar.harvard.edu/files/goldin/files/goldin_aeapres... I think she's said that once all factors are accounted for there is still a 6-7% pay gap that they can't yet account for.
- someperson53 10y ago"when you control for experience, time off for family, etc., pay disparities in most tech fields almost disappears" That's a big "etc" to throw around - do you mind elaborating? What else beyond time off for family could possibly be in this list to the degree that pay disparities disappear?
- WillPostForFood 10y agoAnother thing in the "etc" bucket is the type of degree possessed. Men are currently more likely to have a more technical degree (EE, mathematics) which tend to get higher pay. The Payscale study cited in an earlier comment, for example, only controls for education level, not degree.
- fishtoaster 10y agoI'd be curious where you got that 104% number. Here's a source saying woman make 1-6% less in tech[0]. Here's one saying ~28%[1] among programmers. Based on my casual research, the correct answer to "what's the gender pay gap" is to sidetrack into a half-hour discussion on what you're controlling for and whether it's appropriate to control for that. For example, professions where flexible schedules are rare see the wage gap grow for women between their 20s and 30s (compared to professions where flexible schedules are more common). This is likely because that's around the age where people have children and women are expected to handle a disproportionate measure of childrearing duties. Is that something you try to control for? If you're looking for direct, hiring-manager-discriminating-against-you sexism, then yes, you control for it. If you're looking for the wide variety of subtle ways women are discriminated against, you don't. From what I've found, if you're looking for the sort of direct sexism of hiring managers paying less to _exactly_ the same person for _exactly_ the same work, you come out with a 3-10% wage gap. If, on the other hand, you're looking for the wide variety of systematic ways women are prevented from getting equal pay, you get 10-30%. Some of those ways can be addressed at the individual level, some at the company level, and some at the societal level. [0] http://www.payscale.com/data-packages/gender-pay-gap/women-in-tech http://www.payscale.com/data-packages/gender-pay-gap/women-i... [1] http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-0323-pay-gap-20160323-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-0323-pay...
- yxhuvud 10y agoAnd why should you control for time off for family? Except for the really early time after birth, both parents can do that. Is it the fault of the employer? Well, perhaps they could be more persuasive in motivating the women to work and more accepting of men taking days off to care for their sick children. EDIT: Use similar term for both genders.
- sriracha23 10y agoMotivating "the girls" to work? That language alone -- "girls" versus "men" -- suggests a diminutive, dismissive way of thinking about women.
- yxhuvud 10y agoThank you, that was a very good point and definitely not intended. I updated my post to reflect it.
- KirinDave 10y ago> And, when you control for experience, time off for family, etc., pay disparities in most tech fields almost disappear. Okay, so spoiler alert, I'm grinding an axe right now. It's completely ridiculous to imply that analysts are not normalizing for hours worked. That's one of the most basic things they do, and you really should provide proof in the form of a study that both published its methodology and has been done in the last 5 years that didn't account for this, setting aside that one clickbait publicity stunt from Glassdoor. People keep citing other studies that "don't do this" and it's not true, or point to the national average and say that extends to knowledge work and that's absurd. "The pay gap" is not simply lockstep salary progression. It was just the most obviously unfair and lowest-hanging fruit. That's only the start of it. The fact that women are often passed over for promotion because industries frown on maternity leave, the fact that harassment leaves women with fewer mentorship opportunities, the fact that many environments treat interviews like hazing, all these things add up to create aforementioned gap. Your quote up at the top is the root of the pay gap. It's your belief that someone who works a reasonable sum of hours but then goes to have a child should be paid less. You believe that someone who takes time off for a reasonable work-life balance or a family emergency should be paid less. That attitude is bad for everyone, but it's especially bad for women in much of western society's current form. And yes, there are still places where women DO get paid less for the same work. That is not done yet. And until it's so rare that it's unheard of, we're going to keep pointing it out.
- gshulegaard 10y agoYou can find a more thoughtful post of mine further down the conversation, but I think there are less controls than you would suspect: https://youtu.be/QcDrE5YvqTs https://youtu.be/QcDrE5YvqTs In fact, according to a different video also by Christina Hoff Sommers the 77 cents on the dollar pay gap oft cited is no more than a blanket calculation using Census data.[1] This is seemingly confirmed by the Washington Post.[2] In fact, the Washington Post seems to indicate that the 77 cent figure doesn't correct even for weekly/hourly wage metrics much less hours worked. As a whole I think you might find the Christina Hoff Sommers videos interesting to watch. Although they are "classical liberal"/libertarian leaning right (considering the American Enterprise Institute is a conservative think-tank I am not too surprised by this). But I also wanted to ask some things about your points: > the fact that many environments treat interviews like hazing > someone who works a reasonable sum of hours but then goes to have a child should be paid less > someone who takes time off for a reasonable work-life balance or a family emergency should be paid less These aren't really gender specific so I am struggling to see how they would contribute to a gender pay gap. Perhaps you could elaborate? > The fact that women are often passed over for promotion because industries frown on maternity leave > the fact that harassment leaves women with fewer mentorship opportunities I would be interested to read any sources you have that could give me some insight into these dynamics. These are points I haven't read about before and I wasn't even aware they have been examined to any degree. Personally I tend to be more Libertarian and am very pro-"choice". I don't think being skeptical of the dubious statistics surrounding the gender pay gap makes someone misogynistic or anti-feminist...so I would encourage you to try and keep an open mind before labeling someone so just because they express reservations about the wage gap and the statistics behind it. [1] https://youtu.be/1oqyrflOQFc https://youtu.be/1oqyrflOQFc [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2014/04/09/president-obamas-persistent-77-cent-claim-on-the-wage-gap-gets-a-new-pinocchio-rating/?utm_term=.37c981dec350 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2014/04/...