4 ms·
I don't think the title's quite accurate. It sounds like they had no trouble building a connectome for the chip, they just couldn't then reverse engineer the ch
by taneq 10y ago
I don't think the title's quite accurate. It sounds like they had no trouble building a connectome for the chip, they just couldn't then reverse engineer the chip's functionality by applying standard neuroscience techniques to said connectome while it ran in a simulator.
It's basically saying that even IF we had a full connectome of the brain that we could run in a simulator (and presumably produce a simulated personality) that we'd be no closer to actually understanding how the damn thing works.
- ivraatiems 10y agoUnfortunately, producing a working simulation of the brain doesn't mean the simulated brain would actually... work. Humans aren't created full form with personality and behavior ready to go, they learn over years. A brain in a vacuum would have none of that input.
- andai 10y agoIf you wish to make a brain from scratch, you must first invent the universe.
- ccrush 10y agoI think there are a few instances of medical science bringing back persons from comas that may help with identifying what would happen to a fully formed brain that was completely shut down for a decent period of time. Presumably, reproducing the physical structure of such a brain and giving it similar inputs would lead to an experimentally similar result. The question I would like to see answered is what happens if we do this to someone with a grown brain and wake them up in a simulation of a space ship that traveled to a far away planet. Again presumably, the person would need nutrition and care and education for some time, but then would they be able to carry out significant advances on behalf of humanity. Would they even want to? What if they feel betrayed by their fate and creator? Then again, who doesn't? Someone write a book about this.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThat's not the criticism he's making. He's saying to get to a functional adult brain you must have a few cells that work together, then a fetus brain, then a baby brain, then an infant brain, then a toddler brain, etc all the way to an adult brain and all the care and learning needed in those stages to make it all work. You need the morphology and structures that happen in nature to get the structures and functionality needed to properly simulate a brain. We simply don't know about enough about learning, development, brains, and consciousness to just plug into a simulated adult brain and make it all work. We can only follow the path nature has laid out. I'm sure you can skip some parts like fetal stages, but we develop language at a very specific range of ages using specific techniques. We can't skip the language acquisition stage and then expect our simulated brain to magically know language. We can't skip the angry "me" stage of a toddler and expect the mind to have self-assertiveness. We can't skip the sexual and social awakening stage of teenhood and expect the mind to understand complex social concepts and sexuality, etc, etc. The only scenario I can imagine out of this problem is a per neuron copy of a working brain on the cellular level. I imagine this isn't, or won't ever be, in the cards for practical reasons. Or if you could someone divine the algorithms that create consciousness, assuming this is even possible on a transistor based machine, then that would also be a work-around. Right now we can't do either, so following nature's approach is the probably the sanest way forward. I wouldnt be surprised if the first AI ends up being more a biological 'computer' than anything having to do with x86 instruction sets and transistors, but that's just a guess on my part.
- taneq 10y agoIf it doesn't actually work then it's not a working simulation, innit? Less flippantly, I've never heard a credible argument why a working simulation of an actual sampled human brain, with appropriate sensory inputs, would not function just as that human did. (Note that the magic is in the phrase 'working simulation' - this may require more than just a connectome depending on how much crazy molecular-level processing actually takes place inside real neurons, but assuming this is possible...) There was a news article a couple of days ago about some company in Japan "simulating a human brain" which disappointingly was actually just them simulating a randomly connected neural net with a similar number of neurons. That's not a 'simulated human brain', any more than a skip bin full of transistors is a 'simulated CPU'.
- SapphireSun 10y ago"Can a Neuroscientist Understand a Microprocessor?" argues several points (and is quite an enjoyable read!): 1. Current analytic approaches don't reveal much insight. 2. The authors advocate for using computer architectures as a synthetic model system for developing new analytic techniques. 3. They aren't arguing that the connectome is useless, in fact they needed the connectome to even begin their analysis. I think the Wired title is a little overblown. I work in a connectomics lab (software, I'm not a scientist yet so take what I say with a grain of salt), and we've been having enjoyable debates about the paper. It's hardly a "war". What's kind of interesting about the field of connectomics is that the engineering challenges have been massive enough that it's been hard for many labs to do science with their datasets until recently. Several papers have come out (e.g. a fly visual circuit, two dual mouse visual circuits, a few others), but they generally are findings on relatively small volumes. Thanks to a big grant that created a multi-lab consortium, we are getting closer to doing science with a big volume. We're one year into a five year process which will result in a petabyte size open dataset for the world to use. Because so few datasets have been adequately reconstructed, and most labs have been obsessed with the reconstruction process, I think in the future, as we do more science, we'll discover better ways to glean insight from the neuroanatomy and physiology traces. It's a new field, so I don't think it's unreasonable to expect that there are new methods to learn. I'm happy to talk about what goes into the reconstruction process. :)
- neuromantik8086 10y agoOut of curiosity, what imaging modality(or modalities) are you using? From your remark it appears that you're working at a very fine level and I'm unfamiliar with the techniques used at the scale (although I have heard mumblings about optogenetics from time to time).
- SapphireSun 10y agoMy lab is one of the reconstruction specialists. We're using electron microscopy (as referenced in the Wired article) to map the ultrastructure of the tissues. I've seen datasets with XY plane (the EM scanning plane) voxels as small as 5nm x 5nm and Z resolution as small as 23nm (though not on the same datasets). Other labs at different phases of the pipeline are working with various kinds of physiological indicators including taking movies of GCaMP (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GCaMP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GCaMP) (a calcium activity indicator) expressing neurons under various behavioral conditions. A glut of calcium ions provide evidence for recent firing of a neuron as calcium is involved in triggering the release of neurotransmitters. If you're interested in methods, here's a paper describing a dataset we focused pretty heavily on (that's not related to the consortium dataset, but paved the way with developing techniques): Briggman, et al. "Wiring specificity in the direction-selectivity circuit of the retina" (http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v471/n7337/full/nature09818.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v471/n7337/full/nature0...) We later did some science with it ;) JS Kim, et al. "Space–time wiring specificity supports direction selectivity in the retina" http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v509/n7500/full/nature13240.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v509/n7500/full/nature1... The pipeline has evolved considerably since those papers came out. We're living in exciting times. :)