3 ms·
By giving them healthcare? There aren't actually a large number of illegal immigrants sitting around contributing nothing to the CA economy.
by amluto 10y ago
By giving them healthcare? There aren't actually a large number of illegal immigrants sitting around contributing nothing to the CA economy.
- mahyarm 10y agoA lot of them even pay taxes with stolen SSNs!
- ThomPete 10y agoits not that easy. Once you have a single payer system suddenly you need to follow a budget. You now have to put limits on how many can be treated, for what, what kind of treatments and machines you have budgets for. Thats the thing with healtcare you can never spent enough on it and that alone will affect the willingness to pay for others.
- FT_intern 10y agoI did a quick search and an estimated 11 million illegal immigrants pay an estimated $11.6 billion in taxes, so $1,000 per person. It's a huge net loss. Not to mention the fallout from stolen SSNs and creating demand for stolen SSNs
- amluto 10y agoYou're making an incorrect assumption that taxes paid are proportional to GDP contribution. Do you really think that, for example, low-paid migrant farm workers contribute correspondingly little to economic output? They contribute hugely to farm output! As an extreme example, unpaid workes (slaves in places and times with slavery, interns, etc) still contribute to their employers' output. The right thing to do isn't to reduce their rights and benefits to be commensurate with their nonexistent salaries; instead, their rights and benefits (and hence taxes) should be increased to be (at least) commensurate with their value to the economy. The stolen SSN issue is a bizarre strawman. There's a trivial solution: give them real SSNs.
- some-guy 10y agoWhen I worked a minimum wage job after high school full time I paid zero in taxes, and I'm a citizen.
- DrScump 10y agoWe're not counting working illegally, "under the table". Even (legal) minimum wage workers pay full FICA and Medicare tax.