4 ms·
Celsius is equally arbitrary to Fahrenheit. No, Martians measure in Nano Yocto Planck Degrees above Absolute Zero, I hereby dub that unit the Plancktigrade.
by ars 10y ago
Celsius is equally arbitrary to Fahrenheit.
No, Martians measure in Nano Yocto Planck Degrees above Absolute Zero, I hereby dub that unit the Plancktigrade.
- lazyant 10y agoarbitrary yes, equally, no.
- astrodust 10y agoCelsius at least has a family of units that mesh with it precisely. To heat one cubic centimetre of water up 1°C takes 1 Joule. It also essentially weighs 1 gram at normal temperatures. How many BTUs does it take to heat up one cubic foot of water by one degree Fahrenheit?
- posterboy 10y agoI thought Kelvin would be the appropriate unit for temperature differences, deg. Celsius be only used for absolute values.
- freeone3000 10y agoIt takes one BTU to heat one pound of water, one pint, one degree Fahrenheit. The units may be arbitrary, but they still line up.
- david-given 10y agoIs that a US or a UK pint?
- astrodust 10y agoYeah, but a pound of water is not a cubic foot. A pint has nothing to do with inches.
- ars 10y agoThat has nothing to do with temperature. You can keep metric and use Fahrenheit with very little change. And you got your units wrong anyway: "To heat one cubic centimetre of water up 1°C takes 1 Joule" - you mean 1 calorie, not 1 Joule. Change Celsius to Fahrenheit and only calorie changes, and since it's anyway not part of SI it makes little difference. Joule is the main energy unit, and it's not tied to Celsius at all. I totally get the arguments for metric - except for temperature. For temperature Fahrenheit is the better scale. Look here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_System_of_Units#/media/File:SI_base_unit.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_System_of_Units#... And notice how Kelvin stands alone - it's not tied to any other unit. It can be replaced with almost no impact.
- averagewall 10y agoA difference in temperature has the same numerical value in both degrees C and K. Often differences in temperature are all we're interested in so C is often interchangeable with K. If you use Fahrenheit, then you lose that easy relationship unless you also use Rankine for absolute temperature. But nobody, not even Americans, has even heard of Rankine so it would be a far bigger challenge to get anyone to use that than just Fahrenheit alone. Perhaps an even more elegant unit for temperature would be thermal energy per degree of freedom per particle, which would be joules in SI. I'm not sure if that's really correct tho.
- ars 10y ago> A difference in temperature has the same numerical value in both degrees C and K. I know, I used them basically interchangeably in my post. > unless you also use Rankine If people used Fahrenheit more often they would use Rankine more often as well (and yes, I was aware of it before this discussion). > which would be joules in SI Joules is a unit of energy, not temperature. You need to multiply by entropy to get temperature. It would be one thing if the unit for temperature was based on the SI units, fine. But it's not - it's completely arbitrary, and since that is the case you might as well use the more usable Fahrenheit. If I were doing it I would redefine it such that 1 joule of energy applied to 1 gram of water = 1 new-degree. (Right now it's 4.2 joules.) That would make the temperature scale less coarse, which is good. Then make absolute zero -1000 new-degrees.
- protomyth 10y agoIf we are talking about Mars, then the colony might not like the Earth-centric origin[1] of the definition of meter, but be ok with human centric foot. 1). The original definition of meter was based on the size of the Earth.
- kbenson 10y agoI'm pretty sure it's supposed to be pirate and/or ninja related[1], so you're missing a great opportunity to name it pirate-plancks. 1: http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pirate%20ninja http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=pirate%20ninj...