4 ms·
"Gray area"? Like the "gray area" when my high school went from cinder track to all-weather, and my mile times dropped dramatically? Or how an Olympic-quality t
by mikestew 10y ago
"Gray area"? Like the "gray area" when my high school went from cinder track to all-weather, and my mile times dropped dramatically? Or how an Olympic-quality track is noticeably better (with correspondingly better times) than my old high school's track? Modern shoes that are more cushioned, allowing more training without injury? Or the Adidas shoes from a few years ago (Boost, I believe?) with their energy-returning midsole?
Look, it'd be one thing to have little batteries and motors in the things. But these just take the energy that I've already expended and returns a bit more of it than my old shoes. But I've still got to do the work. And, hell, they're only $250 in a world of $120 race shoes, so I don't consider them to be outlandishly out of reach. Were I still obsessively racing, I'd buy a pair. And were I beaten by someone that has a pair, even if I didn't, I wouldn't have a problem with it.
So it boils down to this: how inefficient does my equipment have to be in order to follow the rules? Put a number on it, manufacturers can build to it, boom, sorted.
- rhcom2 10y ago> So it boils down to this: how inefficient does my equipment have to be in order to follow the rules? Put a number on it, manufacturers can build to it, boom, sorted. I believe this is exactly what they do in car racing with restrictor plates.
- mikestew 10y agoHaving grown up around Indianapolis, that was my inspiration for writing it. Which is why I get wrapped around the axle about this stuff when it comes to physical sports. Racing cars could be much faster, but we don't want drivers plowing themselves into the Turn 3 wall at 300mph at the Indy oval, so restrictions are carefully defined. Creating testing rigs, define sports shoes to only return 57.3% of energy on that rig. Define full-body swim suits to have a drag coefficient of 47.2 (I'm just making up numbers). But all this hand-wringing over whether this is fair, or that is fair, seems to just be something to keep people in jobs (because I'll need to do further study at $300K/year to decide if the UCI should allow that bike or not).
- jdietrich 10y ago> I'll need to do further study at $300K/year to decide if the UCI should allow that bike or not The UCI bike regulations are relatively straightforward, albeit somewhat eccentric. They're based on the principles of the Lugano Charter of 1996. This charter was created largely in response to the arms race between Obree and Boardman, which led to extreme and arguably dangerous riding positions. The charter sought to limit extreme bicycle designs and riding positions, whilst still allowing for safe and useful innovation. http://oldsite.uci.ch/imgarchive/Road/Equipment/The%20Lugano%20charter.pdf http://oldsite.uci.ch/imgarchive/Road/Equipment/The%20Lugano... We can see the impact of these regulations today. The Cervelo S5 is widely regarded to be the fastest UCI-legal road bike. It is a phenomenal work of engineering, but still broadly resembles the kind of bicycle that you or I might ride around town. By contrast, a high-end triathlon bicycle, unencumbered by UCI regulations, barely resembles a bicycle at all. The UCI regulations are a long way from perfect, but few cyclists would welcome a complete technological free-for-all. https://www.cervelo.com/en/road/s-series/s5 https://www.cervelo.com/en/road/s-series/s5 http://www.diamondback.com/shop/andean http://www.diamondback.com/shop/andean
- ironchief 10y agoAgreed. I think you should be able to go to either extreme that is safe. 1. Everyone gets just the equipment they were born with. Its barefoot with nothing beyond basic clothes for modesty/support. In this scenario its all about the human body and training. 2. The other end is springy shoes, aerodynamic clothing. 3. Farther down the line you have safe technology like 100% O2, autologous blood tranfusions. Nothing that permanently changes the body. If you think some of these things are dangerous, I'd counter that the sport itself is dangerous and well known for its injuries. 3a. Even farther you have the things that can cause permanent changes/death for the athelete. EPO, steroids, Perfluorocarbons etc.
- koolba 10y ago> Look, it'd be one thing to have little batteries and motors in the things. But these just take the energy that I've already expended and returns a bit more of it than my old shoes. But I've still got to do the work. How about Pistorius style blades that extend your feet? There's no external power source[1] so would that be okay in your book? [1]: *Assuming they're not "primed" by compressing them prior to the race starting so you bounce off the starter.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoYeah, I bet I could bear Usain Bolt if I was on a bike. Also see: flippers.
- prestonbriggs 10y agoFor 100 meters from a standing start? He'd crush you. Time yourself someday.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoTrue, but over a few KM I could. I couldn't name any longer distance runners off the top of my head.
- douche 10y agoUsain Bolt claims to have never actually run a few KM at a stretch http://time.com/4436498/usain-bolt-has-never-run-a-mile/ http://time.com/4436498/usain-bolt-has-never-run-a-mile/
- PJDK 10y agoDepends how fit you are. Even in a marathon top athletes are maintaining ~20km/hr!
- prestonbriggs 10y agoMaybe. I think it'd be an interesting thing to study. When I was young and running a lot, I could beat (recreational) cyclists uphill, but they would smoke me on downhills. So there might be the kernel of a fun study there. I guess my hypothesis is that, given equally fit bikers and runners, there's an incline where they will climb at equal speeds. Furthermore, at steep inclines, the runners will be faster and at shallower inclines, the bikers will be faster. Doesn't seem too unlikely (or interesting, actually), given the weight of the bicycle. But the general shape of the curves might be interesting.
- 1_2__3 10y agoAre you not aware that literally every major sport has technical restrictions like the ones you're decrying and have for many decades? This whole thread is full of people staggeringly ignorant of physical sport and competition.