3 ms·
You share that hypothesis with a popular award-winning SF trilogy. My critique of that trilogy is that it doesn't incorporate the concept of present discounted
by jessaustin 10y ago
You share that hypothesis with a popular award-winning SF trilogy. My critique of that trilogy is that it doesn't incorporate the concept of present discounted value, which seems to derive from the apparently-universal laws of thermodynamics. If you have the power to destroy nascent interstellar civilizations, and the threat posed by those is their potential to use scarce resources in future, why spend the resources to destroy them now? How do you know they'll live long enough to use those resources? How do you know you'll live long enough to care?
All the predators we've observed, eat their prey to sate a present (or in the case of hibernators, near-future) hunger. We've recently learned how common planets and suns like ours are. Why would any hungry alien civilization drive past all those resources to get to us? We haven't developed anything particularly tasty yet...
- Entangled 10y agoLife is tasty and scarce, the rest is lifeless and abundant, and according to universal laws of supply and demand, that which is scarce (life) is more expensive and in higher demand, for whatever reasons unknown to us, yet.
- jessaustin 10y agoSaying that we're special doesn't make it true. There's no conceivable reason why anything we have now or will have in the foreseeable future would be worth traveling multiple light years to anyone. Perhaps if an attacker could remotely hypnotize us into spending our own resources to send it other resources, that might make us viable prey?