4 ms·
What I don't like about common core is that it is leaving my son and his classmates hopelessly confused and without basic calculation skills. If we want to act
by btilly 10y ago
What I don't like about common core is that it is leaving my son and his classmates hopelessly confused and without basic calculation skills.
If we want to actually fix elementary math education, that would be simple. Singapore has developed a math curriculum that puts them top in the world in testing. Every research study that has used their system has found that it works far better than we do. But we have an entire educational establishment whose profits depend on our having periodic crises that let them rewrite all of the textbooks and charge top dollar retraining all of our teachers. Switching to something that works wouldn't make them money, so they will undermine the political process to guarantee that it doesn't happen.
As for homework, that's a giant can of worms. There is plenty of research on homework. It shows that homework is net neutral on actual learning, but a strong negative on creating stress. Digging in, it turns out that it can help or hurt, but whether it helps or hurts depends on whether there is someone at home who makes sure that the child does correct practice rather than incorrect practice. Therefore assigning homework's main impact (after home stress) is to widen the educational gap between children of different socioeconomic statuses.
The problem with common core homework is that the children don't know how to do it, the parents can't figure out what the teacher wants, and the end result is utter confusion. I've seen this first hand. I have a masters in math, but I'd look at my son's 4th grade homework and say, "I can think of several things that the teacher might want, but I have no idea which one she does." The end result was utter confusion in my son. Confusion that resulted in his lacking basic skills until we hired a tutor to fix that.
Anyways Common Core is a complete and utter disaster. We aren't too far from parents' resentment rising up and causing a new reform movement that will predictably get hijacked by the same interests who guaranteed that Common Core would fail. Which is nothing new. It has happened every 5-10 years for longer than I've been alive...
- Declanomous 10y agoI agree with most of your points, but I don't think common core is a disaster. I couldn't agree with you more on the homework front. However I don't think homework is intrinsically the problem, I think the problem is the fact that our current educational system is based around pedagogy, of which doing homework is only a part. I personally think the fact that Common Core is designed to be more Socratic.
- btilly 10y agoI agree that homework is only a symptom, not the key problem. The key problem is that Common Core is an ambitious set of ideas that requires everything to be done differently than it had been before. While there are a lot of good ideas in there, there are going to be inevitable mistakes and a shaking out period while the challenges get figured out and people learn best practices for how to make it work. In the meantime our children are guinea pigs with widely differing experiences. My son's experience being on the bad side. However we have seen this picture before. Everything that I just said about Common Core could have been said 50 years ago about New Math. The result was Why Johnny Can't Add, and the "Back to Basics" movement. Want to bet on whether something like this happens again with Common Core? And so I predict that our educational system won't figure out how to do Common Core right. Instead we'll have another reform movement, which will likewise have good intentions, good rhetoric, and in the end will likewise fail. As has been happening to us in math since the launch of Sputnik convinced us that the US is behind and needs to catch up. If your awareness of reform efforts starts with Common Core, then there is a lot of history that you're missing. Every reform movement convinces people that it is working. And they will continue believing that it would have worked until long after it is dead.
- mjmahone17 10y agoA lot of the Common Core math concepts are the same as the Singapore Math concepts. Things like breaking apart numbers, playing with them, grouping and re-organizing them. Singapore math does not try to teach the "standard math algorithms" like long division, instead trying to get students to understand the "why" behind why the division works. The major complaint from parents with this seems to be they can't understand it. But that's exactly the point: their kids are supposed to be getting a more rigorous education (in the sense of understanding vs. being able to find an answer). Another key problem: in the US, a lot of our math educators (especially at the elementary level) really don't like math. At the end of the day, the teacher has to explain, assign and grade the curriculum. If they don't understand the core concepts, or don't like teaching them (for instance, they know how to do the carrying-digits multiplication, but never have played with breaking up numbers to add them), they can't teach those concepts effectively. And we put nowhere near the amount of time or money into training our existing teachers as Singapore does. Common Core is an attempt to provide common concepts and training, so we can focus on making teachers better at areas they struggle with. But you can't do that if there's no will or resources to improve.
- btilly 10y agoA large part of success is not having good ideas, it is in having good execution. Singapore Math has had years of refinement to get where it is. Common Core is just starting down that road. And for the record, Singapore Math absolutely does teach "standard math algorithms". They just build up to them in pieces so that the algorithm will be dead obvious when they finally present it. There is a world of difference between this and confusing kids with 3 different algorithms, leaving them with no idea which is which or how to keep them straight. But now we come to this... The major complaint from parents with this seems to be they can't understand it. But that's exactly the point: their kids are supposed to be getting a more rigorous education (in the sense of understanding vs. being able to find an answer). Excuse my language for a moment. Do you have any fucking idea how condescending it is to receive this type of bullshit response to my complaint? I'd be willing to bet money that my background in and understanding of math is more extensive than yours, and CERTAINLY more so than the vast majority of proponents of Common Core that I see this from. Should you disagree, please provide evidence of your graduate degrees in math, placement in the top 100 on the Putnam, published research papers, or public tutorials explaining complex math concepts on par with http://www.elem.com/~btilly/kelly-criterion/ http://www.elem.com/~btilly/kelly-criterion/ or http://elem.com/~btilly/effective-ab-testing/ http://elem.com/~btilly/effective-ab-testing/. The problem is NOT that my son's ELEMENTARY SCHOOL TEACHER is giving him a MORE RIGOROUS math education than I received. It is that she FAILED TO TEACH him. Full. Stop. She FAILED to TEACH him. Even so, on the standardized tests that we use to measure this fucking bullshit, HE WAS BETTER THAN 95% OF KIDS HIS AGE IN CALIFORNIA. This was true DESPITE his lacking basic skills like long multiplication! In other words he is what Common Core proponents will cite AS A GODDAMNED SUCCESS!!! And yet I had to spend my fucking time and money to fix their failure. And not, I assure you, due to any lack of ability on his part. His scores relative to other California children are a testament to THAT fact. Language warning off. Please read my rant multiple times, and try to put yourself into my shoes. And hopefully you'll think twice before dismissing other people's feedback in such a condescending manner.
- uniclaude 10y ago> As for homework, that's a giant can of worms. There is plenty of research on homework. It shows that homework is net neutral on actual learning, but a strong negative on creating stress. Digging in, it turns out that it can help or hurt, but whether it helps or hurts depends on whether there is someone at home who makes sure that the child does correct practice rather than incorrect practice. Therefore assigning homework's main impact (after home stress) is to widen the educational gap between children of different socioeconomic statuses. That sounds very interesting, and really matches what I've seen so far. Do you have a link to some of this research? I'd like to share this with some friends but would like to share more than a link to a single hn comment!
- btilly 10y agoThat comment sums up what I learned from http://www.alfiekohn.org/homework-myth/ http://www.alfiekohn.org/homework-myth/. Every so often I run across more recent research on the same topic. It always comes to the same conclusion. But parents generally feel better about their kids having poor results if they see evidence that their kids are at least putting out lots of effort. Homework serves as evidence, so it is hard to get rid of it. In the meantime I'm lucky that 3/4 of my children get to go to https://www.vandammeacademy.com/ https://www.vandammeacademy.com/ which believes in doing what is proven to work. Therefore they have a no homework policy, adopt proven methods like Singapore math, and so on. Which is why 3/4 of my children are getting a truly superior education with far, far less work. Just to give a relevant anecdote about how strongly parents can feel about it, I know a fellow parent there who turned down a $400k/year job at Google because it would have meant that he had to move to Silicon Valley. He is convinced that he has found the best K-8 school in the country and won't take that away from his children. He's far from the only parent at the school who feels that way.