7 ms·
The possibility of remaking the financial system with the blockchain
- nrdwavexe 10y agoI absolutely HATE the people in the financial industry. They are rotten scum. I want teams of civil servants spying on them until kingdom come. The notion that I'm going to let the rotten scum who treat civilization like a casino game operate the financial system is pure stupid. It is 100% pure stupid. Harvard is full of these types. The absolute WORST of humanity. The absolute WORST. People who have absolutely no respect for anything. Let me tell you this clearly: we are talking about letting LIFE UNWORTHY OF LIFE run our economy. NO FUCKING WAY. no fucking way.
- brilliantcode 10y agosaid the blockchain expert.
- rc_bhg 10y agoMaybe. If so, only on a much smaller scale. A lot of the automation in Blockchain tech might actually help the banks and law firms make even more money by having to employ fewer people.
- vanattab 10y agoyeah... just like the "sharing economy" was going to take over the world.
- InternetUser 10y agoYou don't think that the peer-to-peer sharing of news and other online content has had a significant effect on politics, business, and society?
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoCan you elaborate on what you mean by peer-to-peer. What protocols are people using on the internet that are peer-to-peer?
- kingnothing 10y agoI assume he's referring to getting news from your peers on Facebook, Twitter, etc. instead of watching the news at 7pm every day.
- cholantesh 10y agoThey're referring to apps like Lyft or Taskrabbit, which provided shared access to a resource.
- tylershuster 10y agoYou mean like Uber, AirBnB &c? Give it a couple years. The internet is ~30 y/o. "The Sharing Economy" isn't even a decade old.
- sanswork 10y agoCloser to 20 for the commercial internet.
- brilliantcode 10y agoUber is fucked and AirBNB is facing lot of resistance for making cities unaffordable by incentivizing landlords to rent to short term travellers vs people who are contributing to the local economy who aren't able to move closer to work due to lack of supply. Not exactly what the internet ordered.
- Naed_force 10y agoUber is most certainly not fucked, and if it isn't Uber, it'll be another ride sharing company. Airbnb is growing rapidly and helping to create a more mobile world, where you can affordably travel, or live in different places a few months at a time. And tourists on a per capita basis contribute far more per day than long-term residents, since they're in high spending mode. They also consume fewer government services like welfare and medical care, so they don't cost the taxpayer as much. Airbnb also makes it much easier to rent out spare units that would otherwise sit empty. It makes it easier to rent out that extra bedroom, or your unit while you go on vacation for two weeks. That increases total housing supply. Short term housing is still part of housing supply. People need affordable options when they're transitioning from one long term unit to another. It's not always a same day transition. Markets in general benefit mankind, by allowing more efficient exchange. This is Econ 101 stuff, for which there is mountain of real world evidence.
- splintercell 10y ago> Uber is fucked Uber is definitely not fucked because customers don't wanna use Uber.
- 10y ago
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agoif the same volume of transactions that go through visa, went through bitcoin, the blockchain would grow daily bigger than any available hard drive. you're all idiots
- sanswork 10y agoEvery time I see someone claiming that no one thought the internet would succeed by pointing out that newsweek article I wonder if they are even old enough to remember the mid 90s. I get that it would be regional but in the Toronto area in the mid-90s everyone I knew wanted to try the web and email it was often just expensive or a pain in the ass to do so. Having scanned through the article they basically point out why their premise is wrong. "lawyers argue that regulation through code alone is inflexible and doesn’t permit any role for useful discretion". >In the case of cryptocurrencies, we’re seeing far more aggressive investments of venture capital than we did for the internet during similar early stages of development. Also this is provably wrong. Blockchain VC sits at around 2b over the course of 8 years and it has basically all but dried up. Internet companies had passed that by 96 after 2 years. 8 years after the start of the commercial internet was 2002.
- asciimo 10y agoI agree that there are plenty of differences between the technologies. But the investment comparison in the article seems accurate; a public Internet can be traced back before the 80s, and "early development" to the 60s. A public blockchain opened in 2009. Wasn't VC investment in the former comparatively late?
- sanswork 10y agoThere were BBSs earlier and if you were lucky you worked for a company or university with access but commercial internet access and usage was restricted before the early 90s. So comparing VC to before that point isn't accurate it also doesn't take into account how the internet itself has accelerated the distribution of ideas and tech dramatically.
- BuuQu9hu 10y agoFirst we need to figure out smart contracts and educate folks on how capability security works.
- graphememes 10y agoWhat portions of Smart Contracts is there left to figure out?
- libertymcateer 10y agoLiterally all of the important stuff. In a recent contract I worked on the definition of "material adverse effect" took up a page of single spaced 12 point times new roman text and had about two dozen other definitions involved. Each one of those terms, at its root, comes down to a judgment call that is subject to disagreement among reasonable people. This is why we have trials.
- astrodust 10y agoSounds like something that will never happen.
- libertymcateer 10y agoI do not buy this for a minute and to be fair the headline misrepresents the much more sober tone of the actual article, to the authors' credit. I am not a fan of cryptocurrency in general (that is another argument for another day) so I am just going to focus on one claim regarding law firms: the rise of the smart contract. I do not believe it is a realistic expectation, and here is why: The vast majority of contracts do not have syntactically testable conditions. They just don't. Whether the conditions in a contract have been met is very often a matter of huge debate - this is what "law suits" are about. Unless you can create a condition that is testable by code, you cannot have a contract that self-enforces with the block chain. The conditions set forth in contracts are extremely complex and reasonable people can differ. I cannot imagine how you would have a contract be triggered on the insolvency of a privately held corporation - good luck defining insolvency and good luck getting access to the underlying books. Copyright infringement is also a preposterous idea - the amount of semantic judgment that must be made to determine if a work is infringing is enormous. Only the very simplest of conditions - comparing numbers, checking the time, can be reliably automated, and if you are getting a lawyer to write your contracts, odds are there is substantially more complexity in the agreements than this, which is why you hired the lawyer in the first place. In addition, a fair portion of contracts that can actually be set up to work this already are - and the blockchain is not necessary. They are things like credit cards and they work pretty good without the blockchain. This aside, are you going to trust your lawyers to write blockchain enforced smart-contracts? Every time I post my code to the world I get reamed and I spend a shitload of time writing code and learning about it, far, far in excess of [edit/deleted: any other lawyer] the vast majority of lawyers I know [edit/insertion: a handful of exceptions have come to mind, but I know literally hundreds of lawyers and practice in NYC] - among lawyers I am a giant and on HN I am beneath contempt. Why on earth would you trust lawyers to write code-based contracts? Nothing about that seems right. Who knows, however. If 2016 taught me one thing it is that all bets are off and the points don't matter.
- lefstathiou 10y agoI see the objective of smart contracts in finance as an augmentation of the human auditing that is already taking place. You don't need 100% of the contract to be smart in my opinion but I'm not an engineer so what do I know. For example let's say you're at JP Morgan and are operating a $10 billion conduit ("warehouse") facility. You have a series of eligibility criteria for every originator contributing loans into the program (each of which have dozens of measurable events like average FICO, seasoning, prepayment speeds, days delinquent, etc) in addition to the vast plethora of nonfinancial terms and conditions you pointed out. Every month, these originators file a monthly remit report which in theory must be accurate (failing to do so could instantly eliminate your access to the conduit and tank your business, not something to take lightly). Right now, a banker must process all of the monthly remits for each individual facility and compare them against what was agreed to in the docs. There could be a hundred contributors to the conduit and if you happen to sit on said desk there will only be 2-3 of you managing this process. It simply can't be done. I've spent a lot of time looking at smart contracts and block chain and have walked away a bit skeptical. There are some very real and very serious issues this in theory can address, I just think there are better ways to do it.
- yarrel 10y agoAllow new monopolies to emerge?
- valarauca1 10y agoBlockchains cannot understand intent like a human courts can. The idea that intent is an important part of determining the punishment/morals of the crime came out of the French Enlightenment. I'd really rather not roll back this. The difference between an accident, manslaughter, and first degree murder are non-trivial and VERY IMPORTANT. Also fuck you if you want to train an ML bot to that job. You clear don't get it.
- astrodust 10y agoA small plastic drone with a blue light on top rolls up to the front door of your house and knocks angrily. You answer. "Your parcel was delivered, but the contents were damaged. According to the picture provided by the purchaser the person inside died while in transit." What? A person? "It was a mannequin. It's a piece of plastic." The bot prints out a thermal receipt onto a tray. "You are charged with: Manslaughter. Fifteen to twenty years. Sign here."
- avmich 10y ago> Blockchains cannot understand intent like a human courts can. > Also fuck you if you want to train an ML bot to that job. You clear don't get it. Very interesting :) - can you elaborate more?
- jbpetersen 10y agoAlternately, you could start up a prediction market on how likely the accused is to commit crimes in the future based on potential sentences, sell shares of their future income in order to incentivize proper rehabilitation, weigh the various registered values of voters to determine how much money and time should be sacrificed for the sake of seeing the guilty punished, get the case analyzed by various remote contractors who have proven records on predicting verdicts, and various other ambiguously utopian/dystopian "improvements" to the legal system of today. And how long until you can train the ML bot to do better than a randomly selected jury at predicting what a larger jury would make of a case?
- rdslw 10y agoI wouldn't say 'Law Firms' - however I would say notary public may be severely affected.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]