3 ms·
It would be interesting to see the data on this. I've worked in software development for 20 years and hired tons of people (maybe over 100). I think that profes
by prepend 10y ago
It would be interesting to see the data on this. I've worked in software development for 20 years and hired tons of people (maybe over 100). I think that professional jobs have the lowest pay disparity.
I would imagine it's really hard to measure the pay gap between programmers because there are literally coders that are 2x or 5x more productive than other coders. So I don't think it's as simple as checking all the people with "programmer" in their title by gender.
- zephyrthenoble 10y agohttps://www.cnet.com/news/biggest-pay-gap-in-america-computer-programmers/ https://www.cnet.com/news/biggest-pay-gap-in-america-compute...
- prepend 10y agoThis is all self-reported and not-representative data. So while an interesting story, is not evidence of a pay gap. There should be a statistical paper with a proper analysis somewhere, I'll try looking for it.
- KirinDave 10y agoIt's not proof of a pay gap, but it's evidence of a pay gap. Loads of other evidence of a pay gap is trivially available. I won't entertain the ignorance articulated here on that. You can Google. But I will add an aside that is less obvious. It's entirely possible to have perfectly even pay between every member of your team and still have an overall pay gap if you don't have good diversity in the upper levels of your organization. Many otherwise very good and well-meaning organizations fall prey to this. My position for example, as a distributed systems engineer, is very hard to get into. You don't learn about it in college, you don't find a ton of great books about it, and the field changes rapidly using terms and concepts that were only recently overturned. The way I got into it: a pair of very smart men decided to mentor me when I was younger. But were it not for that apprenticeship/mentorship, I would not be in the field. Women claim they have fewer opportunities for this and that follows with my observations. Therefore, my (higher paying and more in-demand) position is more difficult for many women to acquire.
- 234dd57d2c8dba 10y agoNo, it's actually not evidence of a pay gap. The study is flawed because it doesn't control for number of hours worked for men and women. It is well known that men work more hours, which would explain why "men get paid more". The study you linked is not wages per hour worked, it's just wages. The fact that this myth just keeps getting perpetuated by people is ridiculous. If companies could get away with hiring women for less money, why the heck would they ever conspire against women to hire less women!!! Get the same and/or high quality work from women for a cheaper price or conspire to not hire any women because I hate women I guess? - Pick One.
- mattb314 10y agoThe source: https://www.glassdoor.com/research/studies/gender-pay-gap/ https://www.glassdoor.com/research/studies/gender-pay-gap/ The methodology: https://www.glassdoor.com/research/how-we-analyzed-the-gender-pay-gap-at-glassdoor/ https://www.glassdoor.com/research/how-we-analyzed-the-gende... I didn't find the editorializing in the cnet article very helpful.
- flukus 10y agoI've seen data local to my country that had showed it, but the problem was they grouped all IT workers together. Withe first level technical support being much more gender neutral you couldn't really read much into it.
- danso 10y agoDid you pay those 2x to 5x coders 2-5x more than the regular coder?
- prepend 10y agoSadly no. A 5x will make more, but certainly not 5x salary. In my last company with pay bands, you could see a 20-50% premium.
- danso 10y agoI had assumed the answer was "no", and I asked the question because you seemed to insinuate that the pay gap correlates to merit, and that's why things can't be simplified to comparing people with "programmer" in the title. Well, yes, not all programmers are the same, nor are all definitions and valuations of the title "Programmer" -- which is partly why good data on the subject of "pay disparity" is hard to come by. But I'm arguing that even in some dream world where this data exists, merit would be a very tricky variable to incorporate. As you said, programmers who are 5x, or even 2x, are not paid by multiple-of-productivity. The fact that they aren't isn't so much a reflection of unfairness, but the reality that productivity of a programmer is not at all easy to quantify, and even if it were, not at all constant. The corollary of great programmers not being paid great wages is that there are some shitty programmers are not paid shitty wages. It's possible to accept that there isn't a pay disparity between males and females for a given job at a given company, while believing is that there's a greater tolerance for non-shitty wages to male shitty programmers.