10 ms·
Scrimba: a video format for communicating code
- rachkovsky 10y agoPlease add a favicon!
- ElonsMosque 10y agoAwesome work, this seems like something pulled from the future. One quick question have you considered including Python related stuff?
- mrborgen 10y agoSupport for Python and various other server-side languages is on our roadmap yes.
- netgusto 10y agoWow, this is far much better for code than standard videos. Is it recorded using the scrimba.com website ? Is it only for web code ? The about page https://scrimba.com/about https://scrimba.com/about does not explain much.
- judofyr 10y agoYes! You can sign up now and record your own casts. For now it's focused on client-side libraries, but we're looking at supporting server-side languages as well.
- IanDrake 10y agoSuper cool. One issue... I was watching the flexbox video and modified the CSS code but the view layout didn't update. I clicked the save button thinking that would update the view, but then it had me sign up. After signing up, I ended up with a fork of the video. Cool, but not what I wanted. All I really wanted to do was fool around with the code while I had it paused, see the updates in the layout, and click play again - at which point I would have expected the code to revert to the script.
- arxpoetica 10y agoYes. This. ^
- jonshariat 10y agoDitto. Also was prohibitive to seeing the one "ah ha" moment for users. Would have been nice to experience it before signing up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- judofyr 10y agoOh, you need to click the "run" button (upper right) once before the CSS changes apply. After that it should be live. We need to make that more clear.
- colochef 10y agoThis is really awesome! I was wondering about how you are planning to monetize or sustain the project. Are you going to give the ability for users to monetize their own contributions?
- sagebird 10y agoThis is a wonderful idea and execution. Tip for people trying this out, to experience it fully you have to: - login with github - edit some text - then hit play again. The preview will then update. - also, you can record your own edits to the video. I am surprised by the quality and thoughtful demos. Some simple things would make it better, like updating automatically without hitting play. Also, I think the videos should have x buttons to close them, not just clicking in another area.
- judofyr 10y agoNice to hear you praise the quality. We haven't spent a lot of time on producing the current casts, it's just that the tool makes it easy to create casts of high-production value. No more fiddling with screen-recording software and post-production. It makes a big difference when you can go from "I want to explain this" to a finished cast in three minutes. The "casts are shown in an overlay"-feature was released yesterday. It certainly requires more iterations. Thanks for the feedback.
- brothercolor 10y agoNeat! The audience for the tool seems to be someone who can hear, though. Has there been any awareness or discussion of those who cannot hear? Of those that cannot hear, a large majority use captioning or sign language. Video in a PIP mode, or captioning support, would go a long way in including everyone to the party. Also, the earlier these features are added, the more content is accessible.
- StavrosK 10y agoI don't get it at all. If I edit the code and press play, the code just reverts back to what it was. My edits never execute.
- mrborgen 10y agoAre you pressing the play icon in the lower left corner? That is for resuming back to the timeline the of the creator of the cast. To run the code, press the play icon in the top right corner. When you hover over it, it says 'Run code'. We clearly have some UX challenges here :)
- zokier 10y agoBasically "web version" of asciinema, right?
- speps 10y agoStuck on "loading" in Edge on all videos.
- avenoir 10y agoSame here. Console shows syntax error after loading a stream.
- drumdance 10y agoVery cool. In the last few weeks I've been thinking something similar would be great for podcasts. Not on-screen editing, but tools for displaying information and soliciting feedback. In my case I've been listening to a lot of podcasts about real estate. Frequently they reference a PDF or web site to sign up for more info. It would be nice if that just showed up onscreen rather than having to open a browser on my phone (especially when I'm in the car). Dedicated apps can do this, of course, but I an open protocol would have a lot more uptake from semi-technical people who want to create simple online course distributed via podcast.
- nichochar 10y agoThere is so much opportunity for learning here... I agree, I wish podcasts had some kind of technology that allowed you to follow things that are hard to convey through Audio.
- sly010 10y agoI once started writing a podcast app like that. As a listener I would reallly like the idea. Unfortunately I don't see why a podcaster would do the job of adding metadata on my platform if they don't get anything out of it. If it was a core of their value proposition, they would probably use a mooc platform and not a podcast. Then I though I would probably need to build a more useful tool to manage other needs of a publisher, like website, feed generation, pushing to multiple platforms, etc. That way I would have all sorts of metadata for free AND I would provide value to the publishers (automatic publishing to all other platforms). I could host the content too and give them download numbers, could post listening habits from my app, and all that. But that is a lot of work though, before I can provide any value to either the listeners or the publishers. Then I listened to a podcast about the podcast ecosystem (how meta) about how podcasters actually benefit from the ecosystem being so distributed. If there was a single format for metadata dictated by a single company (would probably be apple) it would eat into their advertising revenue. They would not admit it, but it's actually good for publishers if they only have rough download numbers. Without clicks, they can just make up their numbers, and sell ads even though everyone fast forwards on the ads. If they had actual clicks, their revenue would become dependent on it.
- paulojreis 10y agoMuch like IanDrake said, this is super cool but kind of "primes" the user into thinking that he'll be able to play around with the code while paused. It'd be great if you supported that, e.g. by doing a "fork" into local storage. Anyway, the project is really great and impressive! :)
- mrborgen 10y agoWe do support that. Hit the 'Edit' button in the lower right corner :)
- quickben 10y agoBeware: The website asks my mobile browser for permissions to take pictures and video.
- somebee 10y agoOh, it's probably because we ask for webrtc mic-access when you record. Will look into it :)
- jlarocco 10y ago<rant> I cannot wait for the "everything needs to be a small looping video clip" fad to go away. Video clips of typing make no sense. The animation is distracting, it provides no useful information, and they always either loop too quickly (frustrating me because I lose my place and have to wait for the whole thing to come back), or go too slowly (frustrating me because it won't hurry up). A 3 second loop is great for a hamster meme, it's not great for displaying text that I want to read. It's like an entire group of people completely misunderstood why GIF animations were despised and died off. Seriously, what value are these video clips adding? </rant>
- rajangdavis 10y agoYou can pause and edit the code inline...
- phaed 10y agoYou can also skip to the end and mess with the finished code via the progress bar and edit button if you don't care for the explanation.
- lygaret 10y agoDid you actually click on the link in OP?
- Dangeranger 10y agoWow this is so much better than a traditional video explanation of code. Really well done and polished for a beta project. Speaking of 'beta', what is the plan for Scrimba? Are you interested in it being an open place for sharing videos and demonstrations? Or are you planning on monetizing in some way?
- mrborgen 10y agoWe plan to add monetization options yes. Basically sell courses through Scrimba. But it will also be possible to simply share casts for free.
- benmcnelly 10y agoThats great!
- theobon 10y agofeature request: Ability to change playback speed. Eg 0.5x, 1.5x, 2x
- judofyr 10y agoI've opened an issue for tracking this here: https://github.com/scrimba/community/issues/9 https://github.com/scrimba/community/issues/9
- heywire 10y agoJust wanted to say I think you've done an excellent job with this!
- marknadal 10y agoWow, very exciting! Already starting to use it. Question: How to embed a scrimba "video" on another page?
- mrborgen 10y agoSupport for that will come, but it might be a pro feature. Any specific use case you were thinking?
- marknadal 10y agoJust to post in blogs, github pages, etc. I'm biased but I think you would get free marketing if people embed it, and a paid feature for people to keep them private (password locked, whatever). That way people who publish free educational content (freecodeacademy, me - example, a todo app tutorial: http://gun.js.org/think.html http://gun.js.org/think.html , etc.) would spread scrimba awareness. The inverse, sites that charge for classes - Udemy, etc., have a natural incentive to keep their content secret, which they'd have to pay for.
- funkaster 10y agoGreat job! Is there any other way to login that's not github? I'm trying to move away from github and so far the only thing preventing me are sites that require github login. It would be great if you offered just plain old email login :)
- benmcnelly 10y agoI think its because they use github for storage/forking things, but they could certainly extend it to work without it later.
- funkaster 10y agothat makes (some) sense. It would be great if in the future they could not rely on github.
- sdflkd 10y agoWhy are you trying to move away from Github, out of curiosity?
- funkaster 10y agojust a personal stance. It's a good service, I just personally don't like it.
- sly010 10y agoI really like the idea and I expect to see a lot of great tutorials in this format. I would really use a version that works with tmux or iterm though, something like asciinema but for multiple terminals + a browser. I wouldn't even mind if the result is read only as long as the viewer can copy paste from it. Edit: Just to add one more note: I know recording terminal and chrome at the same time is too complicated to productize, but I wouldn't mind having to set it up. I am a developer. I set things up.
- dmux 10y agoIs there sound accompanying the video? I watched several but didn't hear anything.
- judofyr 10y agoYes. It's supposed to have audio. Could you submit an issue at https://github.com/scrimba/community https://github.com/scrimba/community with details about your browser/environment?
- benmcnelly 10y agoMan this is good. Any plans to extend it to other languages?
- judofyr 10y agoThanks. Yes, other (server-side) languages are definitely coming. We're currently working with a prototype that integrates with Jupyter/IPython, and we're also playing with the idea of using Docker images for giving a full terminal. The biggest challenge is to give a powerful execution environment and make it easy for the viewer to play with the code and be able to run it.
- endergen 10y agoHave you guys seen https://runkit.com/ https://runkit.com/ ? I suspect they are using something like docker for snapshot and replaying. I'm sure there are some tricks to be learned from them
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hairyjewbear 10y agoDo you have a blog where you would update this?
- rudimental 10y agoReally cool tool. Congratulations and great job! Look forward to seeing where this goes. Feedback: the rerun project button is hard to locate and not prominent. I wanted to rerun the project after making some changes. I felt encouraged to save (fork) or resume playback, overwriting my edits. Make it more intuitive to rerun after making an edit.
- abrkn 10y agoLooks great! Signup took seconds.
- fny 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but it looks like this written in a Imba[0]. [0]: http://imba.io http://imba.io
- somebee 10y agoYou are correct :) Initially it was meant as a tool to teach people Imba, but now we support other languages as well!
- aemadrid 10y agovery cool tool. would be even better if you add #tags so say you can filter all the #imba casts.
- rajangdavis 10y agoInsane and well executed!
- JepZ 10y agoWould love to see something like this for golang. I mean the tour of go is already great, but this is yet another step better :-)
- tyingq 10y agoLooks great on desktop. On my android though, it's slow, low-contrast, and a bit janky. The desktop experience, though, is better than comparable stuff I've seen. Nice work.
- xellisx 10y agoNeeds a volume slider.
- 40acres 10y agoWow, this could be a game changer. Imagine using a tool like this to teach math as well. Great job guys.
- saganus 10y agoThis is really cool! However... I might be a bit obtuse or something, but how can I produce my own videos? Maybe I'm overlooking a link?
- Ahmed90 10y agoGreat job, - Any plan on embedding option for 3rd party websites? - Self-hosted versions?
- mrborgen 10y agoYes!
- juliosueiras 10y agoThe moment I try scrimba, I notice is using the code completion from VS code, so I went with my instinct and open a file with .ts(for typescript) and it work EDIT: a bit hackish but it is possible to add d.ts, by putting the file directly(like creating a file call jquery.d.ts and put the jquery def inside), the def will actually load in
- ChicagoBoy11 10y agoThis is insanely well executed - like most people here I am psyched to play with it
- ChicagoBoy11 10y agoDoes anyone have any tips to start playing around in this environment with ES2015 stage-2?
- mrborgen 10y agoWe'll open up for that soon!
- ythn 10y agoThis is so badly needed in a world of video coding tutorials (cough Unity3D). Awesome technology
- mrborgen 10y agoThanks a lot for all the feedback, everyone! We're overwhelmed by all the positive comments. If you have any feature requests, please submit them as issues here: https://github.com/scrimba/community https://github.com/scrimba/community Also, a few people have asked us how to create content, so we're obviously not making it clear enough. To do that, simply create an account (with GitHub) and start screencasting in our browser editor. If you want to get in touch with us, send me an email at per@scrimba.com. Finally, I want to mention that we're applying for YC this spring. If any of you have any tips or connections you think we should speak with, please let me know :)
- biot 10y agoIs the video format documented somewhere, or are you keeping that proprietary?
- faceyspacey 10y agoY apply to YC. If ur serious about anything and ur a serious developer, u don't need money, connections, etc. Y dilute yourself, Y forever be beholden to investors. I know I don't want anyone telling me what to do regarding my baby. Programming apps is quicker than ever now. All you need is a ramen noodle revenue stream to keep you afloat while you build. I urge you to question why you really wanna go to YC. Is it to get consigned by "daddy"? It sure can feel good. It's an accomplishment of it's own, but a sub-par intention. You got this far, why not monetize on your own so you can support yourself through your product, and never have to give up any equity and rights to decision making for YOUR COMPANY! Too many people are eager to allow others to have a say on their baby. Don't do it unless you absolutely need to. Start charging. I'll pay for this product. Forget YC. Believe in yourself. Are you a follower that eagerly seeks direction from others or a leader who just knows what must be done and doesn't look to others for validation. Validation seekers will always fare less well because they are less confident. So the question is: why are you not confident in yourselves? Why is this going to fail if you don't go to YC? To put the question in the positive, how could you get to where you wanna go and farther without YC?? What do you need? Is it just ramen noodle revenue for you guys while you build? If so, maybe there are other ways. Have you even tried to explore them?
- Ruphin 10y agoThis is the coolest web tech I have seen in a while. I am actually not super convinced on the usecase of being able to edit the code at any time, but simply being able to copy it is already so much added value over traditional video course material. I will definitely be checking out the possibilities with this.
- goshx 10y agoA good usecase is for when you are learning something through the video and can play with it right there. Khan Academy uses something similar and it is awesome.
- SeanAnderson 10y agoI literally yelled aloud, "Wait! Stop! What is going on?! THIS IS COOL." when I first interacted with your product. This is novel & fantastic. Well done. EDIT: I've gone ahead and moved all my UI/UX feedback into GitHub per your request. Good luck working on this! :)
- somebee 10y agoThanks for really valuable feedback :) Great if you want to submit and follow up at github.com/scrimba/community! We hadn't really planned for a HN launch yet so a lot of the ux is rough around the edges.
- SeanAnderson 10y agoYep :) I know how valuable the "I've never used this before" interactions can be with a product! I'll toss up an issue!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- erikpukinskis 10y agoIf you provided an embeddable iframe widget that I could put on my own site, and intercept the file changes to do my own rendering, something like: <script src="http://scrimba.com/widget.js"> scrimbaWidget(".my-container", "sc-ri-mbaID", function onFileChanged(name, source, output) { persistToMyBackend(name, source) output.innerHTML = renderFromMyServer(name) }) </script> ... this would be a very interesting platform play. You would be providing essentially the audio, text capture, and synchronization, but I could keep doing my app hosting. Not having to store audio or deal with browser incompatibilities around recording and playback would be worth some money to me. Like Filestack for screen recording.
- applecrazy 10y agoBug: if you hover over the "popular" ones, some say 3.81 views, etc.
- divanvisagie 10y agoThis is pointless, tried editing , did not work as I thought it would. Sad!
- hmottestad 10y agoThere is a small "play" button in the top right corner you have to press after editing. You don't need permissions to edit, but you do need them to save.
- divanvisagie 10y agoYeah I saw that , little bit too minimal to be honest , doesn't scream "click me" so was a bit confused initially. Though it was just another play button for the video. Maybe moving it to the output window would be a bit less confusing
- LukasRos 10y agoGreat idea and great execute, I like it! One thing that I haven't seen yet but what I think would be a really important feature would be embeddable "videos" which developers could put as a widget in an iframe on e.g. their website blog.
- johnomarkid 10y agoIf I edit some text in a video that I created, do I need to re-record all of the audio?
- mrborgen 10y agoAs for now, you can't change the code after it has been recorded audio over it.
- throwaway_374 10y agoI was thinking about something very similar, essentially embedding an IDE on top of Youtube videos. Like others, I agree this is very neat. Is it just me that can't hear any audio?
- metasean 10y agoIf I stop the video, then use the "resume video" in the lower-right corner, then I get the audio but it's out of sync by however long it took me to stop the video in the first place.
- zichy 10y agoThis is a great idea. I have one small suggestion: Please give the cursor a better contrast or outline/shadow.
- pjc50 10y agoMinor nit: some of the thumbnails report they've been viewed "1.52" times.
- somebee 10y agoThank you for reporting. Fixed now.
- lilactown 10y agoIs there a way to search all videos?
- somebee 10y agoWe're working on search, discovery, and sorely needed social features as we speak. It's coming very soon!
- nmstoker 10y agoMaybe you need a YouTube video detailing the experience, as it obviously isn't quite as good on mobile Chrome (no sound, I only realised from the comments here; also awkward to control accurately). A video would also give people a sense of what the environment/process looked like before they hand over details - I'm happy to trade my details for a good experience once I know it's likely to be a good experience, less so when I'm not confident, it becomes a bit chicken and egg...