3 ms·
I am not saying medicine entails complex processes in terms of intellectual capabilities. Quite the opposite, actually. The complexity I was speaking about is t
by rscho 10y ago
I am not saying medicine entails complex processes in terms of intellectual capabilities. Quite the opposite, actually. The complexity I was speaking about is that of actual physical procedures. Most specialties span a much larger range of activities than one imagines at first glance. For example, pathology does involve looking at surgical samples under the microscope, but that is only the final step in the process. You first have to describe the specimen macroscopically, and make sense of its original location and orientation in the body. Autopsy, a process akin to surgery, also falls in the realm of pathology.
Granted, some specialties will be easier than others to automate. But the complexity of the machine feedback processes that will have to be implemented are currently overwhelming in most specialties. We will see a long period during which AI facilitates our work, without replacing us, due to lack of integration in the workplace.
You mentioned surgery as difficult for AI, but interestingly it is one of the fields where feedback will be easier to implement, since patients rarely undergo surgery without extensive imaging first. But in many technical procedures (anesthesia, intubation, catheterization, bronchoscopy, etc...) you often perform without fixed patterns, and orient yourself using the (quite variable) patient environment and symptoms.
There is no question this all will be automated someday. But it is far more complex than working on a car assembly line. We are not there yet.
- austinjp 10y agoThanks for the reply. I didn't known that autopsy was a pathology discipline. Personally I suspect that many medical roles will be broken into sub-roles and semi automated. Humans will remain with stop/go decisions and overview, for a while at least. I think we are probably in agreement. Incidentally, I agree regarding surgery, perhaps I was unclear.