3 ms·
> The main connection I have eeked out that I don't think most understand though is the relationship between the Wall Street group and The City of London/Vatica
by kbenson 10y ago
> The main connection I have eeked out that I don't think most understand though is the relationship between the Wall Street group and The City of London/Vatican/Swiss Banking groups and their many associated secret society groups and orders of knighthood.
This is where you started to lose me. If you've eeked this out, surely you have something you can include to convince us?
> I think it is telling that the decryption passphrase was JFK talking about scattering them to a thousand winds.
I'm not sure what this is referring to. Can you elaborate?
> Stop using windows and osx, even for gaming. Stop installing windows at your business. Start using HIDS like OSSEC. Start checking your logs. Start checking your checksums. Start hardening your systems and your kernel (grsec). Stop using stock android, and don't use IOS. Desoder microphones on systems. Build faraday cages.
That will protect you in your home and on your personal devices (to a degree), but it doesn't protect you in public. Anonymity and privacy are an artifact of our congregating in large enough groups that it's not possible to know all those you see in a day, but the vast majority of our history was spent with no anonymity and little to no privacy. I'm convinced our return to a lack of anonymity and privacy is a return to the norm. That doesn't mean I support it or think it's necessarily better, but information wants to be free and humans like to know things, even if that happens to be what you had for breakfast today. Fighting naturally incentivized systems rarely ends well.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe vast majority of our history was spent with substantial limits on the ability to collect, distribute, and access information on any one individual, let alone cross-compile information from multiple sources or for multiple individuals. Scale and rates matter.
- kbenson 10y agoI don't think the scale matters for the past. You spent the majority of your time with other people in your tribe or village, and they knew everything about you, and you knew everything about all of them. New information could be distributed to 90% of the people within minutes. You could physically ask most the people any questions you wanted about someone else with just a little more time than that. The current scale just makes this true again. Again, I don't think that makes it good, but I do think it's important to note.
- dredmorbius 10y agoToday the observer can be anywhere on Earth, and the data are vastly more detailed. Impunity of the observer is far greater. The subject isn't conversations but surveillance.
- kbenson 10y ago> Today the observer can be anywhere on Earth It's all a matter what you consider "the world". If you were born into and died in a small group of people and had little to no interaction with outsiders, your "world" is that group. In that respect, anyone in the "world" can easily know just about anything about you just by asking, because there's almost always someone around you, and people like to share information (gossip). > and the data are vastly more detailed How so? Because they can determine everything down to what food I like and dislike? I know that about most my coworkers. I think you are treating information you leak through normal interaction with people differently than what is gathered about you online, when really they are no different. > Impunity of the observer is far greater. In the end it's all about enforcing compliance with some group norm and governmental dictate. That's no different in the small group either. The group is the government, and you can take measures to hide your behavior, which in both systems might actually draw attention to yourself, or you can attempt to fit within the group norms, whether that group is the literal or figurative world. A sweet deal has existed for a couple millennia if you've been in a large enough group to benefit from anonymity and the increased privacy that imparts.
- dredmorbius 10y agoLet me put this in other terms. In the world you're talking of, the surveillance happened in person, within a village, with approximately one book per million inhabitants[1], with a typical travel and data transmission speed of roughly 3 mph, a peak of perhaps three times that, exceedingly low literacy (~5% in villages, perhaps 25% in towns[1]), and very low data transmission rates: verbal recitation. Though perhaps with a fairly fast interactive natural-language query system (e.g., interrogation). It was possible to escape that domain by travel, either temporarily or permanently, as little as 10-20 miles might suffice.[2] As late as the 19th century in the United States, it was possible for a well-connected and politically connected man to lead a double life.[3] As to the detail of the data, your question begs credulity in light of what I've stated above. The rates of data accumulation today simply surpass all of recorded history. Something like 90% of all recorded data come from within the past decade. As of 2007, 94% of all information were in digital form.[4] You assert, without proof or evidence, that there is no difference between digital information stored across servers, and the disaggregated wetware knowledge of your immediate associates. I pose as counterexamples Uber's Greyball program, which in realtime tied multidimensional characteristics of a user's Uber account, available hardware information, and social networking profiles, amongst other signifiers, to determine who was or wasn't a possible government employee, and to literally change their perception of reality as a consequence.[5] Thirty years ago, your magazine subscriptions might have been shared amongst marketing organisations, sixty years ago, state intelligence services might have had access to them. Today, your Kindle reader tracks what passages you've read within books, and every website, and its third-party scripts and cookie shares, track precisely what you've read online.[6][7] That is straight up the definition of "Orwellian"[8] Size, scale, and rate, matter. As a noted expert in the field observed, "quantity has a quality all its own".[9] Even gradual changes lead to phase shifts past a transition point, some sudden, some not. A small group of observers -- the few hundred of a mediaeval village -- is well within the Dunbar's limits of our brains,[10] and is subject to direct observation to boot. It has little capacity to keep a permanent record of its information, or even, particularly, to correlate observations from different observers. It cannot spread that information throughout all of humanity (some seven billion three hundred million souls, presently), nor can it act from out of the blue based on that information. It is a petty oppression, not a grand one. Today's digital information attacks are difficult, often impossible, to precisely attribute.[11] Those who build information systems do no, will not, and ultimately in all likelihood can not protect them from attacks or subversion.[12] Data is described, by seasoned experts in the field, as a toxic asset.[13] It persists, can be used for fraud, blackmail, character assassination, to micromanage individuals lives (a supreme denial of liberty), and more. Your arguments, or should I say assertions, are supremely unconvincing. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Buringh, Eltjo; van Zanden, Jan Luiten: "Charting the “Rise of the West”: Manuscripts and Printed Books in Europe, A Long-Term Perspective from the Sixth through Eighteenth Centuries", The Journal of Economic History, Vol. 69, No. 2 (2009) 2. Though, yes, there were strong limitations on such travel, see the Vagrancy and Poor laws of England, as examples, which applied to labourers. Nonetheless, a skilled craftsman, scribe, or professional could and many did, travel throughout Europe, particularly when the political heat got too great at home. 3. Geologist Clarence King, whose professional colleagues had no knowledge of his marriage, and his black wife, who thought he was a Pullman Porter, comes to mind. 4. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/02/110210141219.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/02/110210141219.h... 5. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/03/technology/uber-greyball-program-evade-authorities.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/03/technology/uber-greyball-... 6. http://www.ibtimes.com/psst-your-amazon-kindle-spying-you-925439 http://www.ibtimes.com/psst-your-amazon-kindle-spying-you-92... 7. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/09/online-trackers-and-social-networks https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/09/online-trackers-and-so... 8. https://www.worldcat.org/title/1984-a-novel/oclc/905951412&referer=the_white_fbi_van_outside https://www.worldcat.org/title/1984-a-novel/oclc/905951412&r... 9. Though he covered his tracks well: https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:Joseph_Stalin https://en.m.wikiquote.org/wiki/Talk:Joseph_Stalin 10. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number 11. https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2017/01/why_proving_the_sour.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2017/01/why_proving... 12. https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2017/03/botnets_of_things.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2017/03/botnets_of_... 13. https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic_asse.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_t...
- arca_vorago 10y ago"surely you have something you can include to convince us?" Perhaps, but it's not an easy subject to breach at all, but I appreciate your honest question and will attempt a terse summary. During both my time in the military as a pawn, and during my time as a civilian trying to understand the deep state, I have continually come across two fundamental issues regardless of particular area of research: Bankers touch everything. At first I was just trying to chase the terrorist finance networks up the chain. Thinking it probably mostly ended at some Saudi, Jordanian, UAE banks. Not true, but the problem is that post 9/11 so much of the finance network stuff was taken out of the public view, scrubbed and redacted, or otherwise hushed up. I thought this was for operational reasons, to not give up the game to the ones we were after, but after 3,5,10+ years of no real attacks on the finance network, I'm increasingly convinced they are being protected, not investigated. Now, at this level of course the main argument tends to be similar to the reasonsing used in the 2008 bailout, some variation of "but if we start prosecuting bankers, the banking system might collapse and the economy would tank and..." you get the idea. I don't buy that excuse. Anyway, the real point is that most of the reading I have done on the upper-level banking system indicates they have become supranational, interconnected systems in ways most people can barely understand. This paper is a key reading on this point: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1107.5728.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1107.5728.pdf As for citing sources on the relationship between Wall Street and City of London/Vatican, it gets much more tricky. This is the sort of stuff that I imagine would take a palantir type 6 degrees social graph to really unconver in a concrete way, so for now I have to admit it's mostly inductive instead of deductive reasoning. Many context clues from many books in aggregate have helped me form this opinion. Now, on to the even more slippery subject of secret societies and orders of knighthood. The bottom line is that I don't think anyone can claim to have a holistic grasp on geopolitics/economics/strategy and at the same time ignore the many secret societies associated, for reasons that seem obvious with a little thought. I mean, if you wanted to run a subversive intelligence network, isn't the compartmentalized nature of a secret society simply a mirror of the kind of compartmentalization an intelligence agency would use? (perhaps the agency is the mirror of the society, but I digress). It's just structually set up to allow for infiltration and subversion. Now, that's not to say that is what every society is used for, or that every member is used for. On the contrary, with the rings within rings structure, the vast majority of secret society members tend to have no clue whatsoever of what is happening at the upper level. (Very much like I claim of the CIA). They are useful bodies for cover. One very particular example of this would be P2 or Propaganda Due lodge. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_Due https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_Due For more a more scholarly type of look into this type of thing, the best author I could recommend would be Carroll Quigley. A professor of history at Georgetown, and cited by Bill Clinton as his mentor, he wrote extensively about the British round table groups influence being used as a rings within rings structure for the purposes of the British empire (later renamed the commonwealth for pr purposes). In large part, the origins of this structure was put in place by Cecil Rhodes, who got the inspiration from reading the documents of the actual Bavarian Illuminati of the late 1700's. It was always one point of contention between Quigley and what he called the plagarists (such as the John Birch society), that Rhodes was simply inspired by the rings within rings structure that Adam Weishaupt wrote about, and that there was no evidence for a connection between the ancient secret societies, and "the illuminati" and the Rhodes society group(s). (A common misconception among the lazy conspiracy theorist, even though I have found plenty of evidence that (free)masonry does get it's roots from Egyptian societies of builders, it's is often publicly disputed as otherwise.) As for the orders of knighthood, there are some very interesting connections between certain orders and certain types of military and clandenstine operations. For example, I have found an inordinate amount of (military) operator types and those associated have membership in the Knights of Malta, and other similar groups. Associations vary though, from more than just The Vatican, they include factions in the UK/EU royal houses and aristocracies. They are often at odds as well, the other common misconception of lazy conspiracy theorists is that there is a single monolithic group. Many factions exist whose interests sometimes align, and sometimes don't. There are power plays in this region most of the world never hears about. For example, recently: https://cruxnow.com/analysis/2017/01/29/popes-takeover-knights-malta-brings-chance-needed-reform/ https://cruxnow.com/analysis/2017/01/29/popes-takeover-knigh... Anyway, to summarize, these are difficult subjects that are complex, full of nuance, and often lengthy, and as such don't lend themselves well to such short-term outlets like a hn comment, but that's an introduction that might help steer your own research if you are genuinely curious. "I'm not sure what this is referring to. Can you elaborate?" This reffering to some things JFK said after the bay of pigs fiasco, talking about making a mistake by keeping Allen Dulles (who was conviently put in charge of the commision to investigate the assassination!), and talking about how he wanted to "splinter the CIA into a thousand pieces and scatter it into the winds." "Truman’s Secretary of State Dean Acheson wrote in his 1969 memoirs that upon the CIA’s creation he “had the gravest forebodings about this organization and warned the president that as set up neither he, the National Security Council, nor anyone else would be in a position to know what it was doing or to control it.”" https://theintercept.com/2016/02/22/in-1974-call-to-abolish-cia-sanders-followed-in-footsteps-of-jfk-truman/ https://theintercept.com/2016/02/22/in-1974-call-to-abolish-... "That will protect you in your home and on your personal devices (to a degree), but it doesn't protect you in public." I think that's a start. I'm aware that with technological progress public privacy is waning and will continue to do so, but we should at least remember the rights of privacy (including right to not be subject to search without warrant or probable cause) on our property, even if that property is digital. Capitulations about how privacy is already dead lack the nuance needed to really address the problems. We could just as easily setup attack resistent OS's and platforms as allow MS to monopolize the market. "the vast majority of our history was spent with no anonymity and little to no privacy" I would like to see what makes you think this is true. As far as I can tell, the vast majority of history was rife full of anonymity and privacy. Now, perhaps in a small village everyone in the village, or everyone in the family, knew what you were doing, but there is a big difference between immediate friends and family having first-hand knowledge of your goings and doings and them having knowledge of your goings and doings and storing them on insecure devices which the government can search surreptetiously at will and at a mass scale heretofore unimagined by all but the most forward looking thinkers such as Orwell and Huxley.