3 ms·
It's not really a double standard. A share of stock and an option to buy such share of stock are two distinct products, priced differently. E.g. MSFT share pri
by prostoalex 10y ago
It's not really a double standard. A share of stock and an option to buy such share of stock are two distinct products, priced differently.
E.g. MSFT share price today is $64.27, a contract allowing you to buy a share of MSFT on March 17, 2017 for $64 is 83c.
Investors buy their shares in full, cash-on-delivery, so to speak. Would investors like to be able to buy call options in the companies at pre-specified valuations for just 1.5% of the price and complete freedom to exercise (as well as forfeit) those options four years down the road? You betcha.
Not only do they need to pay significantly less to participate, they can spread those bets around and cover roughly 60x more companies, if they choose. Or double or triple down on this one specific company. Or just sell their option down the road in case it's the next FB or Uber without ever needing to put up cash.
Both investors and employees get to buy their shares for cash. Employees though do get the luxury of time, and can not only benefit immensely from stock's rise, but also save their hard-earned money in case of a dud. Investors do not get the latter option. Therefore they seek compensation elsewhere, usually in the liquidation preference department (which is moot anyways if the liquidation value is $0).
- acjohnson55 10y agoWell then that's doubly ironic, because most startup employees would probably much prefer to have shares over options. I know I would.
- prostoalex 10y agoIf the company allows 83(b) early exercise, they can.
- acjohnson55 10y agoYeah, but you still have to buy the shares at strike price. So not only are you getting paid below market rate, but you have to spend some of that pay exercise cost and taxes to have proper equity. So it's not so simple.
- prostoalex 10y agoWhat did you mean then by "much prefer to have shares over options"? I assumed this implied equal footing with the investors, and shares distributed in exchange for the check. If you have the means and are willing to tolerate the risk, shares are a better deal. If at least one of those components is missing, call options are a better deal.
- dlubarov 10y agoI don't think you're really justifying why employees and investors ought to have different terms. To the extend that investors need extra compensation, they can always be compensated with additional shares, regardless of those shares' terms. I think in an ideal world, investors would normally receive common stock (and more of it), but there are some practical reasons why that isn't the case: - Selling preferred stock lets a company declare a more lofty valuation. - If a company sold common stock to investors, they'd have to use the more realistic fundraising valuation when pricing options, rather than a (typically) more conservative 409a price. - Employees tend to not have access to the cap table, or not understand it, so there's not much disadvantage to giving them less favorable terms.
- prostoalex 10y agoI'd go with Occam's razor on this - investors always want preferred, the more preferences the merrier, companies always want to sell common, and if they could go sub-common (by stripping the shares of voting rights or dividend participation) they would. Whoever has the most leverage in the transaction tends to win.
- propter_hoc 10y agoThe basic reason that investor capital has a liquidation preference is that if it didn't, the founders could raise $X million on day N, then since they hold the majority of voting rights, declare bankruptcy on day N+1, and split the majority of the invested capital among each other. There are ways around this, such as giving the investor a veto on bankruptcies and reorganizations, but the time-honored solution is a 1x liquidation preference where the investor gets their capital back in a bankruptcy.