4 ms·
On a less sarcastic note, the fact that Western governments have such a difficult time gathering credible intelligence in North Korea is evidence that the North
by wahern 10y ago
On a less sarcastic note, the fact that Western governments have such a difficult time gathering credible intelligence in North Korea is evidence that the North Koreans have a robust intelligence apparatus.
What the whole Abdul Khan episode brought to light some years back was how Western agencies underestimated the technological and political skill and motivation of many so-called "third world" countries. Arguably that blind spot was caused by the deep-seated racism and cultural elitism of Western countries. There were plenty of opportunities to discover the illicit trade; we just weren't convinced they were capable of it, despite all the evidence to the contrary. Our leaders never took it seriously because their expectations were that these countries were still too backwards.
Yet another example of why we really need to face prejudice head on. We simply can't accurately assess the state of things if we're blinded by so many poor assumptions, particularly the ones girded by racist attitudes.
If American culture continues casting Asians as uncreative copycats; Muslims as radical fundamentalists; Africans as irredeemably corrupt; and South Americans as hopelessly socialist; then we're in for decades of more wild and very much unwelcome surprise.
- mulmen 10y agoThat's a lot of assumptions. You could say that the lack of another 9/11 type attack in recent history and the high failure rate of these missiles shows that the US Intelligence community has already overcome this prejudice.
- wahern 10y agoI think technocrats do a better job of overcoming it, if only because it's harder to ignore what's staring you in the face, and they're the ones with their noses to the ground. But priorities are set by the elites. We rarely encounter "slam dunks" that force leaders' hands. And so our strategic direction relies heavily on the higher-ups making decisions that are still highly susceptible to bias. Heck, we elect leaders precisely because of their bias--Obama because we thought he had an inside-line on the Muslim thing, Trump because we hate Muslims. I exaggerate but it's not far from the truth. That's why popular culture can be so critical to foreign policy. Two decades into peak globalization, there's no way to hide these things. This isn't the Cold War. Leaders can't do the smart thing while paying lip service to the electorates' prejudices. Even if we could stop all the leaks in the U.S. government, you can't hide the consequences of policy.
- wahern 10y agoAlso, I think it was only in the past few years that everybody finally accepted that North Korea has the bomb. As late as, what, 2013, we were still half-way convinced they were blowing up boxes of high-explosives to fool us. Even in 2016 some outlets were still hedging. Now, maybe the intelligence community came around much earlier. But certainly Congress was still having trouble coming to terms with the reality. Why? Because it was just so difficult to believe (and still difficult to believe) that such a repressive society could achieve such a feat. It is, admittedly, difficult to believe for me. But I understand part of that difficulty is because Westerner's believe that such feats aren't possible without a culture of individualism that unleashes individual initiative. Maybe such a culture is superior. But it clearly isn't necessary. And that should make us question much about what we think other countries are capable of, and when they'll be capable of it.
- trhway 10y ago>Because it was just so difficult to believe (and still difficult to believe) that such a repressive society could achieve such a feat. 194x-195x USSR wasn't a pinnacle of democracy and freedom. And technology and science back then was much less advanced than today.
- nl 10y agoAs late as, what, 2013, we were still half-way convinced they were blowing up boxes of high-explosives to fool us I think that's an exaggeration. I'd note this 2013 NYTimes article[1], which notes that all US intelligence agencies agreed that North Korea tested a bomb in 2006, but were unable to come to a consensus view as to if they were capable of miniaturizing it enough to put on a missile: an assessment by the Defense Intelligence Agency that it has “moderate confidence” that North Korea has the ability to shrink a nuclear weapon and fit it into a missile warhead surfaced at a Congressional hearing. That conclusion was disputed by James R. Clapper Jr., the director of national intelligence, who issued a statement later in the day saying that it did not reflect “the consensus” of the nation’s intelligence community. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/13/world/asia/contrasting-views-on-north-korea-underscore-sensitivities-and-lack-of-evidence.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/13/world/asia/contrasting-vie...
- ams6110 10y agoNone of the "deep-seated racism and cultural elitism" you cite is at all unique to Western countries.
- inimino 10y agoDid the GP say anywhere that it was?
- douche 10y agoSince at least the end of the Cold War, human intelligence operations have been allowed to wither and fade in preference for all manner of whizz-bang electronic intelligence methods. That's a lack of investment that isn't quick to turn around.