3 ms·
To me the most important reason that you can't be forced to disclose a password is that it is impossible to prove that you know it at all. So you can always say
by kevincox 10y ago
To me the most important reason that you can't be forced to disclose a password is that it is impossible to prove that you know it at all. So you can always say "I don't know it" or "I forgot it" so these constitutional rights are basically ensuing you won't get tortured/harassed for something you couldn't reveal.
However with fingerprints you can "prove" that you can't unlock the phone by touching all the fingers to it so the problem doesn't apply.
Basicly there is nothing special about encrypted data, only the "data" inside your head.
- r00fus 10y agoOn Apple's implementation, this wouldn't work; you're allowed five guesses before it reverts to password only, and you have 10 fingers. Theoretically, you could encode using a rare finger (left ring) and exhaust the retries with the other ones. So I'd argue also unconstitutional to force unlocking.
- kevincox 10y agoYes, I thought about this by it seems slightly removed from my core point. They could force you to put whatever fingers they wanted on the sensor. Of course if you can touch the wrong finger enough times before they get the phone they are still out of luck. My argument is that they can make you touch the sensor because that isn't something you can prentend to not be able to do. It is somewhat immerterial if it actually unlocks the phone or not.
- rad88 10y agoOn the face of it, claiming you lack the ability to access your own phone appears evasive and dishonest. Beware of this. Apparently misleading or obstructive behavior might cause more severe consequences than invoking your legal right to remain silent, speak with an attorney, etc. Asserting constitutional protections against unlawful search or self incrimination is not an antagonistic act and is less likely to anger an officer or escalate their investigation.