3 ms·
They would have had a better outcome if they had no policy at all. "Better outcome" meaning they would have been able to shirk responsibility and the woman wou
by rhizome 10y ago
They would have had a better outcome if they had no policy at all.
"Better outcome" meaning they would have been able to shirk responsibility and the woman would have been sent packing with nothing? I weep for the future.
Think about what you're arguing for.
- gpawl 10y agoIf they get punished MORE for having the policy than for not, that incentivizes having NO policy, which leads to more minor injuries without preventing the major injury. Similar to how no one in industry reads patents (opposite of the intended purpose of knowledge-sharing) because they get treble damages if they are found infringing while being aware of the patent.
- derefr 10y agoI believe the parent is arguing for act-consequentialism, rather than rule-consequentialism. A similar argument is against the usefulness of case-law in the court system—it often prevents a judge from making the best possible decision for the particulars of the case.
- rhizome 10y agoFrom the Supreme Court confirmation hearings I've paid attention to, it seems that there are reasonable questions on both sides of stare decisis, but I don't think moving to a non-deterministic legal system would be the answer.
- mannykannot 10y agoAn argument for the usefulness of case law is that provides some damping and feedback against the consequences of judgments that the judge merely thinks is the best possible decision.