4 ms·
The move was ethically challenged and morally bankrupt, but you have to admit it was a pretty clever hack.
by jedberg 10y ago
The move was ethically challenged and morally bankrupt, but you have to admit it was a pretty clever hack.
- r00fus 10y agoOne wonders whether it's particularly clever - it's the same model that is used by the US when aid programs force the aid recipients to hire US contracting/construction companies. [1] https://www.thenation.com/article/usaid-helping-haiti-recover-or-us-contractors-make-millions/ https://www.thenation.com/article/usaid-helping-haiti-recove...
- smnscu 10y agoSorry if I'm being naive, but isn't that like owning a McDonald's and giving homeless people money as long as they spend it at your restaurant? I don't think it's nearly as bad.
- Qwertious 10y agoSure, except in this analogy McDonalds needs to be 100 times more expensive than local restaurants.
- got2surf 10y agoYou're right, very clever, but morally dubious, especially around something as important as cancer screening. Soon-Shiong would probably argue that he was able to get valuable results for the university while also supporting a cancer detection technology that would be a net-win for the future. Definitely shady, but did the donation still make the world a better place?
- mikeyouse 10y agoClever-ish but almost certainly illegal, the University should be very concerned about maintaining their nonprofit status. Self-dealing like that with no variance power is one of the very bright red lines that (c)(3)s should not cross.
- deckar01 10y agoWhat could they have done differently to make the donation unquestionably legal and morally sound (while still maximizing their personal benefit)? Does the company need to donate the services directly?
- smallgovt 10y agoI think this is the most interesting question in the thread. When viewed as a donation of services instead of cash, he's simply giving his product away for free in order to collect data to improve his product. In its own right, I'd argue that certainly should be considered charity and deserving of praise. The questionable part about this transaction seems to pertain to the tax deductions taken. However, it strikes me as unlikely that the loss on the donation withstanding any reasonable tax deduction would be covered by any personal payback on the donation.
- gnicholas 10y agoThe company could have donated the services, but that wouldn't have had the same impact. The donor got a big tax deduction, which then translated into revenue and data collection for his company. If the company had simply donated the services, it wouldn't have looked like they got a big contract. They also wouldn't have gotten the cash infusion, from the founder and funneled through the university.
- ABCLAW 10y agoI'm not sure why people are praising a kickback that was documented in a set of contracts as clever - The fact that you've read about it means that it was done poorly. All that's left is an illegal and unethical transaction designed to mislead investors.
- x0x0 10y agoYeah, I was wondering who got hurt here -- the University at least got $2m plus what seems to be valid omics data -- when I figured out it was the investors. The money was carefully laundered through Univ of Utah so this seemed like an arms-length contract, rather than self-dealing.
- draw_down 10y agoYes. Lord knows we need more ethically-challenged, morally-bankrupt, clever people in this world.
- ska 10y agoDepending on the industry/area involved, "clever" might better be described as "fairly standard practice". This isn't by any measure a new idea.