6 ms·
Thank you for the reply. Can you actually give some kind of a list though? The entire problem here is everyone explains the how but no one is willing to explain
by mehrdadn 10y ago
Thank you for the reply. Can you actually give some kind of a list though? The entire problem here is everyone explains the how but no one is willing to explain the who. I certainly understand it's "multiple sources", I'm asking who are these sources I keep hearing about. There can't be nearly as many sources as there are sites who buy from them. If you'd like to not name the company you worked for yourself then could you at least please list as many other ones as possible? That would be far, far more helpful than just saying they use machine learning and that they use multiple sources, etc.
- blackbagboys 10y agoThere is no such public list. Most of these companies are privately held, their methods are trade secrets, and there is no real form of legal recourse. Your best bet would be to buy a book like this: https://www.amazon.com/Hiding-Internet-Eliminating-Personal-Information/dp/1500397814 https://www.amazon.com/Hiding-Internet-Eliminating-Personal-... and follow the recommendations, but even that is only likely to be half-effective. Much of the public information is mined from sources like credit headers, your court records, utility bills, property and tax assessment records, voter registration lists, motor vehicle registrations, etc. Unfortunately, the legal and technological landscape is such that 'hiding' from these kinds of services is effectively impossible.
- mehrdadn 10y ago> There is no such public list. Most of these companies are privately held, their methods are trade secrets, and there is no real form of legal recourse. How can there not be a public list of these data miners? When e.g. a court needs to control someone's information surely they know who these people are and they can let them know? Is there a secret list in every courthouse or something? Or when someone wants to start another one of the higher-level companies -- how do they know which core aggregators to buy from? If that's a secret then how would they find out? Surely someone's gotta be willing to tell?
- twblalock 10y ago> When e.g. a court needs to control someone's information surely they know who these people are and they can let them know? Is there a secret list in every courthouse or something? The courts don't control information in that way.
- mehrdadn 10y agoThat's surprising. So what happens when there is a high profile case and the court fears for the jurors' lives? Or the case itself involves someone whose life will be in danger afterwards? If anybody can find out where these people live then they're toast. The courts have to suppress the information legally somehow, right? If not the old information, at least they need some protection against mining of new information after the subjects move or change their names, no? Are you literally saying they have no way to order all the first-level companies to stop sharing data on someone?
- pc86 10y ago> So what happens when there is a high profile case and the court fears for the jurors' lives? Jurors' identities are not generally a secret.[0] There are exceptions, but those exceptions do not extend to wiping that person's data from things like pharmacy and gas station reward card databases. Honestly your entire premise shows a lack of understanding of how the criminal justice system works. > Are you literally saying they have no way to order all the first-level companies to stop sharing data on someone? Sue all of them individually, win each case, and have them ordered to stop collecting data on you. Something tell me this is tantamount to "don't use a computer or a credit card. Ever." [0] http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/public-access-to-juror-information-in-a-criminal-trial.html http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/public-access-...
- mehrdadn 10y ago> Jurors' identities are not generally a secret.[0] There are exceptions I was talking about the exceptions. If there are exceptions, a way to handle them must exist, is all I was saying. > but those exceptions do not extend to wiping that person's data from things like pharmacy and gas station reward card databases. I was asking about the companies who obtain this original information, not pharmacies' or gas stations' databases themselves. I feel like you're not understanding my question? > Honestly your entire premise shows a lack of understanding of how the criminal justice system works. Quiet likely (I'm not claiming otherwise; I'm not a lawyer and I haven't exactly been involved in legal proceedings) and I didn't claim otherwise. Also hardly undermines my point. Like I've said in some 3-4 other comments, someone who e.g. starts a new company like InstantCheckmate has to know whom to buy the data from -- like I said, there's no way all of these companies contact all grocery stores and all doctors. That's insane. Someone's gotta be doing the heavy lifting and making money off it. I'm asking who this is. I asked this in the original post. If the court example is wrong or otherwise bothers you just ignore it. If someone not already involved in the business knows to contact these companies to obtain information, someone must know who they are, is all I'm saying. Otherwise they would not exist.
- sbov 10y agoI have a friend who is super paranoid about privacy stuff. He was even able to get his utility bills to use a PO box rather than his home address, which he said was extremely difficult.
- protomyth 10y agoDepends where you are in the country. Many rural places don't have home delivery and only have P.O. Boxes. Home delivery from Amazon, etc. requires a bit of work.
- VLM 10y agoI can give you one very specific answer in that my late father decades ago worked in IT for a collections agency and one way that biz works is they pay a fixed amount to buy some companies 120+ day accounts receivable file (the feds and every state highly regulates this and its highly variable and complicated, but this is the simplified version...) and this gave them a vast pile of records and legal ability to collect the debt. Now obviously they got most of their revenue by annoying the heck out of debtors right up to the legal limit. But they're leaving money on the table if they don't resell all the data they can legally sell. So sure, even 20+ years ago collections agencies were uploading records to various data aggregators in exchange for a check. Not just the original debt but followup activity and intel WRT the collections process. I would imagine that's only increased over the last couple decades. Most of these data transfers were two way streets, not simple data for money trade, and obviously they maximized profits by leaning the hardest on the people most likely to actually pay up, they did not waste time on debtors known to other collections agencies as hopeless deadbeats.
- pandabear187 10y agoI can provide all the sources used for the company I used to work for, however that's irrelevant if you as you said wanted to learn how to fish. Any and every company selling data and there are thousands is in fact a source you would need to deal with to be removed from the sites that sell it. If you think this answer isn't specific enough, you're not going to achieve anything by me spoonfeeding you info for one such company.
- samstave 10y ago>I can provide all the sources used for the company I used to work for, however that's irrelevant if you as you said wanted to learn how to fish. Personally, I think this should be a requirement of the government: "HERE IS A LIST OF ALL PEOPLE THAT ARE COLECTING AND SELLING YOUR PERSONAL DATA, CLICK THIS BUTTON TO DELETE YOUR RECORDS" sort of thing... it should be a mandated public service of regulation. Then, they have a list of all opt-outs from which companies you may have selected to opt-out from, and you can simply send them any further contact from the opted-out companies you may receive and the company gets a fine, you get a compensation fee...
- pandabear187 10y ago2 things, 1.)if you make government enforce this, then we are all going to be paying more and things taking longer. This will push the society toward a fascist or communist states where the government is the all powerful and might beast. I do not like this. 2.) in western countries there are already laws that allow you as the consumer to remove any personally identifiable information from being shared. The ownus is on YOU to go do that, it's not hard but will require to track and follow up every year for ever. However you also have a choice of companies that you provide the information to, and what you provide. Any credit agency when you apply for credit asks if you would allow them to resell this. Opt out! The fact that in most cases people are to lazy to read and understand what they are provinding and for what purpose is the real issue here. Government is not going to make things better or more secure or even be able to enforce this type of governance. Only you and the lawyers can do this.
- 10y ago
- dqv 10y agoIf I was a company, I would be writing scraping engines that scraped * police 2 citizen (a platform many counties and municipalities use to report crime and accidents to the public) * any public facing dataworks plus web application (or whatever various other municipalities/counties are running): the one for the county I live in lists the arrestee's employer * district level and state level court dockets * real estate records, which also link up to tax bills * public voter records Not surprisingly, only the information I've ever listed on my voter ID has ever showed up in Intelius/LexisNexis databases.
- justin66 10y ago> There can't be nearly as many sources as there are sites who buy from them. Sure there can. The sources include state, county, and local governments. There are a lot of those.
- tracker1 10y agoIf you ever buy anything with a CC, use a "membership" card anywhere, or have anything delivered, or for that matter purchased online, then there's a greater chance than not this data was shared by the merchant, transaction provider and/or the credit card company themselves. If you have an online profile, with any friends that aren't paranoid, and allow your friends to see any private information, then this can be collected/correlated by the various bot farms.