5 ms·
The article heavily promotes the idea of the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J, where both the authors of the article are situated. Richard Feynma
by teddyh 10y ago
The article heavily promotes the idea of the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J, where both the authors of the article are situated. Richard Feynman rather famously argued against places like that: http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/52/2/dignified.htm http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/52/2/dignified.htm
“Nothing happens because there’s not enough real activity and challenge: You’re not in contact with the experimental guys. You don’t have to think how to answer questions from the students. Nothing!”
- js8 10y agoI didn't read it completely yet but the opening sentence "At least I’m living; at least I’m doing something; I’m making some contribution" is resonating with me strongly. Coming from an academic family, I tried to do PhD but it was just 2 years of procrastination. So I decided, screw it, I'll find a job, and I am a programmer in a corporation since. It's pretty good, but somehow I wish I had more time to pursue things that go beyond one quarter. So I wish, like Feynman did, there was a place where I could do normal programming most of the time and yet when I have an idea, to pursue that idea. Google 20% time comes close (although it has really been dead for maybe 10 years), but it's still not quite that. And you could have that for any field, not just software. So perhaps we don't need ivory towers where people pursue basic research full-time, but something more balanced.
- nostrademons 10y ago20% time isn't dead, but it's also not useful for what you want it for. 20% time rarely works for projects that stretch much beyond a quarter. The amount of attention you can devote to them prevents you from finishing them in a timely-enough manner that the initial conditions which made you think of the idea still hold. (Trust me, I spent 3 years of 20% time writing an HTML5 parser that was largely obsolete by the time it was released. It was desperately needed when I started it in 2010 and the only options were validator.nu and html5lib. It wasn't so needed by the time it was released in 2013 and you also had JSoup, Hubbub, html5ever, and probably others to choose from.) Same reason part-time startups usually go nowhere. I think that the system that actually does work is something like Silicon Valley, where if in the course of your job, you see an idea, you can just quit and try it. If it doesn't work out, there's always another job out there waiting, which won't hold the work you spent on that idea against you. Anyone with a modicum of financial discipline should also be able to save enough money off a Silicon Valley engineer salary that they have the option to go a year or two without income, too.
- kbenson 10y ago> Anyone with a modicum of financial discipline should also be able to save enough money off a Silicon Valley engineer salary that they have the option to go a year or two without income, too. Is that supposed to still hold true with a family and mortgage, or is it just me that finds that hard? I can totally understand swinging that with less life responsibilities, but I find it hard to save in this region where the cost of living is so high and there's five of us. :/
- nostrademons 10y agoIt still holds true, but you have to settle for a lower standard of living (in terms of living space) than you would elsewhere in the country. My wife grew up in Cupertino and thinks it strange that I want our eventual kids to have their own bedrooms; she shared a room with her brother until she was about 10. We live in a 2BR townhome and the other units in the complex (all 2BR) include a family with 4 kids and a grandfather; a family with 3 kids; and a multi-generational family with a couple, the wife's mother, and an infant. The bargain you make for Silicon Valley is that you'll have great career opportunities, a laid-back work environment, huge diversity of food & culture, awesome outdoor sports and great weather, and a small shot at great wealth, and in return you put up with terrible traffic, near-constant work, lots of superficial people, and crummy housing stock that, if it doesn't fall down in an earthquake, will be eaten by termites in 10 years. Some people like that bargain, some don't - and in particular, it's often a better bargain when you're young than when you're older. If you don't, you should carefully consider whether Silicon Valley is the right place for you.
- kbenson 10y agoWhat I hate is that new construction in the area seems somewhat brain dead too. I have a fairly large house, but I'm also an hour north of SF, which while better, really just means that prices are very, very high instead of insane. My daughters share a room because even though I'm drowning in space, most of it is very poorly utilized in new construction (and this is new). My home office is in one of the walk in closets off the master, and I comfortably use less than half of it. My master bedroom is large enough to make two rooms easily, but the layout makes that impracticable. The one saving grace? The large formal living room which we converted to the main office for my fiance's business (fully utilized, shelves stacked with supplies on all walls). The other options in the area? 50 year old houses with 75% the floor space (admittedly better used), and an actual back yard. Same listing price range, but you'll have to fix a lot of stuff immediately or soon. Being new factored heavily into our decision process, but at this point I'm thinking we might have made a poor choice. Then again, the grass is always greener...
- kbenson 10y agoFrom what I hear (from discussion between Googlers here even), is that 20% is alive and well, but is somewhat manager specific in how it's carried out and what is exected. On the other hand, some descriptions of people using 20% time sounds like it just opens the door to them feeling okay about using company time to persue open source side projects with or without approval, as long as they are getting their work done. That's probably a good middle-road, because as long as the company is happy with your performance, and you are happy with the possibility that not spending that extra time to wow your managers might delay your advancement somewhat, it's probably as open as you could want. This of course assumes a salaried position.
- d0mine 10y agoThe link that you've provided is the example for not against such institutions. The quote: "There was no importance to what I was doing, but ultimately there was. "
- mtdewcmu 10y agoI would think that having grad students around would be good for keeping things fresh and lively.
- codersarepeople 10y agoFeynman was talking about IAS in his days. I've been a PhD student in Princeton for 5 years, and there's plenty of interaction between students and IAS faculty. The difference is IAS people aren't responsible for their students. You could make the argument that IAS people aren't FORCED to interact with students, but the opportunities are there I think.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]