3 ms·
If you are seriously considering going into this business, consider also the possibility that somebody will figure out a way to make an LCD screen that is accep
by jerf 10y ago
If you are seriously considering going into this business, consider also the possibility that somebody will figure out a way to make an LCD screen that is acceptable for this use case once the CRTs are no longer available. Light-guns are likely gone no matter what, or at least going to be inconsistent and hard to use, but an LCD screen explicitly designed to emulate a CRT may be able to fill in. LCD screens not explicitly designed for this use case are getting down to ~25ms latencies, which is getting to within spitting distance of one frame.
It seems to me there's no fundamental reason that an LCD can't be designed nowadays to paint the screen almost identically to the way a CRT did it, complete with an emulation of their "flaws" (with at least a line or two of buffering to pull that off). The fact that older LCDs use an internal framebuffer and are locked to a certain refresh rate seems like an artifact of the older technology rather than a fundamental limitation. Just as G-Sync and friends can start playing with the refresh rate it seems like nothing would prevent you from designing an LCD controller that doesn't wait for an entire frame but just starts painting the NTSC or similar signal.
If I'm wrong, I eagerly await informative corrections. But bear in mind I'm aware that I'm calling for fairly significantly different supporting electronics behind the panel, that work on a fundamentally different architecture than current LCD panels. I do realize this is a non-trivial modification.
You'd have to run numbers but it's possible this is more cost-effective than trying to source all the CRT parts and/or run your own manufacturing line; this approach would involve creating custom electronics (feasible even for a startup) and then sticking them on commodity screens, which is almost certainly much cheaper than trying to make CRTs.
Edit: Apparently I have gored some sort of sacred ox or something? I'm getting downmodded for this? Really? I'm talking about deeply redesigning how LCD screens work, so your current issues with LCD screens don't apply any longer. There are some things about how LCDs work now that are historical accident, not fundamental to the technology.
- chongli 10y ago25ms is still several orders of magnitude too slow for a lightgun. It's important to remember that ~16ms is the approximate time for a CRT to paint an entire frame at 60hz. A lightgun is way, way faster than that. It needs to determine the x and y position of the user's aim. To accomplish this means being faster than a horizontal pulse (the signal that draws one line of pixels) which in the case of NTSC is 4.85µs. I highly doubt you can get an LCD to refresh that quickly since the process involves actual physical twisting of liquid crystals in response to a change in electric current.
- DonnyV 10y agoThis is assuming that no one will just make a new lightgun that works with LCDs.
- chongli 10y agoThe discussion is in the context of playing classic arcade games. A new lightgun would not work with these games.
- jerf 10y ago"Light-guns are likely gone no matter what, or at least going to be inconsistent and hard to use," If I am correct about how the LCDs could be redesigned to work, I can imagine a world where you're paying about 1ms + the actual liquid crystal latency for the display which can apparently also be in low-single-digit milliseconds, which is probably good enough even for frame-perfect fighting games, but you're still going to have a screen that is fundamentally persistent rather than a scanning flash of light. (Possibly 3 or 4 ms if you're going to do some basic CRT emulation. Such emulation wouldn't be able to do full screen distortions induced by too much brightness, but even in the CRT era that was considered a failure, not a feature. It should be able to do slight persistence and local blurring.)
- Kubuxu 10y agoModern 144Hz LCDs are getting close to sub 1ms latency and we have 200Hz LCDs coming out.
- chongli 10y agosub 1ms latency Which is still several orders of magnitude slower what is needed to simulate a scanning electron beam in order to make lightguns work.
- kalleboo 10y agoCouldn't light guns be emulated? Use something wii-mote-ish, and then when the trigger is pulled, wait the requisite time after the next frame to trigger.