5 ms·
I appreciate your practical comments. This particular caught my eye: >"Previously I used Epp's book [1] which in my opinion is an outstanding book but regretta
by bogomipz 10y ago
I appreciate your practical comments. This particular caught my eye:
>"Previously I used Epp's book [1] which in my opinion is an outstanding book but regrettably is $280.44."
This is extortionate. What is the justification for a book being priced at nearly $300? This is one book of how many a student will need that semester? Are school's getting a piece of this as well? Is this why such a racket is permitted?
Sorry I know its tangential to your original comment but I would be curios to hear anyone's feedback, especially someone from Europe or elsewhere. I wonder if this pricing is specific to the U.S.
- dboreham 10y agoPerhaps those of us who seek to make money from entrepreneurial activities should instead wonder at the business skills of people who are able to extract $300 from their customers for a book?
- babygoat 10y ago"How can I get in on that extorting?"
- jcranmer 10y ago> This is extortionate. What is the justification for a book being priced at nearly $300? This is one book of how many a student will need that semester? Are school's getting a piece of this as well? Is this why such a racket is permitted? That is a bit high for textbooks, most textbooks are usually "only" in the realm of $80-160. That said, math textbooks are usually far more expensive than others. The excuse given for high prices is that there is a strong used book market for college textbooks, as most students sell off their textbooks at the end of the semester, so from the point of view of the publisher, they see only one sale in 5-20. Of course, publishers discovered that the "cure" for this is to release new editions of textbooks with minor updates (most importantly, reorder the questions in the question banks!) every few years to kill off the used textbook market and haven't lowered their exorbitant prices to compensate. As an undergrad, I did have one semester where my total book costs were about $1000. Most of the semesters, they were more like $500. Oh, and the prices usually go to lining the publishers' pockets. Not the authors', not the schools'.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"The excuse given for high prices is that there is a strong used book market for college textbooks, as most students sell off their textbooks at the end of the semester, so from the point of view of the publisher, they see only one sale in 5-20." Right, and couldn't they make up for this by issuing e-Textbooks with lower prices that would much higher volume in terms of sales? Also I believe the book stores themselves are in this farce, as large percentage of the bookstores are not run by the schools but private companies such as Barnes and Noble and Follet[1]. So they are making out in this scheme as well. [1]http://www.businessinsider.com/textbook-publishers-going-after-college-bookstores-with-big-e-book-discounts-2010-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/textbook-publishers-going-aft...
- Finnucane 10y agoI spent a little time working at Pearson on a textbook project, and yeah, they're pretty profitable, but the up-front costs are enormous. The production budget for the biology book I worked on was $10 million. And that was for a book that would be widely used at the high-school level. For a math book like this, I'd guess they spent more like a million getting it done. I wouldn't be surprised if it was $50-100K just for the typesetting.
- digler999 10y ago> The production budget for the biology book I worked on was $10 million Most of that probably went to lobbying public school district administrators to uses Pearson's edition. you know, "greasing the wheels".
- tzs 10y agoThere is something more than just high production costs going on, though, for math books. Consider Apostol's "Calculus". Volume I new is $150-270 on Amazon. Volume II new is $160-270. These were first published around 1961. A second edition of Volume I was published in 1967, and a second edition of Volume II in 1969. There have been no further editions. The schools that use Apostol today are still using those late '60s second editions. They were about $20 per volume when I bought them in 1977, which is equivalent to about $80 per volume in today's money.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> What is the justification for a book being priced at nearly $300? It's a product of a capitalist, for-profit producer. The justift for its price is that the market will bear it.
- bogomipz 10y agoIs that a real market though when it is mandated that I must purchase one specific book? So I don't think your "this is just how capitalism works" argument holds much credibility here.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Is that a real market though when it is mandated that I must purchase one specific book? A real market? Absolutely. An idealized free market, no, but real markets never are. > So I don't think your "this is just how capitalism works" argument holds much credibility here. This is, in fact, just how capitalism works, and has always worked, in the real world.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"This is, in fact, just how capitalism works, and has always worked, in the real world." A central tenet of capitalism is a competitive market though. Where is the competition when I am mandated to buy a single book?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> A central tenet of capitalism is a competitive market though It's true that a lot of the defense of capitalism that was ginned up (long) after the system was described and named by its critics involves invoking all kinds of hokum about markets which are both free and competitive which not only has nothing to do with anything in the history of capitalism, but isn't even all that internally consistent because of the tendency toward monopoly in unregulated markets where producers experience economies of scale (and in some other common cases.) But this is a (deeply flawed) rationalization of capitalism, not its foundation.
- feyman_r 10y agoI heard an interesting take on this on the Planet Money podcast. While I still think books are over-priced here, it allowed me to think of different 'forces' that shape book prices: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/03/353300404/episode-573-why-textbook-prices-keep-climbing http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/03/353300404/episo...