4 ms·
The date of Easter depends on which calendar you use. The second largest christian church uses a different calendar than the largest one.
by maxerickson 10y ago
The date of Easter depends on which calendar you use. The second largest christian church uses a different calendar than the largest one.
- scandox 10y agoYes he stumbled into a particularly thorny theological matter there. The Quartodecimans are going to hunt him down.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoIt's a great point. It shows how easy it is for somebody to think wow, that question obviously has a clear answer when the opposite is true. Take the lead example: Was President Warren Harding a member of the KKK? We know the KKK said he was. We know he vigorously denied it. We know that biographers of him and experts in his history do not think he was. But how could you ever prove that somebody was not the member of a secret society? The entire purpose of secret societies is that the outside world will never know if you're a member or not. Look, I'm happy to assume he wasn't, and at some point only kooks continue to chase things down past all reason, but just assume for a second that he was, and that somehow that fact could be determined but the research has not been done yet. So history student X starts wondering about it one day and types the question into Google. Never fear! Google has the answer: he wasn't. And this is Google's answer because this answer has the benefit of looking the most plausible to the greatest number of people. Student X has an answer, gives it no more thought, and wanders off to think about other matters. Student X is now more stupid. The world as a whole is now less productive. And some preponderance of data that academics have assembled somewhere around the year 2015 has become truth for all time. That's amazingly fucked up, Google. Please stop.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, that was my intended meaning. There probably is an argument to be made that in most English speaking countries "Easter" refers to the date calculated using the Gregorian calender, with some qualifier being used to specify the other date (Google answers searches for "eastern easter 2018" and "orthodox easter 2018" with the correct information).
- theseatoms 10y agoGoogle should report a probability distribution for each truth claim.
- jerf 10y agoWhile an interesting idea in theory... and I mean that!... in practice that's saying they just shouldn't provide answers. Even saying for the sake of argument that Google could assemble a meaningful and correct probability distribution, itself a rather bold statement, the average Google user won't know how to correctly interpret such a thing.
- Bartweiss 10y agoAnd realistically, asking for probability distributions over unbounded sample spaces is trouble even for human experts. I suppose the space for "are mermaids real?" is workable (there are caveats like "yes but extinct", but yes/no is basically sufficient), but for anything subjective or political it's almost hopeless. That said, this is a really interesting idea for behind-the-scenes work. The public might not want percentages, but I suspect experts could get some interesting results by diving into confidence levels and secondary answers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- forgottenpass 10y agoBut google isn't even making a truth claim. Google fundamentally doesn't understand the claim, or how to grade it. All the google engine knows is the statistical properties of words and phrases involved and associated with the claim.
- Sharlin 10y agoPlus, of course, it depends on which year you're talking about, in a very nontrivial fashion. Googling "when is easter" gives the date of the current year's Easter, which is reasonable, but might lead to an incorrect assumption that the date of Easter is fixed.
- deong 10y agoThat's true, but I don't think it's a problem. That's a question that just has two separate intentions, and even the world's foremost expert on Easter could give you the wrong one. If Google were as good as the best human experts at answering any question, then I think we'd have to declare victory and live with the occasional miscommunication, just as we do today.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoI think the crux of the issue is that real experts in any area, when presented with a question in their field, will answer "That depends" and then engage you in a conversation that ends with you being more knowledgeable about the specific question you should have asked, and why. This is because most areas of human endeavor aren't solid sciences like physics, although for most day-to-day activity we treat them as if they were. I do not care about the nuances of Easter as long as I can get the flowers delivered to my grandma on the correct day. But I do care about the nuances in a ton of other situations, and the dividing line isn't so clear. Simply BSing an answer that's good enough for most cases actually ends up hurting the rest of us more than it helps us. For lack of a better term, it's fake facts.
- thwarted 10y agoI think the crux of the issue is that real experts in any area, when presented with a question in their field, will answer "That depends" and then engage you in a conversation that ends with you being more knowledgeable about the specific question you should have asked, and why. While I actively encourage this method of inquiry and information acquisition, I've found that people often don't care to know why their question isn't even wrong, and challenging it leads to a defensive posture. This conversation is only keeping them from getting an answer and the expert risks being labeled as "uncooperative" because they refuse to provide an answer. This is a social problem, and it won't have a technical solution.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis is a really good example of the problem. We aren't just struggling with subjective questions or machine learning getting tricked by fantasy (e.g. mermaids). We're also up against the fact that even very simple questions can't necessarily be answered cleanly. Does Google show different Easter results based on location? I'll bet it does.
- rdlecler1 10y agoYes, but Wikipedia recognizes this fact.