4 ms·
I hear this argument so often. It's complicated because the human organism is complicated. Counting calories is a good approximation but it is only an approxi
by klodolph 10y ago
I hear this argument so often. It's complicated because the human organism is complicated. Counting calories is a good approximation but it is only an approximation. The error for calories in a nutrition label is up to 20%, and that is based on an approximation to begin with (e.g. 4 kCal/g for protein). Beyond that, people have different digestive systems with different efficiencies for absorbing nutrients from different sources.
Then there's the soft factors. Counting calories is a lot of work, not many people stick through it. You end up with a lot of gaps in your data anyway, unless you give up eating foods that you can't source good data for. Psychologically we are fairly bad at estimating portion sizes. There are a ton of situations (restaurants, potlucks, etc.) where calorie counting becomes impractical or cumbersome.
On top of that, there's the changes in mood that come with reduced caloric intake. Again, different from person to person. Not simple.
I guess if you phrase it as "eat less, lose weight" then it's simple, but eating and your waistline are far from the only thing in your life. Calories in, calories out is a pretty solid theory but doing the numbers is a different matter.