4 ms·
Why does everyone need to make weight loss so complicated? All you need to do is burn more calories each day than you consume. If you're not exercising, you're
by chatmasta 10y ago
Why does everyone need to make weight loss so complicated? All you need to do is burn more calories each day than you consume. If you're not exercising, you're still burning calories, so in that case you just need to eat less than you're burning!
Maybe the trouble is people exercise and then they think they're hungrier than they are so they eat more calories than they even burned.
- oxide 10y agoCalories in, calories out. I know this because I struggle to gain weight, quite the opposite problem most folk have. If I eat over 3k calories, I gain weight. If I eat less than 3k, I lose it. Not tracking my calories and quitting my workouts due to wisdom teeth extraction and a nasty sinus infection turned chronic has cost me 20lbs. 20lbs I worked very, very hard to gain. Consuming half a gallon of whole milk a day, forcing myself to eat even when I had no appetite, etc. Working out. I felt great and looked better than I had in awhile. All gone now, back to square one. My goal is to get over this sinus infection, (black plague, whatever it is) continue counting calories, as well as exercising, to put that weight back on and then some.
- return0 10y agoTime is your friend. After 30 it becomes a lot easier :)
- coldtea 10y agoTime is not exactly a friend. After 30 parent might have the opposite problem...
- return0 10y agoits a bad friend
- kpil 10y agoNot to mention 40! I must say that the bends in the graph is very noticeable.
- durzagott 10y agoNot always true. I'm now 40 and still struggle to keep my weight up. Same as OP I have to consume a large number of calories throughout the day, eating every two hours. If I let my guard down I slide back to 145 lbs within a few weeks and have to climb the mountain all over again. Age has yet to cure me of this.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- klodolph 10y agoI hear this argument so often. It's complicated because the human organism is complicated. Counting calories is a good approximation but it is only an approximation. The error for calories in a nutrition label is up to 20%, and that is based on an approximation to begin with (e.g. 4 kCal/g for protein). Beyond that, people have different digestive systems with different efficiencies for absorbing nutrients from different sources. Then there's the soft factors. Counting calories is a lot of work, not many people stick through it. You end up with a lot of gaps in your data anyway, unless you give up eating foods that you can't source good data for. Psychologically we are fairly bad at estimating portion sizes. There are a ton of situations (restaurants, potlucks, etc.) where calorie counting becomes impractical or cumbersome. On top of that, there's the changes in mood that come with reduced caloric intake. Again, different from person to person. Not simple. I guess if you phrase it as "eat less, lose weight" then it's simple, but eating and your waistline are far from the only thing in your life. Calories in, calories out is a pretty solid theory but doing the numbers is a different matter.
- zelos 10y agoWe've long thought of weight loss in simple "calories in, calories out" terms...Today, researchers view this rule as overly simplistic. They now think of human energy balance as "a dynamic and adaptable system,"
- GunlogAlm 10y agoIt's the idea you need a caloric deficit of 3,500 kcal in order to lose 1lb of fat that they're describing as 'overly simplistic', based on this study: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4035446/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4035446/ At the end of the day, weight loss is still calories in, calories out -- as frustrating as that can be.
- jeremy151 10y agoThe complication is that long term weight loss is functionally a behavioral challenge, and getting human beings to make long term behavioral change is not easy. Sure, maintain calorie balance or deficit and you'll be fine, but it's exceedingly rare that someone will track calories for their entire life. So we're left with either retraining their ability to intuit what they should be eating on a daily basis, and/or eating the types of foods that tend to make this job easier. That's where you start to end up with all the varied advice—it's an attempt to overcome behavior. If everyone had a perfect willpower, obesity would be an easy solve.
- sgift 10y agoOr maybe because that view is overly simplistic - to quote the article: We've long thought of weight loss in simple "calories in, calories out" terms. In a much-cited 1958 study, researcher Max Wishnofsky outlined a rule that many organizations — from the Mayo Clinic to Livestrong — still use to predict weight loss: A pound of human fat represents about 3,500 calories; therefore cutting 500 calories per day, through diet or physical activity, results in about a pound of weight loss per week. Similarly, adding 500 calories a day results in a weight gain of about the same. Today, researchers view this rule as overly simplistic. They now think of human energy balance as "a dynamic and adaptable system," as one study describes. When you alter one component — cutting the number of calories you eat in a day to lose weight, doing more exercise than usual — this sets off a cascade of changes in the body that affect how many calories you use up, and in turn, your body weight.