7 ms·
Facebook expected to revise plans for Messenger Bot API as failure rate hits 70%
- yousry 10y agoI'm pleasantly surprised how Facebook openly admits that this project is a complete failure. I hear almost daily whitewashed NLP results from other companies.
- criddell 10y agoHave they ever said how they would define success? What would a smashing success look like to Facebook? Is it mostly about revenue?
- reitanqild 10y agoWhat would a smashing success look like to Facebook? Tinfoil hat on: a smashing success for them is controlling everyones online life. See: the Whatsapp acquisition - burning a double digit number of billions on a profitable platform just to remove their one source of income and USP so as to get even more juicy metadata and eyeballs. (Yes, I was a huge fan of Whatsapp. Yes, so much that I expected them to manage to stay true to their ideals after the acquisition. Yes, I tried to believe Facebook actually just wanted a part in what Whatsapp was about to become. Fool me once something something )
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoAfter FB and Oculus, MS and Minecraft it should be clear that these companies only acquire for control.
- jeswin 10y agoIf someone from Facebook is listening, allowing bots in Group Conversations will enable other companies to innovate in this space. For example, you could replicate Slack for a small team with Messenger and Group Chat bots. Right now, there is very little you could do with their Messenger API.
- chatmasta 10y agoTotally agree with this. I'm not sure why Facebook hasn't implemented group chat for bots yet. It must be on their roadmap. Maybe they are choosing to focus on 1-1 interaction right now, because 1-N interaction will require much different UX and code. Some 1-1 features have no obvious corollary in 1-N interaction. For example when a messenger bot sends you a "menu" with options, should the bot send the same menu to everyone in the group? Should only the person who triggered the bot in the group be able to interact with the menu? These are answerable questions, but there are a lot of them and I can see why Facebook would choose to focus on 1-1 interactions first (especially since those are more likely to become paying interactions). Personally I would love group bots. They can enable a lot of fun interactions, and it's certainly more fun to "play with" a novel bot with your friends than by yourself.
- nl 10y agoIf there is to be another AI winter it will be because of unfulfilled promises in NLP. As someone who works in NLP I don't think there will be an AI winter. There will be a Gartner "valley of despair", abut no winter. That doesn't mean NLP is solved though.
- rand_r 10y agoNLP is a distraction. Computers won't be able to do NLP until they understand the real world. Parsing a sentence about snow without know what snow is will not be useful for a computer or a human.
- kalms 10y agoNatural Language Processing is an abstraction? That's quite the statement, considering the recent advances that has been made. I mean, you don't see the value in a computer being able to perceive meaning when you say: "Siri, please dim the lights 40%"? A computer doesn't need to know how you feel about snow, to tell you that it's snowing outside, and you'll probably want to remember snow chains.
- jerf 10y agoYou sound like you think you're disagreeing with rand_r, but all your text is in support of rand_r's point. You use one example that is basically solvable with regexes and in your second paragraph you appear to strongly agree that NLP isn't important at all.
- adventist 10y agoYeah I agree! I don't need NLP to be able to fulfil those requests.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoWhat makes you think NLP isn't a method for understanding the world? Embedding the word "snow" in a sufficiently rich abstraction tells you what snow is, in so far as anyone else can articulate it anyway. I think you have an artificially high threshold for what a useful level of understanding is.
- watbe 10y agoWhat is the metric actually measuring? Where did 70% come from? The article says that only 30% of requests were automated but I find it hard to believe that the API aims for 100% automated responses for all requests. Heck, if the bot API managed to reduce human resourcing by 30%, I'd say that's more success than not. Is this an article or an opinion piece? It reads very weirdly but I can't pinpoint it.
- wheelerwj 10y agothis article is pretty much vapor. theregister has been hitting the news pretty hard and is becoming one of the more popular non-mainstream sources. So they probably need some filler content? 30% in a year is solid, especially with the proliferation of tools for building bots making it more and more accessible to tinkerers and smaller orgs. ie, use caes where complete automation may not be the primary goal.
- laurent123456 10y agoI'm surprised there's so many theregister articles on the front page these days, it's not exactly the most reliable source of information and most of its stuff is clickbait. I seem to remember certain websites automatically get a lower weight on HN when they get upvoted a lot - shouldn't this be applied to theregister too?
- mattmanser 10y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?query=theregister&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=pastWeek&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=theregister&sort=byPopularity&... Doesn't look like a particularly popular source to me.
- mtw 10y agoI haven't followed up everything, but how is Google leading the AI race vs Facebook? I haven't seen a consumer service by Google run by AI. There's the hugely popular Tenserflow but it's for developers and Facebook also released nice libraries (e.g for Torch)
- hendzen 10y ago"I haven't seen a consumer service by Google run by AI". Have you, perchance, used Google Search?
- detaro 10y agoGoogle Now, Speech recognition in various other products, image search, automatic tagging of photos, ... ?
- ganfortran 10y agoWHAT? It is exactly opposite, no Google services that accumulate enough data don't use machine learning these days. For god sake, they even use deep learning to save electricity bill for their data center! Search, recommendation, knowledge graph, ads, photos, translate, even youtube thumbnails have some parts powered by ML.
- Houshalter 10y agoAs late as 2008 Google said they didn't use any machine learning in Search. They didn't trust it. Instead had an army of people to manually write search heuristics.
- jeppebemad 10y agoA lot can happen in 8 years.. :) Google has RankBrain to process search results, and that's only what they've admitted to. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RankBrain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/RankBrain
- Jordrok 10y ago
- pmlnr 10y ago> Others suggested that whichever superpower lost the AI arms race would relapse into a state of primitive technology feudalism. We are already there.
- going_to_800 10y agoI tested FB messenger bots from different companies...They are very intrusive. They need to limit the messages somehow and also make a clear difference between messages from bots and friends, like gmail does with promotional messages.
- jerf 10y agoDefinitely an incentive problem there. The bot must do "something" to justify its existence and attract attention to the fact it is useful, while simultaneously not being so annoying that it is, well, annoying. I'm not sure even a human could hit that window consistently, especially as it's probably a window of negative width (i.e., outright impossible) for a lot of users.
- drivingmenuts 10y agoAs an end-user, how would I even come in contact with the AI on a daily basis? I have messenger for talking to real-world people I already know. What's the incentive to talk to a bot?
- matans 10y agoOn the subscription page for the source article: "The Information is, for sure, the most thoughtful / smartest tech coverage." SAM ALTMAN PRESIDENT OF Y COMBINATOR lol