4 ms·
Anybody actually have an assessment if this library is actually accurate? The problem with most computational geometry libraries is that they tend to be 1) rid
by bsder 10y ago
Anybody actually have an assessment if this library is actually accurate?
The problem with most computational geometry libraries is that they tend to be 1) riddled with bugs, 2) slow and 3) covered by stupid licenses.
The license is nice. So, how is the accuracy and speed?
- rwbt 10y agoGood questions. I'm also interested and I'm planning to test it out first thing tomorrow. But from the FAQs, this project seemed to be around since 1997 (not C++ back then though) so I'm guessing it should be pretty stable.
- santaclaus 10y ago> 3) covered by stupid licenses Hello, CGAL.
- ska 10y agoWhat is stupid about the CGAL licenses? If I understand it correctly - If you are using it academically or in free software you can use it. If you are using it commercially you can pay a reasonable license fee and use it. Sounds like a better solution than most; what am I missing?
- jtuente 10y agoHonestly, the worst part of CGAL licensing is figuring out which parts actually require the commercial license, since most of the simpler structures in CGAL can be used freely in a commercial product.
- ska 10y agoI haven't looked for years, but as I recall very little was LGPL other than the core, and the rest was licensed by module. Even if you just licensed the whole thing it wasn't particularly expensive.
- plafl 10y agoWhat I remember from college, more than 10 years have passed, from using MicroStation and SolidEdge is that even professional design packages will accumulate some errors. Actually you could build the same piece in several different ways and some ways were more precise than others. My understanding is that all operations are carried numerically and the only way that would prevent accumulation of errors would be to perform them symbolically and solve them numerically just at the end but I suppose that would be extremely inefficient. I wonder if someone knows about any book or software library that follows the later approach since I find the subject quite interesting.
- ArashPartow 10y agohow about something like this: http://www.wykobi.com/faq.html#FAQ06 http://www.wykobi.com/faq.html#FAQ06
- willyt 10y agoYes. In the U.K. many architects persist in drawing their buildings at OS grid coordinates relative to the origin of the file in mm because it make importing surveys and OS maps easier. So a building in Scotland would have a translate of something like 10000000000, 700000000000mm it's one of the reasons BIM is mysteriously unreliable in practice because points that should be coincident aren't because of of accumulated errors.
- eps 10y agoWhat's "OS"?
- dtf 10y agoThe Ordnance Survey grid system, a form of map coordinates in the UK. https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/resources/maps-and-geographic-resources/the-national-grid.html https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/resources/maps-and-geograph... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordnance_Survey_National_Grid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordnance_Survey_National_Grid
- 10y ago