5 ms·
I find the notion of 3D printing a house intriguing but it seems ultimately impractical. There are better ways to manufacture homes that can be componentized an
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I find the notion of 3D printing a house intriguing but it seems ultimately impractical. There are better ways to manufacture homes that can be componentized and transported for final assembly on site. One where I visited the factory was the BluHomes[1]. You can automate much of the construction of walls and wiring and finishing if you do it in sections.
[1] https://www.bluhomes.com/ https://www.bluhomes.com/
- mapmap 10y agoPricey. How are these competitive with traditional construction?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe price is artificial, much like the Tesla Roadster pricing they have been focused on really high end homes that someone can truck up into the Sierras and 'poof' your mountain getaway is there. They are developing a core competency of creating the fixturing to mass produce homes. The cost per house should drop well below that of a traditional house with equal square footage when they go for volume. They do that by removing construction labor, site/weather variability (so site delays), economize material transport cost, and reducing time to construct (labor hours). Things that don't change, the cost of basic materials, the cost of land, the cost to prepare the site (foundation/leveling etc), and permitting/access. For the absolute lowest cost with on site materials the 'sand' homes [1], that provides the framing (much like the 3D printed house in the article). [1] https://www.niftyhomestead.com/blog/earthbag-homes/ https://www.niftyhomestead.com/blog/earthbag-homes/
- justinph 10y agoAll of those homes cost nearly or over $1M. A garage is $60k. How is this even remotely similar?
- bane 10y agoPrefab houses have been around forever. I grew up in one. I think my parents paid about $100k in 1989. The construction was: - dig a hole - pour a foundation - truck in the house in two halves - bolt the house together - do final wiring, plumbing move the family in I have no idea how much these kinds of homes are today, but their latest zillow zesitmate puts it at around $300k (on an acre of property)...so YMMV. 3d printing, in general, is expensive and better for one-off, or low-volume things. Mass manufacture techniques are hyper-optimized and beat 3d printing most of the time when you need to make >10 of the thing almost every time...this includes houses.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoExactly right. And as the manufacturing techniques expand you get more choices than just single wide or double wide.
- bane 10y agoYeah, it was basically a fixed double-wide mobile home with better materials. I can't remember the movie offhand, but there's a fight scene that takes place in half of a prefab house on the highway. The house is still there, still looks fine. A little cramped for adult me, but a perfectly fine place to live and grow up. The house I live in now could fit that house inside of it and have plenty of room to spare. My parents still live there, have all the amenities of a modern home. They turned half the basement into their master bedroom suite and the other half into a nice extended home office. Housing crises are not going to be solved by tiny houses on half-acre properties. The houses are a tiny fraction of the overall property values -- and are made in a factory, on the cheap, in mass quantities. Making structures has been solved for hundreds if not thousands of years, making land is the problem.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago> Making structures has been solved for hundreds if > not thousands of years, making land is the problem. Well stated. I think land allocation also contributes to the issue. I was pleased that 'mixed commercial/residential' zoning got to be a thing as it makes for a much nicer living experience if you have your basic needs met by walking. I'm still waiting for a mixed commercial/residential/governmental tract where you can have a police station, library, courthouse, and office space mixed in with houses and shops. I remember touring York in the UK and thinking about how medieval villages were set up, they have the taint of 'old times' but they optimized a space for useful living and commerce. I think there are things to be learned there.
- bane 10y ago> I'm still waiting for a mixed commercial/residential/governmental tract where you can have a police station, library, courthouse, and office space mixed in with houses and shops. Especially for "consumer" facing government services like libraries and postal centers. I think getting local governments to mix in more "official" functions might be harder since some of the legitimacy of those functions sometimes stems from the power signalling they use to distinguish the building from the rest of society -- e.g. courthouses tend to be big official looking buildings with lots of wood paneling in the courtrooms. In Korea, where land is at a premium, you find tiny police stations all over Seoul, but even the very small ones tend to be stand-alone affairs. IIR courthouses tend to be either standalone or as part of larger local government centers. http://img11.deviantart.net/5c0d/i/2013/337/5/1/police_station_in_seoul_korea_by_toyonda-d6wnct2.jpg http://img11.deviantart.net/5c0d/i/2013/337/5/1/police_stati... https://s3.amazonaws.com/gs-waymarking-images/fb6d6675-11fb-40be-8681-ee9063581f82_d.jpg https://s3.amazonaws.com/gs-waymarking-images/fb6d6675-11fb-...
- elchief 10y agoHalf a million for 600 square feet. C'mon man
- jfim 10y ago> Half a million for 600 square feet. C'mon man Why half a million when you could have 600 square feet for 1.3 million in Silicon Valley? https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Sunnyvale-CA-94085/19543398_zpid/97547_rid/37.397556,-122.003603,37.368571,-122.049737_rect/14_zm/ https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Sunnyvale-CA-94085/195...
- elchief 10y agoThat includes the land at least...
- Shinkei 10y agoWow. I'm really trying to understand this house price. I just can't imagine who would think 1.3 million is a reasonable price for this house? I mean that's like a $10,000 mortgage. That's the same amount of money as a $333/night hotel room. A quick search of the area reveals $100/night hotels--typical across the country. So... how is this market priced housing? I mean I could have housekeeping and free breakfast every morning plus two or three 'bedrooms and bathrooms' in a secure, maintained property for the same price as this house. Sure, I am not building home equity... but I'm assuming a house rented in this area would not be a lot cheaper than that. So your choices are rent or live in a hotel if you don't want to buy a home this expensive? I would be making some tough choices if I had to move out there.
- elchief 10y agoIt's Chinese bureaucrats parking their ill-gotten gains wherever they can
- jfim 10y agoTo be honest though, that one is an outlier. It's in a crap location (next to the highway) and looks pretty awful. I wouldn't be surprised if this is a house that the realtors can point to in order to make other houses in SV look "inexpensive" in comparison.
- elihu 10y agoThe current technology is perhaps impractical, but it will get better with time. Some advantages of having a building built by a machine are a) the skills of your workers are no longer a constraint on building geometry and b) machines don't care if the houses are all the same or all different, so individual customization is cheaper. What follows from b) is that it would be less difficult/expensive to customize a house to match the constrains of its site, which is currently hard when dealing with non-flat, non-rectangular lots. One could even generate building designs algorithmically according to some heuristics. My prediction is that if house-building robots take off, we'll see a lot of co-evolution between the machines and architectural design software.
- whitneyrzoller 10y agoMy parents just built one of these homes. Having contributed reluctant and unskilled labor I would be interested in hearing how the automation of wall construction, wiring, and finishing is done.
- Unbeliever69 10y agopractical for colonizing other planets maybe
- keypress 10y agoI love the idea of building on site with site materials. Rammed earth housing - is an example. Mouldings/hoardings are brought in, but if you do sections at a time, you don't need that much. Labour is the intensive part. If you could get a machine to print with materials on site, or tapping into the waste stream that would be great. Not so happy with the concrete here. I'd rather a more friendly aggregate. An adobe tube house isn't a far cry from this - but looks more eco friendly. I'm sure you could machine much of that building process.