3 ms·
Your argument amounts to an appeal to nature, and appeals to nature are suspect for two (immediate) reasons: * Humans are capable of rational activity, and hav
by woodruffw 10y ago
Your argument amounts to an appeal to nature, and appeals to nature are suspect for two (immediate) reasons:
* Humans are capable of rational activity, and have no need to appeal to our development for moral justification.
* What happened in our development (that which was) has absolutely no bearing on what we ought to do based on what currently is. We have strong archaeological and anthropological evidence that early humans cannibalized and murdered each other, yet we intuitively understand that those acts do not justify contemporary ones.
- rudrigu 10y agoAppeals to nature are suspect, appeals to the irrelevancy of nature are outright dishonest.
- woodruffw 10y agoNature is irrelevant in moral discussions, as are all variables that exist beyond the agent's control. Blame and approbation come from choice made by the agent, not for the agent. Nature is useful for understanding why something amoral is the case (like sexual dimorphism), but does not and should not inform our understanding of what ought to be the case.
- rudrigu 10y agoWhat ought to be is what benefits the tribe. More people benefit the tribe, because you then have expendable males that can be used to pillage the neighboring tribes. Unless you have depleted the environment (e.g., overhunting), there is no incentive to abstain from breeding as much as possible.