4 ms·
That's by the way among the only books I've bought due to the title alone, without knowing what it was about. And it was an interesting read (basically about c
by FabHK 10y ago
That's by the way among the only books I've bought due to the title alone, without knowing what it was about.
And it was an interesting read (basically about categories/measure words/collective nouns, "families" of meaning or "radial" categories, and rejection of the good old Aristotelian notion of definition as membership in a class together with some more specific boolean predicate, e.g. "a bachelor is a man that is not married").
Anyways, great title, great book. Interesting paper you posted, though I don't recall whether Lakoff actually made the case that Dyirbal speakers saw women as dangerous. The paper suggests that "there is no synchronic conceptual association among all of the items in a given gender class; in particular, the smaller subsets within a class do not need to be radially related to the semantic core. The overall class membership is motivated only diachronically, and even then not necessarily on semantic grounds." - would Lakoff disagree?
- mirimir 10y agoI read the book decades ago, so ... But no, I don't recall that he argued that Dyirbal speakers thought of women as dangerous. It was just a sensational title. And that's why I cited the paper. For what it's worth, I read it together with Illuminatus! by Shea and Wilson and Lessing's Canopus in Argos series, and found the mix immensely transformational :)