7 ms·
No matter how much feminism pretends otherwise, women are not keen to form lasting relationships with unemployed men. The reality on the ground is that many wo
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
No matter how much feminism pretends otherwise, women are not keen to form lasting relationships with unemployed men.
The reality on the ground is that many women consider extended unemployment a good-enough reason to end a marriage.
A cynical but not unrealistic view is that humans tend to display loyalty to performed roles in relationships, not to individuals.
If one individual stops performing their assigned role, the relationship ends.
- bigmanwalter 10y agoWomen who don't date men without a job are like men won't date a woman with a career. There's plenty of sexism on both sides.
- vocatus_gate 10y agoThe simple reality is that women do not respect men they have to provide for.
- EliRivers 10y agoFeminism, the advocation of equal social and political rights for women? What does that have to do with wanting to form lasting relationships with unemployed men?
- gotchange 10y agoBecause traditional gender roles dictate that the man in the relationship to be the breadwinner and being a bum doing nothing all day long wouldn't bode well for the woman in the relationship and given that feminists are against the status quo and traditional gender roles, it would look hypocritical that they disqualify a male suitor or partner for a romance or LT relationship based on their LT employment outlook or prospects.
- EliRivers 10y agoOh right, traditional gender roles. I thought this feminism was the advocation of equal social and political rights, but actually this is something else on top. I seem to be an appallingly bad feminist. For me, it's about equal social and political rights, but it turns out it's really all about a whole lot of crazy stuff I don't understand. It's odd that the people who most loudly understand what feminism really is seem to be those opposed to it, and people who simply label themselves feminists (such as myself) end up mystified by where all this extra junk comes from. Sometimes I wonder if perhaps people aren't conflating advocation of equal social and political rights with a whole lot of other things, but it's generally not worth the conversation.
- FabHK 10y agoSo have equal political and social rights been achieved yet? I'd assume that for political rights, the answer is yes. Not sure about social rights - could you elaborate?
- EliRivers 10y agoI think you're more than capable of digging up answers to that question yourself. I do apologise if you're genuine; you seem genuine, and your website certainly paints you as a reasonable person, but I've just had too many bad experiences in such discussions online that I no longer engage in them. I'm sure you can imagine the kind of thing. HN in particular seems to suffer from it; a disturbing sense of perceived victimhood in some that poisons their conversation.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoThe problem with finding examples ourselves is that we don't know what you meant by the terms you used. I, for one, would have some difficulty drawing the line between "social equality" and "other stuff on top", such as getting rid of traditional gender roles. (what I see as) the mainstream feminist position is that getting rid of traditional gender roles is essential to achieve equal social rights. It's not really equal if one can legally do a thing but everyone else will think it's innappropriate.
- Jill_the_Pill 10y agoThere's a big gap between not-being-a-breadwinner and being a bum. My sister's ex stopped working and stopped looking for work. That in itself wouldn't have been bad -- they were financially ok. But, she would still come home from her long day of work and do the dishes and laundry and cook supper (for her a chore, not a hobby). I have other friends with unemployed husbands where the dad does 90% of the childcare and most of the housework, and that seems to work out pretty well. People like a team effort, regardless of who is doing what.
- stefco_ 10y agoThis. It is very common for guys who are out of work to be much less productive around the house despite having more time available to dedicate to housework. Tons of guys are not brought up doing housework and being detail-oriented about this stuff, so in a lot of relationships where the guy is at home more often (for whatever reason), he doesn't know how to pick up the slack at home. I'm not saying this is because those guys are dumb or lazy or malicious; I have trouble with it and don't consider myself those things. My girlfriend and I try to split stuff up evenly (we both have jobs and neither of us likes housework, so we try to be fair), but I still find it hard to remember to do certain things that she has been doing for years (e.g. remembering to clean the toilet bowl), or I will not prioritize certain other things that she makes sure to do promptly (e.g. I will wait longer to do laundry). I am trying to pull my weight, but I can definitely tell that I am catching up to her in housework productivity. And, from most anecdotes I hear, this is a very common (though obviously not universal) phenomenon. This is not to say that there are not other things wrapped up in this (people are attracted to roles, and I am sure plenty of women in traditional subcultures find jobless men just plain unattractive regardless of their value in other dimensions). But I can definitely see why someone who is already going to have to raise and provide for a kid would be reluctant to bring another person into a lifelong relationship when that other person (judging from widespread anecdotal evidence) will very likely not be much help at home while also not contributing a paycheck.
- douche 10y agoHousework is like a gas - it will expand to fill any volume of time that you are willing to allocate it. The dirty secret is that not doing some of it, or doing it on a more, eh, relaxed, timescale, doesn't make a whole lot of difference. Results vary according to your & your partners levels of OCD, however...
- derrickdirge 10y agoNot only would it look hypocritical to not enter into a relationship because someone doesn't fit into traditional gender roles, it would disqualify one from being a feminist altogether. That mentality is one of the reasons we need feminism. Women will only become increasingly equal to men as time goes on. If we blindly cling to antiquated, unrealistic notions of what constitutes an acceptable partner, we impede progress.
- techdragon 10y agoIt's not even an issue of feminism or any other -ism. It's statistics and sociology. The last time I saw data on this, that was one of the most common causes.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI spoke to a divorce lawyer and as someone getting married in a few months I asked him what made marriages fail. He said that "It's mostly out of your control, when men come in it is mostly because their wife has been unfaithful. When women come in it is mostly because the man has lost his job." He also said that women seem to tolerate a great deal of infidelity on the part of the man up until the point where he stops earning. Sort of makes me glad that I met my fiancee while I was very poor, hopefully I set the bar rather low.
- derrickdirge 10y agoIf I knew my wife was considering divorcing me because because I lost my job, she wouldn't have to consider it any longer because I'd get the ball rolling. I suspect that there are deeper compatibility issues at play and major events like infidelity or job loss just act as catalysts for divorce.
- ams6110 10y agoIt's comforting to think that, but human nature is what it is. The typical woman would not immediately hire a divorce lawyer if her husband lost his job, but after a year or two she'd definitely be thinking she could do better (regardless of "fault").
- derrickdirge 10y agoI just think that's a very reductionist outlook. Humans are complicated. They have a lot of different needs that all have complex relationships with one another. Everyone experiences theses needs to varying degrees. If the needs that aren't adequately satisfied aren't outweighed by those that are, then it's reasonable for a person to start looking elsewhere to satisfy those needs. If my wife became a huge economic burden and wasn't contributing anything else to the relationship, then after a year or two I'd definitely be thinking I could do better.
- gotchange 10y agoGood point but there's nothing that precludes these assigned/expected roles in a LT relationship from changing or evolving in the future and for persons in the relationship to adapt to the new dynamics and realities.
- 77pt77 10y agoMany of these thing are deep atavistic behaviours well rooted in our evolutionary past. Very difficult to change in any meaningful way. You'll have outliers, but statistically it will be insignificant.
- xiphias 10y agoThis may be true now, but there's a trend of women accepting that a man earns less (or even sometimes doesn't have a job) as long as she doesn't yet want to have a baby, and the man looks hot. It's still all about supply and demand.
- tajen 10y agoSeriously, where can I find those? It seems to be an incredibly good and responsible attitude that would radically change the face the world, and, as a man, I'm dying to see such behavior happen. Does this trend have newspapers or forums where they share this positive attitude, so I can witness it and bump up my faith in my future?
- nmcfarl 10y agoIn my experience the baby has nothing to do with it - I know at least 3 women who have married that guy+, and now have a happy marriage and a kid. 1 of them even describes himself as a house husband with a side gig. Money isn't everything - particularly if you have lots of it. + well hot, smart, and having lived interesting lives by 35. That describes all 3 of them.
- booleandilemma 10y agoI read an article recently saying that women want men to be the breadwinners and they also want them to do the housework. We can't win. http://on.mktw.net/2li9AOT http://on.mktw.net/2li9AOT
- cd_cd 10y agoThe state has taken the place of the father as the primary bread-winner amongst the working class in the west. Prior to universal welfare most women would never have risked pregnancy outside a stable relationship because of the financial risks. There are no risks now, in fact there is actually an incentive single mothers get more money via state benefits that a single women with similar qualifications can earn in work.
- mjevans 10y agoWe can, through automation of /everything/. When there is no more work, in the house or out, all that is left is room for enlightenment or self-destruction.
- mos_basik 10y agoSome say the world will end in fire, Some say in ice. From what I’ve tasted of desire I hold with those who favor fire. But if it had to perish twice, I think I know enough of hate To say that for destruction ice Is also great And would suffice. I rather think the choices are self-destruction through violent conflict and self-destruction through lack of purpose/lethargy. But maybe that's only nation states. Or maybe I just have an unreasonably glum view of human nature.
- vostok 10y ago> No matter how much feminism pretends otherwise, women are not keen to form lasting relationships with unemployed men. I am a feminist man and I would not be keen to form a lasting relationship with an unemployed woman unless she was already wealthy.
- pasquinelli 10y agoMaybe, but a lot of shit heads are unemployed, and a lot of men who become unemployed become shit heads too. I read in a related article posted here that most prime aged men who've given up on the labor market aren't doing more child care, aren't doing more work around the house, are watching more TV and using alcohol and drugs more. So, basically, they're shit heads, either because they're out of work or with that cause and effect flipped. Edit, forgot to include the article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13795397 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13795397
- pentae 10y agoCalling them shit heads for 'giving up' when they feel the deck is stacked against them is an oversimplification that avoids the issue. I think we're seeing in western culture what has been happening in Japan for the last 20 years. Herbivore men who simply evaluate the marketplace and decide giving up on working, women and a family and sticking to a life of video games is their best risk/reward option.
- ams6110 10y agoIf you recall Maslow's hierarchy from high-school psychology, you will understand that if non-working men still have shelter and food (and television and internet in many cases) they have their most fundamental needs met. Internet (porn, games) provides sexual satisfaction and a sense of winning at something, leaving little in the way of motivational pressure to do more. TV is there as catch-all distraction in case lingering guilt remains.
- mcguire 10y ago"...feminism pretends otherwise..." Source?
- 77pt77 10y ago> A cynical but not unrealistic view is that humans tend to display loyalty to performed roles in relationships, not to individuals. >If one individual stops performing their assigned role, the relationship ends. This is a very succinct way to describe reality. Thank you for stating it so clearly.