4 ms·
> Social problems like alcoholism and drugs are talked about as if they would be same as being unemployed. It is odd conflation, it is not the same, not even ne
by golergka 10y ago
> Social problems like alcoholism and drugs are talked about as if they would be same as being unemployed. It is odd conflation, it is not the same, not even nearly.
When comparing two things, it's useful to understand what is the comparison being made. Of course these things aren't the same in general sense of things - but as far as making a man "unmarriable" (as in statistically desired by either gender for a long-term relationship and partnership), they have a pretty similar effect, don't they?
- beaconstudios 10y agoin the gender model of man-as-provider, the real disqualifier is the unemployment.
- pessimizer 10y agoI'd assert that not living anywhere near you is a similar impediment. If women can find local employment, but men have to move into the cities, even if everyone's employed that's going to affect the number of marriages.
- watwut 10y agoAlcoholics and junkies cause way more trouble to their families then people who are just unemployed.
- phkahler 10y agoRight. An Alcoholic with a job will still be able to provide for his family even though he beats them too.
- watwut 10y agoAssuming he don't spend all money on alcohol, which is pretty easy with low income and assuming employer won't get tired of paying alcoholic. Domestic violence is something that is even more different - living with such person is spectacularly bad idea and directly dangerous.
- Pharylon 10y agoMy Dad was an alcoholic for as long as I can remember. A pretty serious one, but functional. But he held down a white-color job at a shipping company for which he was paid pretty well, and we lived a pretty comfortable lifestyle. He always had a temper - he gave us lots of spankings. By some measures, maybe he was abusive, but he never hit us or left bruises with his belt. He just tending to give out those "whooping" at the drop of a hat if he'd had too much to drink. Then he lost his job when the major job provider in town closed. He kept trying to find a new one, but it was never a good one. For someone that had spent 15 years making good money at something he was apparently pretty good at, working menial low-paying jobs was devastating to him. His alcoholism got worse, and pretty soon he wasn't able to hold down even the menial jobs. Needless to say, my parents marriage fell apart.
- watwut 10y agoI haven't seen the statistics, so I do not know. However,for pregnant young women, marring alcoholic or junkie is freaking stupid idea. Marrying unemployed to soldier on together makes more sense.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> I haven't seen the statistics, so I do not know. However,for pregnant young women, marring alcoholic or junkie is freaking stupid idea. Marrying unemployed to soldier on together makes more sense. Not necessarily. A woman might be better off holding out for someone with a job. Especially when she isn't already pregnant.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoNo, because this ignores the cause & effect reality of nature. If people are turning to drug-based stimuli for the purpose of numbing and unfulfilled life of 1) no sexual partners 2) few job prospects, then we should not act as if the drugs are the first-tier causes of their predicament... Anyone who has seen the upper echelons of society knows how many drugs are used up there too - and therefore knows that they are not first tier-causes (of being on the bottom) in every use case.
- mirimir 10y agoFor the rich, there are challenges of ennui and expectations. And that drives “shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations”. Maybe it's not so unrelated.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoI thought those sayings came from the idea that we get lazy when we have a lot... I've never heard that the proposed cause is drug use - any sources on that?
- mirimir 10y agoThere may be published studies, but I haven't looked. But consider the Beats. Most of them were trust-fund kids. Or the people who hung around Warhole. Or the early college hippies, protected against arrest by institutional influence. Or what they used to call the jet set. Drug use is common among wealthy kids because they're so well protected from consequences. All children like to experiment, and have fun. So why not? I knew a guy who burned through his inheritance, and then became a heroin smuggler. He used his friends as unwitting drug mules, and kept living the high life on the profits. But then one of them got busted, and sold him out. Oops.
- mcguire 10y agoIn this article, chemical abuse seems to be an effect of economic disadvantages.