4 ms·
Utopia never existed. Until about 250 years ago, your outcomes depended overwhelmingly on what family you came from, no matter your skills. Children of peasants
by toyg 10y ago
Utopia never existed. Until about 250 years ago, your outcomes depended overwhelmingly on what family you came from, no matter your skills. Children of peasants would become peasants; children of artisans would become artisans; and so on and so forth. Rebelling to that state of thing would likely get you hanged or ostracized.
The industrial revolution and global colonization changed that, injecting opportunities for an ever-growing section of men; and genocidal mass-war eventually did the same for women. This land of mirth and honey where every man has an opportunity to bootstrap himself is a somewhat fantastical invention. Social mobility might have been higher than average in the US between 1850 and 1950, but anywhere else "where you come from" was always the most important factor in anyone's fortunes.
- watwut 10y agoMoreover, men were happy to support and fight those genocidal wars in part because lives for many of them were shitty.
- c06n 10y agoYour blanket statement is bullshit. Maybe you should read a book from the era, men were terrified of the horrors these wars produced. Perhaps they saw a chance to escape their absolute poverty, that doesn't mean they liked what they did. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplicius_Simplicissimus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplicius_Simplicissimus
- watwut 10y agoYes many men were opposed and many of them even severely punished for that opposition. The point however still stand - both wars and political parties who brought them in had a lot of support. Not just from women. Those revolutions and wars did not just randomly happened out of nothing. People, not just women, wanted them. Also, many German veterans from wwi wanted the war, wanted to reverse humiliation they felt after loosing. Some were opposed, but opposition was not universal among them. It wasn't just escape from powerty, it was something meant to give their lives meaning, building imperium and all that crap.
- cancancan 10y agoThere was a lot of shaming of men who were not soldiers. One particularly interesting example of it is The White Feather[1] campaign against men in England during WWI. It was orchestrated by women, including prominent feminists no less. [1] http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/151/the-white-feather-campaign-a-struggle-with-masculinity-during-world-war-i http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/151/the-white-feath...
- cancancan 10y agoIndeed, especially in the 1850s. You could always sell your Negroes and start a new exciting career. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/07/the-weeping-time/374159/?single_page=true https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/07/the-wee...
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly posting inflammatory and ideological comments to HN despite being asked to stop.
- cancancan 10y agoIt was a sarcastic response to toyg's belief about social mobility in 1850s referring to the auction poster in the link provided, but whatever. Enjoy your echo chamber.