5 ms·
If you're ever in doubt about tech's sexism problem, revisit one of the HN comment threads where gender roles come up and marvel at the unchecked support for th
by closeparen 10y ago
If you're ever in doubt about tech's sexism problem, revisit one of the HN comment threads where gender roles come up and marvel at the unchecked support for the idea that women should be stay-at-home mothers. Then, for bonus points, check out a divorce thread.
Civilization was built on all sorts of identity-based subjugation relationships and as we chip away at them, in the long run, it gets better.
If your implicit assumption is true (women only stay in relationships because they require a partner's income to survive) then we have a moral imperative to provide escape hatches from those toxic relationships as quickly as possible.
- jules 10y agoThis is what's wrong with politics today. Every question gets moralised. Every opinion gets evaluated on a scale from angel to bigot instead of true to false.
- Infinitesimus 10y agoIt is a bit problematic that the original comment doesn't seem to consider women as potential provider for a family and the narrative is centered around a male provider.
- mirimir 10y agoTrue. The study found that women are coping better with deindustrialization than men are. It's just that they're raising children alone.
- phkahler 10y agoEvolution has made men the provider. In the old days (not even that long ago) being pregnant makes a woman vulnerable, while raising children takes time and effort. It made sense for a male to provide for his family while the female was less able to do so. The gender roles are a result of evolution, and womens desire for a man with social and/or economic standing are just as ingrained as a mans desire for visual signs of fertility in a woman.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Evolution has made men the provider. Evolution works on the level of genes. It literally cannot prescribe complex social roles. "In the old days", both men and women worked full-time at various tasks: hunting, gathering, mending, caring, building, planting, harvesting, etc.
- ams6110 10y agoCitiation? I would think that evolution certainly plays a role in selecting for instinctive behaviors (such as preferences in a mate) that benefit survival
- DaUR 10y ago> It literally cannot prescribe complex social roles It absolutely can. Evolutionary psychology is science, and it's based on the scientific method (ironically, unlike the sociology that's obsessed with "gender roles", which isn't based on science at all). Check out Gad Saad's podcast on Joe Rogan.
- tnone 10y agoIf you're ever in doubt about the regressive left's tunnel vision and lack of critical thinking, just visit one of these threads, and watch the people unable to distinguish descriptive from normative claims come out of the woodwork, dropping the mandatory moralising chastisement about toxicity and sexism. From the article it seems the problem is that women continue to seek providers, despite what decades of feminism have tried to tell them they should want.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoDo you see what you did here? Someone comes up with a hypothesis that is scientific and not a moral question, and you succeed in politicizing and moralizing it in one fell swoop. Why is it important to derail this line of questioning? If government and welfare systems effect the organization of families, relationships, reproduction, courtship - and the like - then isn't that a worthy thing to study?
- vertex-four 10y agoActually, the GP made a pretty blatant assertion, not "we should study this" but "this is the way I believe it is".
- pokemongoaway 10y ago"blatant assertion..." Blatant: (of bad behavior) done openly and unashamedly. Assertion: a confident and forceful statement of fact or belief. Are you implying that we should be closed and/or ashamed of beliefs we might hold in this category of discourse?
- vertex-four 10y agoNope. I'm implying that trying to suggest an assertion that affects political discourse and thus real people's lives is "just a scientific hypothesis" is not on.
- pokemongoaway 10y agoYou just don't seem to be able to take any nuance without failing. My comment wasn't about what you put in quotes - I don't know who you're quoting.
- watwut 10y agoIt was not scientific hypothesis nor proposal for research, it was statement of opinion presented as fact.
- idiot_stick 10y ago>revisit one of the HN comment threads where gender roles come up and marvel at the unchecked support for the idea that women should be stay-at-home mothers. As someone who's hung around this place along time, I'd love to see a link of a discussion with "unchecked" claims that women should stay home.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago> If you're ever in doubt about tech's sexism problem, revisit one of the HN comment threads where gender roles come up and marvel at the unchecked support for the idea that women should be stay-at-home mothers. Then, for bonus points, check out a divorce thread. And then look how many people have ideas about what's "natural" that come straight out of Victorian etiquette books.
- DaUR 10y agoYour comment is the epitome of social-justice dogma. > marvel at the unchecked support for the idea that women should be stay-at-home mothers. Learn the difference between positive and normative. There is a huge difference between "mothers should be stay-at-home mothers", and "widespread celibacy will cause societal instability"? > women only stay in relationships because they require a partner's income to survive Obviously, taking GP's point to an absurd (strawman) and then dismissing that isn't a reasonable debate strategy. People get married for a whole load of reasons. Many women, if their partners lose their jobs, will divorce them. No, that doesn't mean they're abused victims. (is that parody?) Turning an interesting question based on trends into a moral outrage, and hijacking the conversation, is infinitely puerile. Please don't do that.
- closeparen 10y agoParent claims that women would divorce their partners on a scale large enough to be a threat to civilization if women were to receive UBI, because they would no longer need male providers. Do you have some explanation for why this might be the case, other than "the need for a male provider" being (in parent's view) the only thing holding those at-risk relationships together? >Many women, if their partners lose their jobs, will divorce them. Preferring to be in a relationship with a well-employed men is very different from needing a male provider as a condition of well-being or survival. >Turning an interesting question based on trends into a moral outrage Fear and dismay at the proposition that women might stop needing male providers is morally outrageous, particularly when you consider that people who believe women receiving income threatens civilization are likely in a position to influence the hire/no hire decision on female candidates in our industry.
- dang 10y agoThere's no "unchecked support" for anything on HN, let alone "the idea that women should be stay-at-home mothers". HN is divided the way society at large is. All sorts of comments appear here, and inevitably some are noxious. This is what happens with any large-enough sample of people, especially on the internet. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13795530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13795530 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]