5 ms·
Requiring a take-home assignment, not just offering it as an alternative to an in-person interview phase, is a great way to systematically reduce the diversity
by wahnfrieden 10y ago
Requiring a take-home assignment, not just offering it as an alternative to an in-person interview phase, is a great way to systematically reduce the diversity of your hiring pool. It works well for some, but please don't require it of everyone.
- nialo 10y agoI am confused by this, could you help me to understand why this is so? In particular, it seems to me that take-home assignments are strictly better for candidate scheduling etc than in-person interviews, if time spent can be held equal. Maybe time spent is just not equal very often?
- stale2002 10y agoBecause if a company is going to make me spend X hours of my time, then I want the company to be spending X hours of THEIR time.
- hackinthebochs 10y agoYes, absolutely. I say this every time this homework assignment shit pops up. It's offloading the cost of hiring on to prospective candidates. The asymmetry of cost should give everyone pause. It's plainly exploitative. So you block off 4-8 hours of your life for this job you're really excited about. What is the employer putting up? Generally nothing. They get a sea of responses and they get to pick a few of the best ones. The 100 responses they got cost these candidates 400 hours of time for no cost to the employer whatsoever. Take home assignments are fine, but the employer needs to put up something as well. Either pay for the time I spend on it, or have the assignment late in the interviewing process and have employment contingent on passing some known bar ahead of time. That is to say, I should be the only one doing the assignment and there should be no wishy-washy rejections.
- gnaritas 10y ago> It's offloading the cost of hiring on to prospective candidates. The asymmetry of cost should give everyone pause. It's plainly exploitative. There's nothing wrong with that, it's a competitive market, those who get hired are those willing to compete, not those who complain about unfairness about being asked to demonstrate their skills. Employers spend tons of time filtering candidates, even reviewing the submitted work takes time and effort, saying it's no cost to the employer whatsoever is not only untrue, it's naive.
- rnovak 10y ago> What is the employer putting up? Generally nothing. Unless you've been in the shoes of a hiring manager, I'm unsure as to where this idea is coming from? Having been a hiring manager, it is a horrible experience. Unless it's extremely naive, homework sets generally take time to come up with and formalize, and certainly take time to review the results for. I suppose I can understand conflating the motivations of an interviewer with their employer, but it's not generally true to say that interviewers are just trying to exploit those they interview.
- navalsaini 10y agoHow many companies waive the coding requirement or postpone it towards the end, if you already have open sourced a bunch of code. It is also possible that the HR managers are just happy taking a route, where they can offload most work to the other party. The can instead act as better intermediaries, aligning the hiring goals of the company and the experience for the applicant. Whats wrong with asking them to create better value or understand the domain better so as to be able to create better value?
- prodigal_erik 10y ago> if you already have open sourced a bunch of code How do I know you wrote it and didn't merely paste your name over some project I've never heard of?
- 10y ago
- gnaritas 10y agoThat's a good way to get passed over for good jobs. As a potential candidate, you aren't in a position to making such demands and your unwillingness to demonstrate your skills on a simple assignment just means you won't be considered. Plenty of other fish in the sea who have no problem completing a simple assignment.
- throw_away_777 10y agoIt depends how desperate the candidate is for a job. A coding assignment may have a hidden cost of filtering out many qualified candidates, if qualified candidates don't feel the need to apply to companies with these assignments. Anecdotally, these assignments seem like just another filter companies use, they don't replace any steps in the process, just one more hurdle to pass.
- gnaritas 10y agoIf you aren't willing to demonstrate your skills with a little coding assignment, I don't consider you a qualified candidate. I've used a coding test for years, always get exactly the good kind of people I want, it filters out the lazy and the liars, most programming candidates are liars and simply don't have the chops they claim.
- idiot_stick 10y ago>Plenty of other fish in the sea who have no problem completing a simple assignment. And yet companies have an incredibly hard time hiring talent, even with so many other fish out there. Odd, that. People need to start understanding their value as an employee. You create more value than you're worth; that's why companies need workers. You don't need to bend over for a potential employer. Plenty of other fish in the sea of employers, too.
- gnaritas 10y agoIt's not odd at all, those are old school companies playing by the old rules of looking for candidates locally. And demonstrating your skills isn't bending over, it's showing your value and it's how you get a job. Seriously, this notion that you should be hired for a high paying job without needing to audition for it is just absurd; I wouldn't hire anyone with your attitude.
- rnovak 10y agoUnless they have a gun to your head, they aren't making you do anything. Applying/Interviewing is your choice.
- navalsaini 10y agoHe is saying that the company needs to tell their people to fix the process and do what they are paid for. Not offload it entirely to the applicant. Maybe just open separate channels for people who have an open source portfolio. I have about 30 repos in my OSS, but still have to take these assignments. Its such an utter waste of my time.
- stale2002 10y agoYes.... And I would choose NOT to apply to such a company, because F them.
- aisofteng 10y agoIf you're applying for a job, you're asking for the company to pay you a salary and to believe you can provide labor worth that salary. You can find a few hours.
- jpttsn 10y agoThis just seems petty. Do you actually want the job? Or are you just there to spread some kindergarten version of justice?
- stale2002 10y agoI do not want to work for a company who disrespects me and my time. That is a huge red flag, and means that they will disrespect me at work as well.
- wool_gather 10y agoIt does, if they're actually doing it in a way that's useful to them. At least one, probably two, engineers are going to evaluate what you send in, take notes, and then go over it with you. And they have to do that for every response. So that's an absolute floor of an engineer-hour per candidate: Anything less than 30 minutes to read through it and take notes is useless, and figure another 30 minutes minimum for a call. If they're not going over the responses in detail and then talking through them with the candidates, then they're just wasting their own time because they're not actually judging anything.
- shams93 10y agoI agree its not a process of applying for college, its a job. Testing to see whether somehow is a recent BSCS helps to systemically impose all 3 of the most problematic isms, racism. sexism and ageism. You can get brilliant employees from bootcamps, my current coworker is a truly brilliant bootcamp guy. He's African American and decided to skip student loans and go direct for code bootcamp and for front end he's really good. But if you tested him over recent BSCS type of stuff you would be screening out a brilliant front end developer.
- aisofteng 10y agoIt never ceases to amaze me what situations people find a way to shoehorn -isms into. It's a job. It has an application process predicated upon demonstration of some base level of aptitude. Fulfill it or fuck off and apply somewhere else.
- prodigal_erik 10y agoI wouldn't hire a frontend-only guy instead of a qualified developer, for the same reason I wouldn't hire a guy who can only mount wall outlets instead of a qualified electrician. Everything he didn't care enough to learn is a risk.
- caconym_ 10y agoIf the homework assignment is at least somewhat related to the job (not CS esoterica, etc) then I can't really imagine a better way to measure the candidate's relevant programming skill, which is certainly not the only thing you're hiring for (if you're smart) but it's important and I don't really see how it reduces the "diversity" of the hiring pool in any undesirable way. Could you elaborate on your reasoning?
- wahnfrieden 10y agoPeople have children or other life situations that make it harder and less desirable on average to give up weekends and evenings for a homework assignment. It optimizes for people more willing and able to use their off-hours for work, which is not an even distribution across the population or even necessarily a desirable trait in candidates for that matter.
- caconym_ 10y agoAssuming the homework assignment is happening in the hiring phase after the initial screenings, I don't buy this. Getting to that point means it's time to show them why they should hire you, and it's going to take up your time whether you do it in person or "asynchronously". If they give you the opportunity to spend those couple of hours at home rather than at a whiteboard in their office, but you don't care enough to make the time, I don't know why they should care enough to hire you. If the "homework assignments" are just a scheme to get work done for free, or a competent engineer's time is not set aside to review them, then that's a different story. But as a fair test of programming ability, administered in good faith, I don't see the problem, and such a test is important.