9 ms·
I was paying upwards of $150 a month for heating in a tiny <400sqft studio in Boston at one point. $200 on one month. There was definitely something wrong with
by dheera 10y ago
I was paying upwards of $150 a month for heating in a tiny <400sqft studio in Boston at one point. $200 on one month. There was definitely something wrong with the meter readings, and pretty sure I was getting charged for someone else's electricity considering how little I was at home with the heater on. The utility company refused to investigate and would only threaten to send in debt collectors if I didn't pay up. My property manager only pointed me to the utility company. I tried complaining to DPU, but they didn't respond to e-mails, and I didn't have time for phone calls or mediating this mess, in general.
As much as I wanted to fight, as sad as it sounds my time was worth more than the money I'd get back by spending time on the phone arguing and escalating the issue at critical hours of the day. :-/
Moved to California, paying a much more reasonable utility bill, and glad I didn't have to deal with that again.
If there were a "deal-with-humans-as-a-service" business that took a 20% cut of any money I could get back in situations like this, I'd totally pay for it. I once had to argue for 2 hours on the phone with T-mobile about $250 in excess charges on my phone bill, and while got it all back after escalating it to a manager, I'd totally pay $50 for someone to deal with the 2 hours of phone calls for me.
- dmix 10y agoI got charged $600 for two months in Toronto during a cold winter a while back and calling Toronto Hydro got it reduced to the actual $300 it was supposed to be. So FWIW in my situation at least it was worth the effort to look into it. I was in an older (1980s) apartment building so I couldn't blame a singular meter, I'm not really sure how measurements are done in big buildings (maybe someone could explain?). I've heard that elsewhere in Ontario, Canada and in Toronto (two different companies) that overcharging is a big recurring issue. I wasn't given a good explanation about my one anecdotal case outside of an 'accounting error'. I just knew that it sounded far too high to be normal.
- klodolph 10y ago> I'm not really sure how measurements are done in big buildings (maybe someone could explain?). In most jurisdictions, your electricity must be metered separately if you are billed by the utility company. In my building, there is a room with a bank of electricity meters, one for each apartment. Next to it is a bank of gas meters.
- DaiPlusPlus 10y agoIs water different? I lived in a complex (of about 40x 2-3 storey buildings with ~12 apartments each) where they said the water bill was the building total divided by the number of apartments in the building. I wasn't complaining because it was so cheap, but I wondered if it was legal.
- cstejerean 10y agoIt's legal, and in that case you get a water bill from the apartment complex (or the management company) rather than from the utility company.
- dheera 10y agoMy lease in California has the water divided up like that; when I signed the lease it was specified as such. I guess the water is cheap enough that nobody really complains.
- MertsA 10y agoMore importantly there's just one base charge for the apartment complex instead of each unit getting a separate base charge.
- vxNsr 10y agoAs long as it's specified in your signed lease it's ok.
- lewiseason 10y ago> I'm not really sure how measurements are done in big buildings (maybe someone could explain?). Similar to klodolph - it's very common in the UK for each dwelling in a shared building to have its own supply, termination point and meter for both electricity and gas.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- buttcoinslol 10y agoIf you had electric baseboard heating it's possible those readings were accurate.
- dheera 10y agoI did have baseboard heating. But it was a very tiny single-room studio, and what I was paying was still out of whack for baseboard heating. There was also one month when I was out of town, had the heaters off, and was still getting a large bill.
- piotrkaminski 10y agoI believe https://getservice.com https://getservice.com is the "deal-with-humans-as-a-service" you're looking for, taking a 30% cut of recovered money. I haven't personally used them, though.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoOK, first I never expect to read "Moved to California, paying a much more reasonable utility bill.." :-) That said, it is very hard to argue with the power company. As the article points out you can have the meter sent to a special testing lab but if it works, well it you are out of luck. About 10 years ago a friend in the Santa Cruz mountains got a bill that was out of whack (and he was a EE) and the power company would not be budged, so he pulled his meter out of the socket for a month[1] (don't try this at home!) and still got billed for a bunch of power use. It turned out that someone had 'tapped' the power wires leading up to his house, and PG&E wasn't bothering to read his house meter, just looking at how much their transformer sent to the 'only' house up there. Whoops. One of the things I suspected, and then later proved, was that my 1st generation SunnyBoy inverters from SMA on my Solar system confused the smart meter when they installed it. It would not accurately read the power generated by the panels so was under reporting power generated. That got "fixed" when one of the inverters failed (unrelated, it was over 10 years old) and we replaced two 2500W inverters with a single 5500W inverter. The modern inverter and smart meter get along fine. [1] Since he lives in the mountains and outages were not infrequent he had a whole house generator powered by propane that he could use.
- sathackr 10y agoI'm curious as to the details of your friend's story. Maybe they do it differently in CA than FL, but I have never seen any device that measures "how much their transformer" sends installed in any normal situation. A more reasonable explanation would be that they were using "estimated" billing -- billing that is based on a few spot checks of the meter reading, but not a check every month. This is common in places that the electrical meter is not easily accessible, such as behind a gate or being guarded by a dog(or out in the mountains). In this case they would have extrapolated previous months to produce an estimated usage and billed on that. I have had direct experience with a local power company billing for a "demand"[1] rate that exceeded by >300% the actual capability of the transformer and wires to supply. If that amount had actually been consumed, the wires would have caught fire and/or the transformer would have failed, possibly spectacularly. After I pointed this out to them, they quietly refunded the amount without an explanation and assured me there were no other errors of this type. [1] https://www.talgov.com/you/you-account-plans-demand-billing.aspx https://www.talgov.com/you/you-account-plans-demand-billing....
- eitland 10y agoIf there were a "deal-with-humans-as-a-service" business that took a 20% cut of any money I could get back in situations like this, I'd totally pay for it. Just learned a couple of weeks ago from a friend of me that there is something like this in Norway. They only deal with technicalities around the invoicing, not actual usage but still claimed to maje a decent living by finding issues with invoices for 1/5 companies. (Oh, and I think they took 50%.)
- mtgx 10y agoSounds like a civil court issue? There's a good chance they'll fix it if you even threaten them with that.
- raverbashing 10y agoFor all those that are facing a similar issue 1 - shut down the incoming circuit breaker, see if the meter "stops spinning" (today it's a light that blinks). If it doesn't, call the electrical company 2 - Get the (heater power) x (time it stays on IN HOURS) = your consumption. Heating and electric showers usually make up the bulk of your consumption (unless you're into home baking or bitcoin mining but even then). Calculate that, see if it matcher what you're paying 3 - Weather proof your place. Find places where cold air seeps through, seal them. Keep doors and windows closed when using aircon.
- BillinghamJ 10y agoIn the UK: - make a complaint - ensure the company is recording it as a complaint officially - request that the company provides their "final response" - contact the Financial Ombudsman Service Normally mentioning the FOS is enough for all issues to be magically resolved by the supplier instantly, but if not, the FOS a will sort it out for you - free of charge. The reason companies "shit the bed" about FOS stuff is because they get charged a flat ~£600 if the FOS receives a valid complaint about them, regardless of merit. This is in addition to the compensation they pay you.
- jimnotgym 10y agoThis is true, make sure you say the words, 'I want this recorded as an official complaint', and ask for confirmation. All regulated industries will go the extra mile for this. I was once in a call centre were they had special complaint handlers for people who said the above words, so they could resolve it before the ombudsman hears!
- BillinghamJ 10y agoTechnically, any expression of dissatisfaction must be recorded as a complaint. Many/most companies do not seem to comply with this.
- chaostheory 10y agoIf you live in the SF Bay Area and you have PGE, you can opt out of a smart meter and go back to analog. The catch is that you have to pay $75 up front and $360 over 3 years; still worth it.
- euroclydon 10y agoMy brother owned a vacation condo in Reno. He didn't rent it out and only occupied it 10% of the year. He always had a big electric bill. After eight years, he found out the meters were cross wires with the next unit which was occupied full time. It would have cost him more in legal fees to do anything about it than he could have hoped to recoup.
- imjustsaying 10y agoJust assuming he lost $100 a month, after 8 years that's 9.6k. It seems like a lawyer could be had for much less.
- cmdrfred 10y agoStatute of limitations might come into play here.
- imjustsaying 10y agoI'm not sure if statute of limitations applies to civil cases. As far as I recall, you can try to sue for any reason at all, although you may not be successful.
- agumonkey 10y agoThe refusal to investigate is so common. It's doubly sad because when it is at the benefit of the other party, investigations are usually thorough. Should be an obligation to do business don't you think ?
- mythrwy 10y agoI got like a 800 bill one month for an apartment not much larger than you describe. Then close to that the next. Turned out they had routed the hot water from the heater under the foundation to the taps and there was a leak. They came and jackhammered up a section of floor and fixed it and apartment complex wound up crediting me for rent.
- Twirrim 10y agoPaul English, the co-founder of Kayak, founded a company to do just this, called "GetHuman": https://gethuman.com/ https://gethuman.com/ It gives you an option, they can guide you through stuff giving you specific steps they've learned from interacting with the companies in the past, or you can have them handle it for you, for a small charge.
- sly010 10y agoI once was on the phone for hours with Time Warner Cable about a $50 security deposit charged twice, that was a mistake on their side. Turns out I was paying someone elses bill! At the end I explained to the supervisor that I will keep calling back until they fix this, not because I don't have $50 to spare, but because this is their messup and it's a matter of principle. They put me on hold (for about an hour) until their technical team fixed up something on their billing system. It's a pain to do this, and most peoples time is worth more, but if noone does it, we will be (in fact we already are) living in a scam society, where everyone is making money on everyone else's lazyness to track things down. When you call in, you are doing good not only for yourself, but for the company as well as every other customer.
- dwringer 10y agoCounterpoint: They are analyzing call logs to determine how in the future to better mislead customers and avoid dealing with callers like yourself, so every time you call in you're hastening the advent of an even more oppressive system.