4 ms·
If a Rogowski Coil and Hall Effect sensors both give incorrect results - what did the researches use to measure the meters?
by ars 10y ago
If a Rogowski Coil and Hall Effect sensors both give incorrect results - what did the researches use to measure the meters?
- stagbeetle 10y agoAn oscilloscope.
- ars 10y agoAn oscilloscope is the display. I was asking what measures the current.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoA current shunt. There are modern energy monitoring ICs that sample voltage and current at high speed and accurately compute power and energy with switched reactive loads.
- zkms 10y agoper the article, a Dranetz Products made PowerXplorer PX5-400 http://www.dranetz.com/product-services/current-dranetz-products/powerxplorer-px5-400/ http://www.dranetz.com/product-services/current-dranetz-prod... here's the original paper http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.sci-hub.bz/document/7866234/?reload=true http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.sci-hub.bz/document/7866234/?relo...
- barrkel 10y agoThe headline deviations are measured with respect to an eletromechanical meter (the kind that predated smart meters, described as a Ferraris principle meter).
- mcshicks 10y agoA current probe. You might need more then one probe for instance you might have one current probe that was accurate at a lower current but could not measure the higher current, and a second probe for the high current. Then process the data using the appropriate instrument depending upon the current. I haven't done much w/ AC power measurements, but it's a common enough problem (large dynamic current range) for DC power measurements. Agilent (now Keysight) make instruments like the N6705B DC Power Analyzer that can sample a pretty high rates (like 10's of uSeconds) and be accurate at both uA range and 100's of mAs for dynamic current. I would imagine you could rig up something similar for AC power measurements.
- barrkel 10y agoYou may be interested in this earlier 2016 paper by the same authors: http://doc.utwente.nl/102016/1/Runaway_energy_Meters.pdf http://doc.utwente.nl/102016/1/Runaway_energy_Meters.pdf In this paper, it seems they were using an electromechanical meter (i.e. the analog style that predated digital) for reference because that's what consumers were using. This is measuring energy, obviously, not current.
- flapjackdan 10y agoThe static meters' readings are compared against a conventional electromechanical meter.
- rnhmjoj 10y agoFrom the paper: The registered energy of the static meters was measured using an Arduino microprocessor and optical sensors for detecting the pulses from the LED on the static meter fronts. The readings were verified using the liquid crystal display (LCD) reading on the meter. For example, the LCD displayed 18 kWh, and the Arduino measured 17902 Wh, while on another meter the display showed 7.43 kWh, and the Arduino measured 7430 Wh. A conventional electromechanical meter based on the Ferraris principle was used as reference, because consumers are also using this as reference.