4 ms·
> Another aspect is that many cool new things are happening > in languages other than Java - they have more interesting > tools (eg. Sinatra), and more intere
by mindcrime 17y ago
> Another aspect is that many cool new things are happening
> in languages other than Java - they have more interesting
> tools (eg. Sinatra), and more interesting energy in the
> community, because they attract those crazy, eager,
> young, passionate, enthusiastic early adopters.
Of all the comparisons I've heard, this is one I'd say I'm dubious about. There is still a LOT of activity in the Java space, and lots of cool and interesting tools and libraries continue to be written in Java.
Off the top of my head, I'd mention Lucene, Hadoop, Weka, Mahout, Tika, HornetQ, UIMA, GATE, Camel, Jackrabbit, DERI Pipes, etc., etc. This isn't too say that other languages don't also have lots of activity in tools and libraries and frameworks, but I think Java is still in pretty solid shape in this regard.
- KERMIT 17y agoMost of the projects you just listed are several years old, and some go back more than five years. That's not exactly "new" when it comes to computing.
- mindcrime 17y agoYeah, but they're all being actively developed, so I'm not sure how much it matters when the project was originated. And that was just "off the cuff" of stuff I use or am interested in. There's other stuff out there as well. Anyway, I'm not arguing that Java is the most active in this regard, just that this particular criticism - of all the ones one could level - is, in my humble opinion, relatively weak.
- KERMIT 17y agoDon't confuse "development" with "maintenance". They are very different things. We see most of those projects merely being maintained, not radically improved. True development is happening within the Haskell community, for instance, where they're taking concepts from various fields of mathematics and applying them to software development in ways that haven't really been done before. Most Java-based projects are merely reimplementing something that somebody else has already done, or they're making minor, incremental improvements to a well-aged piece of software.
- 10ren 17y ago5 years ago was probably Java's sweet spot, in terms of cycles being used to help the developer, while still giving adequate performance. It would be interesting to graph the average ages of the users of the popular languages; youth being a proxy for the (perceived) current best thing. When you're starting out, why wouldn't you choose that?