4 ms·
Exactly. High rent is an economic signal, saying "build more housing" or "move away". You have to listen to it, not fight it.
by paulddraper 10y ago
Exactly. High rent is an economic signal, saying "build more housing" or "move away".
You have to listen to it, not fight it.
- dilap 10y agobut non-city areas are cultural wastelands. theyve been hollowed out. does it really have to be the case that nice cities by the sea can only be the playground of the elite and the workaholic childless?
- knz 10y agoMany mid size urban areas (often away from the coasts) are having a small renaissance and have a thriving local culture. Rural areas aren't a cultural wasteland either. Urbanization had been a consistent pattern for centuries now - decreasing economic opportunity isn't anything new to rural areas.
- dilap 10y agofor sure i exaggerate. but still: look at hemingway, for example. he could work and live in new orleans, easily, with plenty of time left over to write. can you do that anymore? i dont think so. we've lost something.
- ghaff 10y agoNew Orleans isn't the best example. Costs have gone back up somewhat post-Katrina but 1BR rents are still close to $1K/month depending on location. New Orleans isn't a particularly expensive city, especially outside a few premium uptown locations.
- dilap 10y ago$1K a month is still essentially 100% of your income at minimum wage. But yeah, it's not as crazy as SF for sure.
- ghaff 10y ago>non-city areas are cultural wastelands That's quite the broad brush. Most desirable locations are pretty much by definition going to be expensive to live in. Well, some people like the sunbelt and it's less pricey than the coastal cities that people like. In any case, cities create their own culture. There's nothing unique to a handful of coastal areas that are in vogue with the tech crowd.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>does it really have to be the case that nice cities by the sea can only be the playground of the elite and the workaholic childless? Well, if those nice cities refuse to build enough housing for everyone, even though they have the land-area... yes.
- knz 10y agoIs the resistance to more high density housing in SFO just due to a NIMBY mentality? Building up seems like such an obvious solution and one that would only benefit the economy there - how much talent avoids moving to the Bay area due to the cost of housing and associated issues. Lack of jobs is another economic signal but our recent election has shown that voters have an expectation that they will be able to stay in their communities (an interesting contrast to centuries of increasing urbanization).
- vidarh 10y agoMany places building up would negate what made the people currently living there choose to move there. It's a tradeoff between the interests of those currently living there and those who aspire to living there.
- knz 10y agoIs that unique to the bay area though? It's been a few years since I was there but to seem I recall some larger high rise buildings. Smaller apartment blocks (3 stories etc) doesn't have to come at the expense of the lifestyle either - the large European cities I've been to all had thriving neighborhood's , likewise with parts of larger US cities.
- vidarh 10y agoThe Bay Area is very diverse. What residents would object to varies accordingly. > Smaller apartment blocks (3 stories etc) doesn't have to come at the expense of the lifestyle either - the large European cities I've been to all had thriving neighborhood's , likewise with parts of larger US cities. Of course you can. That's not the issue. The issue is that in many of these areas the current residents largely do not want this because they don't want the character of the areas to change. It boils down to how much control you want existing residents to have over planning. This would be equally hard to change in most of Europe in places where you have geographically constrained areas full of wealthy owners that does not want the area to change too much.
- 10y ago
- gcb0 10y agoif ny or sf didn't have rent control it would now be a cultural wasteland just like the valley.
- dilap 10y agoi think you may be right, and it is trending that way anyway.
- vidarh 10y agoIt's also a signal saying "try to develop business clusters elsewhere" to government, and that's where it often falls apart - a large chunk of demand for housing follows job availability.
- paulddraper 10y agoGovernment doesn't normally develop businesses, but I agree. "Find cheaper employees elsewhere" is another message.
- vidarh 10y agoGovernment almost everywhere, including even places like the US, does however do things like provide tax incentives and subsidies or plan infrastructure improvements in order to shape where businesses choose to locate themselves.