6 ms·
The most common reason I've turned down very qualified candidates is that they didn't appear to want the job very badly, relative to other candidates, and didn'
by dahart 10y ago
The most common reason I've turned down very qualified candidates is that they didn't appear to want the job very badly, relative to other candidates, and didn't seem willing to extend much effort to appear interested in the job they were applying for.
Some very experienced applicants seem to assume their experience weighs so heavily that their chances of getting the job are better than anyone else's, and that there's nothing else they can do to get the job aside from fill out the form and show up for the interview.
I've had very experienced candidates come to an interview and complain about their current jobs, and complain about how stupid all the young inexperienced kids around them are. I love hiring experienced people, but that is a total turn-off, and an indicator that this person will not try to work with others, will not fit in, and generally will not perform well.
You mentioned that you hate your current job. So my question is whether you're knowingly or unknowingly communicating that during your interviews. Even if you're not saying it out loud, one's demeanor, body language, tone, excitement level, etc. can all expose someone who's unhappy doing what they're doing, and presenting yourself as unhappy being a PM is - in my experience - the worst thing you can do.
Some other ways experience can work against you include that your salary is at the high end so employers feel they can get equally good work for less money, and that your experience has hardened you in the operating procedures of other companies. Employers want to feel that you're open to adapting, willing to learn, and will go out of your way to shed any old dogma you have that doesn't fit, and adopt new dogma that benefits the new company. A PM job also involves a lot of rallying people, so you have to come off as a person who's able to tell a good story and convince others to do what you need and follow your lead.
Good luck to you, and please keep in mind that nobody here knows what's wrong. It could be you or could be racial or could be a bubble job market in the area you're applying... all of these things are absolute speculation. Your question doesn't have enough information for anyone to know.
- NumberCruncher 10y ago>> You mentioned that you hate your current job. So my question is whether you're knowingly or unknowingly communicating that during your interviews. I wanted to ask the same.
- navalsaini 10y agoI might need a job badly but I find it difficult to show that I need it badly. It just seems too much drama for me. I just hate these interviews - they are so much about pretending to so much better than you really are, etc etc... But I really don't have a solution to propose either. I just wish interviewers start registering in for different kinds of personalities.
- dahart 10y ago> I might need a job badly but I find it difficult to show that I need it badly. Okay, so there's a very fine line here. You don't want to show that you need it badly. You want to show that you want it badly. Need it badly would imply that the reason you're there is for the cash, and you don't care about the company you're applying for or the job you're going to do for them. Want it badly might likely imply that you're dying to do the job you're applying for, and you're dying to work for this particular company. A candidate who just needs a job and spends time communicating that they need a job badly is going to lower their chances. A candidate who wants the job badly spends time talking about the company they're applying for, and why that particular company is the place they want to be, and why that particular job is the job they want to do. > they are so much about pretending In my experience, pretending doesn't go very far. It's far better to be in a place of complete honesty about your skills and about your needs and wants. When you're honest, and you find the job you actually want, and you apply for that job, it will show and your chances will go up. I've been interviewing engineers for a couple of decades, and I can tell you it's fairly easy to spot people who are pretending about how good they are and how much they want the job, the entire process is designed to weed out pretenders.
- coldtea 10y ago>Want it badly might likely imply that you're dying to do the job you're applying for, and you're dying to work for this particular company. How about not asking people to be "dying" for the job, but just be professionals? Except if the target audience is starry eyed 20-year olds to exploit. When did merely having a good resume and being professional gone out of fashion?
- coldtea 10y ago>The most common reason I've turned down very qualified candidates is that they didn't appear to want the job very badly, relative to other candidates, and didn't seem willing to extend much effort to appear interested in the job they were applying for. So no ass-kissing, looking desperate or acting over-eager at working for some random company out of tens of thousands of other companies like it was a dream coming true?
- l_t 10y agoNobody said anything about that. The point is, even if you have experience, you can't phone it in during the interview. If you aren't likeable, many people won't want to hire you no matter how experienced you are. It's just basic psychology.
- coldtea 10y agoAsking that people should "appear to want to job very badly" (and on a later comment changed to suggest they should be "dying for the job") is not merely about not phoning it it, or not being likeable.
- l_t 10y agoWell, I think there is a semantic difference between saying that they "don't appear to want it very badly" and stating that they "should appear to want it very badly". If someone seems diffident, you might say they don't want the job very badly, right? But you wouldn't say that about someone who seemed excited about it. It's just an idiom. You have to show some interest, but you don't have to be desperate. About the "dying for the job" comment, though, I agree that is going too far. Personally, I think you should project a positive attitude about both your previous job, and about the possibility of working at the new place. But never act in a way that implies you aren't on equal footing with the interviewer. It should be a discussion, not a petition.
- dahart 10y agoI didn't change anything, that was a separate point in a separate sub-thread. And I didn't say everyone should be "dying for the job", I replied directly to a person who said "I need a job badly". I'm making the point that if you need the job badly, then it's better to say "I want the job badly" than to say "I need the job badly". It's better to act interested than to appear needy, given that you do want the job badly. I did not say that everyone everywhere should go around ass-kissing like crazy, you are going out of your way to take my words out of context here.