4 ms·
Remember when in the aftermath of Katrina, Paypal seized donations fundraised from Something Awful intended for the Red Cross for "fraud" and then refused to re
by paulmd 10y ago
Remember when in the aftermath of Katrina, Paypal seized donations fundraised from Something Awful intended for the Red Cross for "fraud" and then refused to release them even when everyone told them they knew full well what was going on? After they got called onto the mat they finally agreed to release the funds but only to one of their own selected list of charities, all of which had vastly greater overhead expenses. In the end Lowtax finally had to tell them to refund everyone and have them make individual donations instead.
Paypal is shit, the best thing you can hope is that you fly under the radar, because the horror stories are very real. They are not a bank, they are an unholy, unregulated "money transmitter" and if they choose to screw you there is nothing you can do about it. Have fun with your mandatory binding arbitration.
- facetube 10y agoAbsolutely. Paypal attempted to direct the funds to the United Way, a high-overhead charity that they had an existing relationship with. [1] 1: http://www.somethingawful.com/news/paypal-fiasco-summary/ http://www.somethingawful.com/news/paypal-fiasco-summary/
- nolok 10y agoFYI, Paypal is declared and regulated as a bank in the EU, declared in Luxembourg. So if something like this happens to you as an european, either sender or receiver, use your rights. > As of July 2007, PayPal provides localized versions of its service to customers in the EU through PayPal (Europe) S.A.R.L. et Cie, SCA., a wholly-owned subsidiary of PayPal that is licensed as a bank in Luxembourg. Whereas: > In the United States, PayPal is licensed as a money transmitter, on a state-by-state basis
- smartbit 10y ago@nolok what is the value of this regulation? Some recent/current examples. 1) During the banking crisis after 2007 EU banks loose 100billions of euro's and the taxpayer mostly payed for their losses. 2) They get 80billon euro's for free every month (quantitative easing) from the ECB which goes down the drain, iow into their profit, not into supporting the economy. 3) Up till the Greece crisis, Greece had to pay high interest rates to the commercial bank because of the risks associated with lending to Greece, but when the shit hit the fan, the commercial banks got their loans redeemed by the IMF/ECB instead of the banks having to write them off. 4) And more recent, N26 is regulated in Germany but had very flakey security https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-7969-shut_up_and_take_my_money https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-7969-shut_up_and_take_my_money. And I can go with al long list... I couldn't agree more that Paypal can not be trusted, in my vocabulary Paypal US stole the money from the designated charities. To say that Palpay is nice and good in Europe because they regulated by Luxemburg banking authorities, IMHO is far stretched.
- ptaipale 10y agoI don't think the parent said that Paypal is nice and good in Europe. It merely said that they might be under a stricter regulatory control in Europe, so unhappy customers have more tools available to keep them to account. [Edit/add]: However, American citizens have often stronger tools available in class action suites. EU countries trust the authorities, and it is then up to officials to control parties like Paypal. Do they do it? It's not necessarily very consistent.
- tokenizerrr 10y agoExcept class action lawsuits get you absolutely nothing unless you are a lawyer. Enjoy that voucher for a free pancake, only redeemable between 4.30 and 4.32 AM at a single restaurant.
- ptaipale 10y agoBut at least they can be started and participated by individual citizens.
- sedachv 10y agoAs an individual consumer you are very likely to shrug off small losses because of a company acting in bad faith and move on. It is not worth your time. The management of an individual company has a large incentive for acting in bad faith because the aggregate profits from ripping off many consumers can be large. Class-action lawsuits are expensive for the company being sued and act as an effective deterrent to bad behavior, and are one of the very few ways for consumer collective action under a capitalist system.
- pjc50 10y ago> 80billon euro's for free every month (quantitative easing) from the ECB which goes down the drain, iow into their profit, not into supporting the economy This is not how QE works and it is absolutely not free money.
- aleksandrm 10y agoPayPal is a nightmarish company. I've lost ~3000 USD to PayPal when I was doing small business back in early 2000s. Their "buyer first" policy had screwed us big time, even though we have provided all the documentation to contest the bogus claims. PayPal froze our money, and terrorized me for a whole year with collections agencies. It was awful. I am out of 3K dollars, and I have stopped using PayPal since.
- bbarn 10y agoOnly ~500 for me, but same deal. Fradulent buyers flat out lying and no amount of evidence on my side stopped them from trying to go to collections over it.
- partycoder 10y agoNotch (original Minecraft author) got $750k frozen by PayPal.
- jliptzin 10y agoSame here, about $2,000 they claim I owe them because they stupidly decided to refund money to an obvious scammer. Luckily I had already withdrawn the money. This happened when I was 15 and since then I am banned for life from Paypal - every time I tried opening up a new account they would eventually ban me. However during the last 15 years I have started multiple successful businesses and used alternatives like Stripe instead of Paypal and they are missing out on literally hundreds of thousands of dollars in fees.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoAt 15 you aren't allowed to have an account with PayPal and were technically defrauding them with a false birthday to get in. It isn't much of a stretch for them to ban you for that alone. Even if you were emancipated, it would be nearly impossible to prove that to a web business with no allowances for unusual circumstances.
- jliptzin 10y ago
- cronjobber 10y agoOn the other hand, it isn't entirely impossible that Paypal algorithms saw something about the Red Cross that looked like fraud. http://www.npr.org/2014/10/29/359365276/on-superstorm-sandy-anniversary-red-cross-under-scrutiny http://www.npr.org/2014/10/29/359365276/on-superstorm-sandy-...
- packetized 10y agoLiterally nothing in the PayPal algorithms could have foreseen something like the article you've linked, and to suggest so is exceedingly disingenuous.
- cronjobber 10y agoIt is likely that they didn't catch the linked problem, and I didn't intend to suggest so. What the linked article shows is that the Red Cross isn't beyond the suspicion that something they did wasn't that clealy above board that an algorithm couldn't possibly have been triggered.
- Lazare 10y agoThe algorithms was triggered before any attempt to send the funds anywhere was made, and without any knowledge of where the funds were going, and with the stated concern that they might not be going to a charity. Yes, we get it, it's ironic that the Red Cross didn't look so good either in the aftermath of Katrina, but this has literally nothing to do with Paypal or their algorithms.