6 ms·
It's easy to imagine engineers working on small parts of the system, and never really connecting the dots that the whole point is to evade law enforcement. I w
by mindcrime 10y ago
It's easy to imagine engineers working on small parts of the system, and never really connecting the dots that the whole point is to evade law enforcement.
I would volunteer to work on that project because its whole point is to evade law enforcement. A lot of us (hackers/technologists) take a pretty dim view of arbitrary State regulations and "laws" and are quite happy to work to evade them. Most people who fit the techno-libertarian or cypherpunk mentality would probably feel the same way.
- yannyu 10y agoBut wouldn't it bother those same people to think they're working for a Megacorp instead? Maybe I have a dim view of law enforcement, but wouldn't I also not want to work for Ares Macrotechnology?
- mindcrime 10y agoSome of them, yes. Depends on the Megacorp, I think. I mean, I work for a Megacorp now, while working on bootstrapping a startup on the side. But I don't think I'd work for Uber (not because of this though).
- jfoutz 10y agoBut you know that upfront. You can take appropriate precautions up front. If this is actually illegal, the poor engineers could be looking at conspiracy charges at least. You know the danger and you're doing it with your eyes open. They probably didn't know, and i'd bet Uber sacrifices a few engineers just like VW did.
- blackguardx 10y agoHow far does your scofflaw streak go? Is this different from adding law enforcement blocking controls to any illegal tech product? Should everyone get to decide what laws to follow? I think you are describing anarcho-capitalism, not libertarianism.
- Karunamon 10y agoShould everyone get to decide what laws to follow? You act as if they don't already. Society works pretty well anyways.
- blackguardx 10y agoTell that to the millions of Americans in prison. How did that work out for them?
- Karunamon 10y agoSociety > USA.
- jessaustin 10y agoThat example is supposed to inspire us to respect the law more? You need more practice at this rhetoric thing...
- blackguardx 10y agoI didn't say you had to respect it. Unjust laws should be changed. There is a process for that. It is fundamentally unfair to have one segment of society (tech workers) have a different set of rules than the rest. Do you disagree?
- odbol 10y agoThe process doesn't work as well as you think it does: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig
- hype7 10y agoYes, everyone should decide what laws to follow. Ask rosa parks or any poor soul unfortunate enough to be a citizen of nazi Germany.
- prewett 10y agoAre you also going to take the same generous view towards people evading State regulations and laws that you don't like? Because if you are only okay with people evading laws that you don't like, but they should obey the ones you do like, then you are setting yourself above the law. That way lies authoritarianism.
- DaUR 10y agoNot sure how civil disobedience leads to authoritarianism rather than the opposite. Also, by your reasoning, civil disobedience is never justified. And does Trump being President change your reasoning at all?
- pharrington 10y agoCivil disobedience works precisely by accepting the consequences of the law. This is the literal opposite of Uber's behavior.
- yestoallthat 10y agoDisobedience would be refusing to take part in such scummy schemes, and making a huge stink over it. > Civil disobedience is the active, professed refusal to obey certain laws PROFESSED. To twist that on this on its head, and use another sociopath to excuse it is hilarious. But since you ask: no, that's even MORE reason to not accept this bullshit.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoCivil disobedience is breaking the law one perceives as unjust (or refusing to follow it) to make a point about the legal system. It includes accepting the consequences of one's actions. What Uber does is garden variety illegal business practice. No societal benefit in mind, just money to be made.
- themaninthedark 10y agoSo then is the country clerk that refused to sign marriage certificates for gays a hero too? She was just practicing civil disobedience. Or perhaps she should just move very slowly when it comes to same sex couples, just never can get the work done. She isn't refusing it just never gets done.
- pharrington 10y agoAssuming you're against -arbitrary- people and entities operating above the law, how do you square that with the opinion in your comment? A broader point is that its 2017; we have a decent grasp of chaos theory. We know that self regulation in chaotic systems takes the form of hard to predict cycles of extreme variation. We know that stabilizing these systems requires external adjustments to parameters; some dampening here, a little increase there, etc. Personally, I've grown to quite enjoy being a part of an economy that has some measure of stability introduced to it.
- yestoallthat 10y ago> arbitrary State regulations They're way less arbitrary than Uber's action, so that's just projection. You want out of the social contract, be my guest.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe problem is once your professional ethics makes this ok, you start to slip further into the rabbit hole. That's how it becomes OK for a company to facilitate engineering managers to exert pressure where women either agree to have sex with them or suffer career consequences, using corporate institutions to do so. Hopefully most people around you don't feel that way -- your immaturity will ultimate catch up to you.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAnd here I thought that's just teenagers "who fit the techno-libertarian or cypherpunk mentality", and only until they finally grow up. The mindset you're describing is pretty self-centered and ignorant of how societies work. The law is there to reconcile conflicting interest so that people don't start using violence to pursue their goals. Techno-libertarian teenagers should imagine what would happen if some people they disagree with contracted that libertarian spirit. ETA: Announcing two new startups - Uber Biotech and Uber Medicare. Because what could possibly go wrong from arbitrarily avoiding regulations for the sake of profits.
- aantix 10y agoHow dare Rosa Parks defiantly take a seat at the front of the bus.. How could she be so self-centered and... adolescent?
- azernik 10y agoShe was not, as far as I understand, opposed to laws just because they are laws. She had very specific moral objections to very specific laws. Anti-racism != anarchism.
- aantix 10y agoUber is... Anarchy? Like in the movie Thunderdome? Sure. Their opposition wasn't arbitrary; they knew they could provide a better service outside the monopolistic constraints that were already in place. So they fought those battles and because of those battles, everyone gets to experience a much better ride service than the antiquated taxi system.
- azernik 10y agoNot uber in particular; the anarchism is in the mentality that "you want me to circumvent the law and avoid law enforcement? in principle, I'm in!" Which seemed to be the position mindcrime was taking.
- 10y ago
- sprafa 10y agoGrow up. You're defending destroying society so you can get what YOU think is right (based on how much it increases your net worth?). Did you similarly fight for the end of copyright? Did you join the pirate party? What about racial equality or gender equality ? Did you fight for those with the same fervor you propose to fight tor Ubers profits? For a company to replace a million others? that's all that's happening btw - one million small businesses are being replaced by one huge one, with a price advantage only because it erodes or destroyers worker protections. Get a grip. Under any reasonable government Uber would be destroyed tomorrow under the same argument as pirate bay or a torrent tracker - it's conductive to illegality.
- adamsea 10y agoWhat are your thoughts on food safety law? The 40-hour work week? Net neutrality (such as it is)? Also it's disingenuous to call laws "arbitray". Like them or not, many, if not most laws, are the opposite of arbitrary.