4 ms·
> This second mode of money is essentially private, running off an infrastructure collectively controlled by profit-seeking commercial banks and a host of priva
by smacktoward 10y ago
> This second mode of money is essentially private, running off an infrastructure collectively controlled by profit-seeking commercial banks and a host of private payment intermediaries – like Visa and Mastercard – that work with them. The data inscriptions in your bank account are not state money.
This raises a question in my mind which probably shows my ignorance of finance more than anything, but here goes:
Why not just have a public system of electronic transactions?
What I mean is, the current system of electronic transactions feels to me a lot like the way things were back in Ye Olden Days with cash. Cash didn't start out as state money, it started out as private money -- notes issued by individual banks, promising to pay the recipient in coin or specie on behalf of the bearer. (Which is why paper money is still referred to in some places as "bank notes.")
Which was fine for a long time, but as commerce got bigger and more widely distributed, it reached a point where it didn't scale anymore. Every note was only as dependable as the bank it was drawn on, and the farther away the transaction was from that bank the harder that reliability was to evaluate -- uncertainty which added risk to transactions. So governments started removing that uncertainty by organizing central banks and issuing their own notes, which became the paper currency we all know today.
Fast forward to now. We have modern cash, which has all the virtues the article cites; and we have a separate system of online payments which lacks those virtues, run by private companies who take a non-trivial piece of every transaction for themselves. Those drawbacks weren't too important when electronic payments were a new thing, because it wasn't clear then that they would ever be more than a niche product for the convenience of rich people. But now they're everywhere, and it seems inevitable that at some point they'll become the universal method of payment.
So why not do like we did with bank notes and cut out the middleman? Why not have electronic payments systems operated by governments, in the same way that they print currency? It seems like it could solve a lot the of problems with a cashless society at a stroke, and help the economy to boot by returning the percentage of each transaction that used to go to the banks back to productive circulation.
(The cynical part of me says that the reason is because the middlemen in this case are banks, and in the modern world banks tell governments what to do rather than the other way around.)
- colorint 10y agoYou say bank notes were redeemable for "coin or specie," but really that's state money. So state money precedes bank money. This was also a horrible system, because bank notes didn't have guaranteed parity (with each other or with state money) or guaranteed redemption. Also, the "final" clearing system for electronic transactions is public. In the US, it's called Fedwire, which is operated by the Federal Reserve which, despite various paranoid ramblings, is a public institution. The problem is, only reserve banks are allowed to have accounts with the central bank, which makes the system appear private. It's even trickier with credit cards, where you're basically asking a credit provider for a loan every time you swipe. So maybe the better question is, why isn't there a national depository bank of the United States? And then you can advance whatever answer you want for that one.