9 ms·
While I agree that cash is extremely convenient and largely anonymous, it is still much more of a hassle to manage than credit or debit cards are. I lived in NY
by nunez 10y ago
While I agree that cash is extremely convenient and largely anonymous, it is still much more of a hassle to manage than credit or debit cards are. I lived in NYC for a bunch of years and the one thing that I absolutely do not miss is paying for >$100 dinners, entirely in cash, because the restaurant was "too cheap" to handle processing and transaction fees.
- marak830 10y agoDid you mean less than? The processing fees part is throwing me off. I do agree though, in Japan I'm seeing a lot of credit or phone based transactions , I almost never carry cash now. Side note: my wallets last longer!
- nxc18 10y agoThere are business owners who for some reason think it is appropriate to stick their customers with that burden. Those business owners are customer hostile and are worthy of neither my business nor anyone else's.
- ISL 10y agoInteresting -- just got back from Japan, traveling in smaller communities. Almost all of our transactions were in cash.
- marak830 10y agoYes while travelling it's a huge cash based society here, but Tokyo/yokohama are really leaning towards cards/suica(the train ticket pre-charge card)/Edi(mobile phone payment system) and such.
- kalleboo 10y agoRestaurants and anything mom&pop will probably be cash-only, but pretty much anything that's a chain (big supermarkets, stores in malls with their own branded cards [includes JR train stations], etc) tends to support electronic payments. I find a lot of places may accept cards if you ask them, but they don't have card logo stickers anywhere or a prominent card reader.
- fjdlwlv 10y agoGreater than, makes paying in cash annoying
- the-dude 10y agoStart a business, discover the fees.
- pdkl95 10y ago> still much more of a hassle That's when everything works correctly. What about when the power goes out and the card reading device stops working? What about transaction denials due to bank mistakes (or predatory policies)? Having the option to pay with credit/etc is nice, but the failure modes can be nasty.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI've had the pleasure (?) of going on vacation without notifying the card company. Because a hotel was late with a correction to their charge, that showed the card in use at two places at once, so they shut it down. While I was on vacation. That got... uncomfortable. Fortunately, they only shut down my card. My wife's still worked, and we were able to proceed. It made for a more stressful vacation, though...
- ghaff 10y agoPro tip. Always carry a second credit card (from a different bank) when you travel. It's just too easy for anti-fraud systems to be triggered by something they don't like and to be in a situation where you're not really in a position to spend 30 minutes on the phone proving you are who you say you are. The systems can really trigger on random stuff too. After the last time when I gave them holy hell and threatened to pull my business, I haven't had trouble since. But before that, as someone who travels worldwide, I had transactions declined at 1.) a gas station convenience store and 2.) a grocery store in the Western US.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoThis is why I always have two bank accounts (with two different banks and two different ATM cards) and always have two credit cards, in case one bank account or one credit card gets shut down or skimmed it wouldn't be a big inconvenience. Especially helpful if you are going out of the country.
- ghaff 10y agoI've never gone so far as to have a second bank account. But I'm guessing a brokerage account could basically serve as the same thing.
- mrec 10y ago> it is still much more of a hassle to manage than credit or debit cards are I don't really get this. I use credit cards (almost entirely online), but I've never used a debit card. Not out of any deep-seated aversion, I just don't see the point.
- eric_the_read 10y agoThe appeal is largely that credit cards let you spend money you don't have, and debit cards, by definition, don't. For people who have a hard time operating within their budget with credit cards, this is a huge difference.
- jk563 10y agoWorth pointing out that this can be fuzzy, I have a £1600 overdraft facility that I can use with my debit card (I don't use it though).
- eric_the_read 10y agoTrue enough, but I hate those things. They tend to incur nasty fees when used on top of the overdraft itself, and then there's interest to be paid on the overdraft amount if not paid in full, etc., etc. If allowed, I will always disable them, and when not allowed, I will change banks to one that will allow it.
- jk563 10y agoI agree with the sentiment, though I'd argue they're getting better. For example the Nationwide FlexDirect current account[0] comes with a £1,200 overdraft limit that gets charged at 50p per day it's used. A vast improvement in my mind, I remember getting charged around £30 for going £2 overdrawn for less than 2 hours! [0] http://www.nationwide.co.uk/products/current-accounts/our-current-accounts/overview http://www.nationwide.co.uk/products/current-accounts/our-cu...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- phil21 10y ago> because the restaurant was "too cheap" to handle processing and transaction fees. I applaud businesses like this. The fact we slowly let a few giant private corporations enact a 1-3% fee against pratically the entire consumer economy would be ludicrous in any other situation. Plus the privacy concerns just are not worth the convenience. Whenever possible I use cash, simply so I slow the day coming where I can't function in society without having my entire spending history out there for any agency to decide to take a look at.
- maxerickson 10y agoI'm not a big fan of credit cards, but cash isn't free.
- dredmorbius 10y agoMoney is an information and accounting system. Regardless of how implemented, it has processing costs.
- jliptzin 10y agoThe bulk of that transaction fee gets rebated back to the consumer as points, cash back, etc. I only use 2% cash back cards.
- beambot 10y agoSo anyone who isn't creditworthy (ie. poor) pays additional tax in the form of higher-priced goods. But to heck with them for being poor, right, because you get the convenience and cash back?
- aianus 10y agoThat's not at all what creditworthiness is. You can be rich and have bad credit as easily as being poor and having good credit.
- 10y ago
- jjawssd 10y agoI assure you the reason they didn't accept anything but cash was not because they were cheap but because they could mix in and clean up dirty cash from their other clients for a fee without an audit trail.
- jrowley 10y agoAlso related, tax purposes, e.g. they can pay workers under the table.
- sotojuan 10y agoHeh, where I live in Brooklyn there are no places that take card for less than $20 (sometimes $10). It definitely required some adjusting.
- jk563 10y agoAnd yet I'm living in a village outside Leicester in the UK and I've paid <£0.50 on a card/using Android Pay on multiple occasions.
- ghaff 10y agoHistorically a lot of restaurants and retail establishments in the US had minimum charges for credit cards. My anecdata is that this is far less common today (Brooklyn notwithstanding). There's also just been this psychological shift that makes it generally OK in most places to put that $3 salad on a credit card. I'd never have done that 10 years ago. Now I routinely charge my lunch or a cup of coffee. I don't know how much of this is changes to credit card fee structures and how much is that it's just become a cost of doing business many merchants now feel they have to put up with.
- jk563 10y agoWe had that in the UK for a while too. It seemed that the big corps ended up absorbing the fee and then most others had to too. There's still the occasional merchant that has a minimum but I see less and less as time goes on. In theory, our interchange fees were reduced, but from what I saw it just resulted in most decent cashback schemes disappearing. This seems to have resulted in issuers making the same margin as they no longer pay out a part of it to the customer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mmagin 10y ago
- sametmax 10y agoWhich means your bank knows if you buy a sex doll, if you have diarrhea, if you are a member of a political party or if you donated to your cult. And I don't believe in the legal system enough to think that the information is not shared. Also, cash is one of society safety net. You see, nothing is black and white, and society is not perfect. If it can control everything, then the citizen has no margin, no grey zone to try things that the current society consider wrong. And this is a problem, because you can't make society evolve if you can't try what you want to change for first. Cash let a small part of society locally try things that are not (currently considered) right. Without it, you would soon have a static society. Another problem is that, because society is imperfect, it will create rules that in certain situation are bad for the people. Without a way to bypass the system at a local level, you are at the mercy of errors (not even talking about evil doing), with no short term solution. Without cash, if visa or bank x doesn't like you, you are screwed. Without cash, if you are doing something moral but illegal, you are screwed. Without cash, if you are doing something that society consider immoral (ex: going to a gay bar in a repressive country), you are screwed. Yes cash is abused, but a life without cash eventually would derive to something way worse : a rigid society.
- galago 10y agoIts probably both the fees and the taxes. They want to be able to choose what business activity to report.