3 ms·
Isn't bitcoin and other blockchains validated by "proof-of-work", meaning a nontrivial amount of energy is required to post something to this discussion forum?
by alkonaut 10y ago
Isn't bitcoin and other blockchains validated by "proof-of-work", meaning a nontrivial amount of energy is required to post something to this discussion forum?
I mean it's nearly indefensible to even add an energy overhead to financial transactions, but this...
- na85 10y agoNotwithstanding the bandwidth and storage costs associated with downloading an maintaining a multi-GB blockchain.
- logicallee 10y agoA quick note: I don't know what you think it means, but the word "notwithstanding" as a preposition means exactly "in spite of" or "despite" (even when it comes after the words it modifies.) It sounds like you're using it as "to say nothing of"...
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoRequiring proof of work to make forum posts could seriously cut down on spam.
- alkonaut 10y agoYeah. But the proof of I'm-Not-a-robot is usually a simpler captcha or image task. Preventing low quality posts by humans is probably easier with voting, flagging, minimum message lengths, minimum interval between posting etc.
- clarkmoody 10y ago> I mean it's nearly indefensible to even add an energy overhead to financial transactions Come on now. How much energy is devoted to securing the traditional financial system? I'm talking about buildings, personnel, armored vehicles, weapons, lawyers, courts, etc. Other blockchains are secured by different mechanisms than proof-of-work, and research is ongoing into more efficient ways of achieving distributed consensus.
- alkonaut 10y agoThat's a valid point - but it would certainly attractive to not require either of the two costs. Sounds encouraging that there is research in the field.
- runeks 10y agoBitcoin miners "mine on" the Merkle tree root hash of all the transactions in a block. Therefore, the amount of transaction data does not affect the amount of energy expanded. However, as block space is limited, actually using the Bitcoin blockchain as a discussion forum is prohibitively expensive, because miners only want to include the highest fee-transactions.