4 ms·
There is a minority of criminals who have serious mental problems and who are likely to commit crime again as soon as they are out. Are you confortable with tha
by ekianjo 10y ago
There is a minority of criminals who have serious mental problems and who are likely to commit crime again as soon as they are out. Are you confortable with that?
- jake314159 10y agoShouldn't someone with serious mental problems be in a hospital not a prison?
- praptak 10y agoObiously they should. The article hints at the sad reason they aren't: "...economical, not compassionate, reasons...". It's just cheaper to lock them up.
- soundwave106 10y agoHousing even non-solitary confinement prisoners is pretty expensive though. Average cost is about $30K a year per prisoner in the United States (http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/24/nyregion/citys-annual-cost-per-inmate-is-nearly-168000-study-says.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/24/nyregion/citys-annual-cost...). Some areas of course are way more expensive: In NYC, it's $168K per prisoner per year apparently. I think part of the issue here is that, in the past, mental health institutions itself had their own huge issues. There was a large movement to move away from mental health institutions, at least in the US, in the 1970s as a result (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation). The unfortunate consequence is that, instead of community-based mental health systems rising up to address the wrongs of the mental health institution, as envisioned by the de-institutionalization movement, the prison has ended up somewhat taken its place (https://thesocietypages.org/sociologylens/2012/07/03/deinstitutionalization-and-the-criminal-justice-system-an-unfortunate-correlation/ https://thesocietypages.org/sociologylens/2012/07/03/deinsti...).
- gozur88 10y ago>I think part of the issue here is that, in the past, mental health institutions itself had their own huge issues. There was a large movement to move away from mental health institutions, at least in the US, in the 1970s as a result (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deinstitutionalisation). There was a new generation of drugs people thought would end the need for institutions. I don't think they even considered the possibility people with mental illnesses would, in a state of mental soundness, decide not to take the drugs necessary to keep them there. There was also a bit too much optimism when it came to assessing the effectiveness of the drugs.
- venomsnake 10y agoIn Norway they don't have life sentence. But they are able to extend it if needed/deemed to be still dangerous. Brevik is not getting out ever.
- csydas 10y agoI think a corollary to adjusting and modernizing the penal process is also providing better support for those who need mental assistance. For many of these individuals, though they are dangerous, the current system basically dooms them to a life time of torture or being cast out into the streets. It's a vicious cycle since homelessness/the mentally disturbed are an issue everyone wants to go away, but not spend a lot of money on.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoCompletely. But pre-existing (or developed, since some don't turn up until one's 20's) mental health problems are a bit different now, aren't they? I'm not comfortable with these folks being in prison before they've had proper mental health care, honestly. Most folks with mental disorders are OK once they are stable with medication and sometimes need support to make sure they take such medication. We should more likely require by court order they stay their course and continue to receive proper help than try solitary first. This is how you treat the same folks as neighbors. If this fails, prison is still not the proper environment - a live-in mental health hospital is much more appropriate.
- ekianjo 10y ago> a live-in mental health hospital Much more expensive and there are much less investors for such facilities. So it's not going to be a solution anytime soon.
- kazagistar 10y agoRight, so let's torture the mentally ill patients to save a bit of tax money. Seems like the right solution.
- techthroway443 10y agoNah you're right, let's just make you pay for it all. Much better solution.
- kazagistar 10y agoIf you want to deny someone freedoms for whatevery reason, the least you can do is pay for it properly.
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoThere are less investors because it's not a growth sector, because America increasingly criminalizes mental illness, so the mentally unwell end up in jail far more often than in mental hospitals. It could easily be a solution if we switched away from a mass-incarceration, punishment above rehabilitation regime like in Norway as described towards the top of this thread.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI'd call into question whether such people should be punished at all, for what's arguably not their fault.
- amorphid 10y agoA not-trolling, serious question... If they shouldn't be punished, what would you recommend? I don't have a well-informed suggestion.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe way I see it, there are two aspects you want to balance: safety of the society and cost of ensuring that safety. When you have a person that commits crimes due to severe mental issues, you could observe that: - punishment won't work as a deterrent - punishment definitely won't work as resocialization tool - it's of questionable morality to blame a person for things they have no control over Applying punishment in such cases will cost money and make the criminal suffer, for no gain in the safety of the society. I.e. it's literally spending money just to mistreat someone. So what are the alternatives? If the condition is treatable, let's treat it instead. If the condition is not currently treatable, you can isolate the person from society - but this will already win you all the safety you can get, so there's no point in punishing them further. Of course the issue is complex, because most variables here have pretty blurry borders. -- Anyway; basically, I'm of the opinion that one should use methods effective for the purpose at hand. If your goal is to ensure safety of the society, punishing mentally ill people is not helping. On the other hand, if your goal is to give the society a sense of revenge, then by all means torture people - just be honest about what the real goal is.
- amorphid 10y agoThanks. It's gets interesting that when a person with a treatable condition doesn't want to be treated.
- Natsu 10y ago> If the condition is not currently treatable, you can isolate the person from society - but this will already win you all the safety you can get, so there's no point in punishing them further. We have to remember here that some prisoners are a danger even to their cellmates--I've heard of some who threatened to kill any cell mate, then did so. For that population of violent people who are a danger to everyone, isolating them could be both harmful to the prisoner, but the right move for society. Though I suppose it's an open question whether executing such prisoners would lead to less suffering.