4 ms·
This is a feature designed for enterprises. Imagine you had tens of thousands of machines in your company. A secondary processor that's hardened against virt
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
This is a feature designed for enterprises. Imagine you had tens of thousands of machines in your company. A secondary processor that's hardened against virtually all attacks running an independent operating system allows you to manage and audit those machines even if those machines have been compromised maliciously or just messed up accidentally.
- madez 10y agoIf that were the use-case then nothing speaks against giving full control to private customers over their chips or not including these features into chips for private customers, while neither of both is done.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoBoth would cost significant money and effort. The first would probably require replacing lots of purchased code with code that can be disclosed, and doing a full security audit of the remaining code. The second would require separate SKU's and validation for consumer vs business use. The first would benefit enterprises too by replacing the current "security by obscurity" scheme with auditable security, so that's where we should probably focus our lobbying.
- madez 10y agoI don't see how giving full control to the user requires significant money and effort. It is not necessary to release the full source code. Providing hardware documentation and a way to flash the firmware is enough. This shouldn't put AMD in front of significant problems.
- wolfgke 10y ago> If that were the use-case then nothing speaks against giving full control to private customers over their chips or not including these features into chips for private customers, while neither of both is done. This is (as far as I know) only one use-case. Another one (that makes Hollywood drool) is implementing DRM.
- joosters 10y agoAt some point (maybe already), the malware will catch up and infect these secondary OS/processors, leading to machines that are securely and permanently infected!
- pdkl95 10y ago> hardened against virtually all attacks Hardened? Have you tested it? This feature relies on obscurity for it's "security". > all attacks Also, stating that anything could be secure against "all" attacks is the kind of hubris that encourages complacency. > independent operating system That OS is monoculture[1], greatly increasing the utility of an exploit. > even if those machines have been compromised Only if you assume the builtin OS is magically secure. Intel/AMD have had many bugs in their products in the past. [1] really a small set of monocultures
- bryanlarsen 10y agoYup, should have included scare quotes around "virtually" and/or "hardened" to indicate that I was parroting marketing, not that I agreed.