5 ms·
"That commitment requires China to build and install 800 gigawatts to 1,000 gigawatts of new wind, solar, NUCLEAR, and other renewable energy generation facilit
by hutzlibu 10y ago
"That commitment requires China to build and install 800 gigawatts to 1,000 gigawatts of new wind, solar, NUCLEAR, and other renewable energy generation facilities by 2030"
Nuclear green and renewable?
But Ok, this sentence you can understand in another way but not together with:
"China has committed to build a renewables-only system that is equivalent to the entire U.S. electricity system by 2030. This nonfossil fuel target is the deepest hook in China’s Paris commitments. It is already creating massive demand for new clean energy technologies"
All talking about green, renewable energy and specifically in the context of the 1000 GW from before, what INCLUDES nuclear.
And even though I prefer (proper) nuclear plants over coal, I think you can't really put wind and solar energy together with nucleaer in the same bag and label it as green and renewable. So the article is either intentionally missleading, or dumb.
- youngtaff 10y agoSo Nuclear has it's own challenges but it's low carbon compared to coal, and oil (Yes, there's a huge stack of CO2 emitted during concrete production)
- TeMPOraL 10y agoRenewable? Sure, you can't. But just green energy? Any article that does not put nuclear in the green bag is misleading.
- hutzlibu 10y agoA technology, where you don't know yet, what to do with the highly toxic waste products and where you have a large area contaminated for a long time in case something goes really wrong, does not really qualify as "green energy" in my opinion. Still better than coal, yes. But not green. Especially not, if you consider this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_power_accidents_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_power_accident...
- spangry 10y agoThe RationalWiki page on nuclear waste disposal is surprisingly informative (and non-snarky, by RW standards): http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste As for the list of 'nuclear accidents', given all but one of the accidents listed have a fatality count of 0, I'm not sure what it is that alarms you. To be fair, the WHO projects a total of ~4000 deaths to occur as a result of Chernobyl (increased rate of cancer, using the linear no-threshold hypothesis). For Fukushima, the number seems likely to be either 'small' or 'none' based on WHO projections, although two TEPCO workers died at the time of the incident (they drowned, I believe) and a significantly larger number were killed as a result of the (perhaps overly cautious) evacuation of the surrounding populated areas.
- ptx 10y agoThe link says that "no solution is in use today" for the waste management problem and that it "can't go on forever" but on the upside it "may not be an intractable problem". That sure sounds safe and sustainable to me!
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThere are "no solutions in use today" partly because it really isn't that big of a problem now. Compared to all the other toxic industrial waste we generate, nuclear waste is minuscule in quantity and manageable. The worry is not about it killing you, or me, or our children, or our children's children. It's a worry about the waste killing someone 5000 years from now, after civilization already collapsed twice and humans are living in caves again.
- hutzlibu 10y agoSo because we argue against nuclear waste, means we like other toxic waste? And the worry is exactly that there will be no more humans in 5000 years, because someone in charge might decide Who cares, makes careless decisions, and in the end more groundwater gets contaminated and though not immeaditely killing everyone, but damaging the genes so to produce more retards, leading us in a nice downward spiral.
- aaron695 10y ago>Renewable? Sure, you can't. This silly if it runs out in a million years you can't call it renewable is just that, silly. As long as it lasts a 100 years it's renewable. If we don't have solar etc up and running by then we never will.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI was going to add that the present estimates of available nuclear fuel suggests we're pretty good for the next thousand years[0], but I didn't want to start an argument over the meaning of the term "renewable energy source", which would detract from the general point that nuclear is a viable and eco-friendly replacement for fossil fuels. [0] - https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_161.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_161.shtml
- hutzlibu 10y ago"As long as it lasts a 100 years it's renewable." Not really, a good option for now, yes, but not renewable, so nothing sustainable in the long run. Which is why I disagree to put it together with solar and wind, because as long as the sun shines, there will be energy. So yes: " If we don't have solar etc up and running by then we never will" Nuclear as transition and backup, but not propagate it as green and awesome. And with progress on medicine, many people on earth now can hope to live 100 more years. (or even 1000 years)
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBut it is both green and awesome. It's just isn't "renewable". Good for transition period, and should be enough to last until we finally crack fusion.
- hutzlibu 10y agoSo fusion in 20 years? I don't get it, why not just use the big fusion reactor right out there? There are plenty of deserts out there and enough storage technologies avaiable, which does not need a breakthrough. Improvements, yes, but renewable technology is allready good as it is.