3 ms·
I really wish they'd publish more of the limitations as well in the paper. I wonder how much of it got cut out in editing. Publishing limitations and negative
by djsumdog 10y ago
I really wish they'd publish more of the limitations as well in the paper. I wonder how much of it got cut out in editing.
Publishing limitations and negative results that lead to dead ends can help other scientists when they attempt to replicate and improve on tech like this.
- philipkglass 10y agoI agree that publishing negative results would help the whole enterprise of science, but the prisoner's dilemma is pretty clear. I would guess that the authors have been "trained" well enough by publication incentives that they didn't bother to highlight limitations even in their original manuscript. That kind of information shows up in the paper only by absences and implication; it's only informal chats with peers where people talk honestly and thoroughly about the negative results and limitations of their approaches. It's a shame that scientific publication ended up this way. It's one of the reasons I left research to write software.